by Dan Neil of the Wall Street Journal, published two days ago, is a good commentary on why "ordinary" people will mostly be glad to use driverless cars, and regulators and insurers will be glad to nudge drivers to use them.
"As a mature, postindustrial society, the U.S. has in many ways topped out economically (population growth, consumption) compared with younger competitors on the world stage. Americans are learning hard lessons about the value of their work in a race-to-the-bottom global economy.
"The one brilliant part of the U.S. economic profile is productivity. It turns out, Americans are a little nutty when it comes to work.
"If autonomy were fully implemented today, there would be roughly 100 million Americans sitting in their cars and trucks tomorrow, by themselves, with time on their hands. It would be, from an economist's point of view, the Pennsylvania oil fields of man-hours, a beautiful gusher, a bonanza of reverie washing upon our shores."
The statement in the article submitted here from Sergey Brin "You can count on one hand the number of years until ordinary people can experience this" is an ambitious prediction, and I wonder what that suggests about the cost of the self-driving system, as fewer and fewer cars look affordable to many "ordinary people" these days. I would especially like to see self-driving cars introduced in this state as soon as possible, where I expect they will perform on the roads much better than the typical licensed human drivers here.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by stephengillie on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @03:47PM
(#4577608)
Really well written article. I'm enjoying the "self-driving digital divide" section. Who wants to start a group to retrofit older cars with self-driving tech?
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by uncoder0 on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @03:53PM
(#4577638)
This shouldn't be very hard and I plan on doing it once Google brings the sensors to mass production then I should be able to easily afford it. I already have the software too but I would much rather use Google's... Since mine is about five years old :p... I can't wait until I can get a Velodyne for <$20k
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by elchief on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @05:02PM
(#4578031)
Over time, driverless cars will become much cheaper, as they won't crash, so will not require heavy and expensive safety features, and can probably be made out of plastic instead of steel.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by freehunter on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @08:28PM
(#4578721)
At least here in the Midwest, deer and other animals pop onto the road suddenly. Even with robotic, split second reaction times completing the perfect action to avoid an accident, you're still going to have an accident. Children still run into the road. Things drop off trucks unexpectedly. Road conditions change extremely quickly as it rains in the winter then a gust of wind suddenly freezes the rain under your tires. Vehicle malfunctions still happen to cause a sudden blowout, loss of control, or accelerator/brake seize.
Cars may never crash into each other again due to driver error. Cars will still need to be safe for the passengers because crashes will still happen.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by jwoah12 on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @02:54PM
(#4577327)
By that logic, you could count to 100k on one hand in base10. If you count your fingers in binary, it would still be 5 years, it would just be expressed in writing as 101 instead of 5.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by rory096 on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @03:08PM
(#4577413)
Only if you have 10 possible positions you can place each finger in. The grandparent describes a method by which each finger denotes one binary digit. He even mentioned how it could be increased using knuckles to achieve higher bases.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by saberworks on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:21PM
(#4577804)
If you have a problem with your Google-branded self driving car, don't bother looking for a phone number to call or a dealer to talk to. Instead, you can visit their support forums, which may or may not be visited by a google employee in any given month, and your issue may or may not be read, and even if it is read, it may not be responded to. But you can definitely look through the google knowledge base which will helpfully describe how the self-driving car is supposed to work.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by smokey_the_bear on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @03:48PM
(#4577612)
My husband and I are expecting our first child very shortly. We were having a slightly worried conversation about how it would be teaching our son to drive, since we both grew up in the midwest where driving is a little more laidback. Then we remembered cars would drive themselves by then!
More seriously Brin is quoted "You can count on one hand the number of years until ordinary people can experience this." which is not equivalent to owning them, which I think the title baitingly implies.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by jentulman on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @03:19PM
(#4577468)
I'm trying to be optimistic that it will mean at least a few taxis or some form of public transport running in (probably tightly controlled and limited) inner city areas.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by stretchwithme on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:15PM
(#4577781)
Can it drive in the rain and at night? Can it stop when a dog runs across its path?
Before robotic cars are viable, we'll first need cars that prevent human drivers from causing an accident. If a car can't stop a human driver from crashing, how can it stop itself?
And if people were to see accident rates plummeting for new cars, they would have the confidence that robotic vehicles will be safe too.
We can test robotic safety before the first robotic car takes to the road.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by tomkarlo on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:37PM
(#4577897)
A robotic car can adjust to inclement conditions more effectively than a human will - not only can it use detection systems that are less hampered by rain than our vision, it also can adjust its driving to account for the change in braking distances, etc.
We already have cars today that can stop a human from crashing - there are cars that will automatically apply the brakes to avoid a collision (Volvo has one for pedestrians, Toyota for objects, some are in production), and can maintain a set distance to the car in front of them on a roadway (auto cruise control).
Those are both a form of automation / robotics, even if the car makers don't like to call it that.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by Qworg on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:55PM
(#4577993)
No, sorry, it can't. It comes down to sensor systems. The Google Car uses a Velodyne - and it is terrible in heavy rain, snow, or fog. It has radar, but that isn't accurate enough to allow driving.
The human eye is an amazing sensor, one we can't even get close to with our current technology.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by tomkarlo on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:59PM
(#4578009)
So you're taking the current state of the prototype, and projecting it out five-odd years to the capabilities of the final projection model? Google can make the sensors on the car better in each iteration, but our eyes aren't going to be changing.
The human eye is amazing, yes, but it has severe limitations relative to other types of sensors, which we have to compensate for with systems like headlights and street lamps. It's also backed by a recognition system that wasn't really ever designed to work at >20 MPH.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by VMG on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @06:36PM
(#4578384)
> The human eye is an amazing sensor, one we can't even get close to with our current technology.
It's a pretty bad sensor. We can only see certain wavelengths need corrective devices, have a blind spot and can only focus on a small part of our visual field.
And if the system gets tired and the sensors shut down.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by roc on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @03:07PM
(#4577412)
They could deliver a taxi service initially.
Given that the sensor tech is only theoretically going to become affordable as production ramps up, they may have to start there to keep pushing things forward.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by danboarder on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:07PM
(#4577738)
The idea of autonomous taxis has been a part of the conversation for some time, I recall this was one scenario when Google was lobbying in Nevada. (think self-driving taxis on the Las Vegas strip).
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by thematt on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:10PM
(#4577751)
HA! Yeah right. Look at the outrage that is coming just from Uber offering a service that is basically a comfortable taxi you can hail from your phone. Now imagine what the reaction is going to be when you tell them you want to eliminate the need for a driver altogether.
It'll inevitably happen, but there's a ton of legal battles that will need to be fought between now and then.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by roc on Thursday September 27, 2012 @04:37PM
(#4582759)
Medallion/contract holders would get to squeeze out the overhead costs of employing drivers and would no longer need to ensure/insure the drivers' personal safety. This sort of automation promises to increase their profits directly.
So long as this was pitched as a service for them as opposed to competing with them, I doubt they'd fight it.
The only place I think you'd see push-back, is where drivers are not medallion/contract-holders but have (union) contracts that protect their place as the vehicle operator. But that's far from universal.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by randomdata on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:11PM
(#4577759)
When autonomy started coming to agriculture equipment, it was provided by third-parties that used equipment that would integrate with equipment made by most manufacturers.
I personally do not see Google going in that direction, but it is an option to offer add-on systems for all cars. It doesn't necessarily need to be a partnership with anyone.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by dandrews on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @02:57PM
(#4577362)
It'll likely be another ten years after that before the Googlecars are trusted to drive by themselves. I'd love to be able to send my car down the road to pick up my Mom, but the government will probably want to have a responsible driver to oversee the automation. Baby steps.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by dtparr on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:10PM
(#4577755)
From the article you linked to:
"The regulations would allow vehicles to operate autonomously, but a licensed driver would still need to sit behind the wheel to serve as a backup operator in case of emergency."
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by Aloisius on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @06:30PM
(#4578363)
I will buy one. Maybe not the first year, but certainly after they've been out for five years.
I don't care if they can't drive in the snow, heavy rain or fog. As long as the car can tell when driving conditions are too difficult for it and pull over to let me take over, I'm happy because 99% of my driving time is in decent conditions.
Even if I drive to Tahoe in the winter and have to deal with driving perhaps as much as 75% of the time, I'll still take automation the other 25%.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by hnriot on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:09PM
(#4577748)
in the form of airport shuttles between terminals maybe. but as great at tech as Google are, they haven't even thought about the real world issues. Even something as simple as who the technology puts out of work. And aside from the hn community who aren't even all for this, I wonder if this is something that regular people even want. if they don't the economics wont work out. you need mass demand to drive down price, and i am not sure there is mass demand.
I bet the next quarter century will see this come to high end cars, not as self-driving, but as augmented safety, like a glorified cruise control that tracks other vehicles, intervenes when the driver is txting and fails to notice the cars in front are stopped, that kind of thing. Then very slowly the car will take on more and more of the role of driver and the cars the tech is installed in will eventually make its way down to the family Honda and computer augmented driving will be the norm. But that's probably mid century.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by jlgreco on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:12PM
(#4577764)
> "I bet the next quarter century will see this come to high end cars, not as self-driving, but as augmented safety, like a glorified cruise control that tracks other vehicles, intervenes when the driver is txting and fails to notice the cars in front are stopped, that kind of thing."
High end luxury cars already have exactly these things. I expect to see them trickle down to "regular" cars, as safety features in luxury cars usually do, rather soon.
In addition to AEBs, driver monitoring systems have been in high end cars for years, as have autonomous cruise control systems and lane departure warning systems.
Luxury cars are already so close to driving themselves, it is pretty wild.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by hnriot on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:26PM
(#4577832)
If you've ever driven the 880 you'll know that none of those trucks have anything like this, where staying in lane means very little to these drivers.
we don't have augmented vehicles yet, we have simple warning systems, there's no car that will slam the brakes on for you if you didn't already and the car in front is stopped. There's nothing that will steer you back into lane, the closest thing we have to augmented driving is the stupid self-parking mode on some cars for the parking challenged.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by ceejayoz on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:30PM
(#4577851)
"we don't have augmented vehicles yet, we have simple warning systems, there's no car that will slam the brakes on for you if you didn't already and the car in front is stopped. There's nothing that will steer you back into lane, the closest thing we have to augmented driving is the stupid self-parking mode on some cars for the parking challenged."
> Mercedes introduced Distronic in late 1998 on the S-class.[12] For 2006, Mercedes-Benz refined the Distronic system to completely halt the car if necessary (now called 'Distronic Plus' and offered on their E-Class and S-Class range of luxury sedans), a feature now also offered by Bosch as 'ACC plus' and available in the Audi Q7, the Audi Q5, 2009 Audi A6 and the new 2010 Audi A8. The Audi A4 is available with an older version of the ACC that does not stop the car completely. In an episode of Top Gear, Jeremy Clarkson[citation needed] demonstrated the effectiveness of the cruise control system in the S-class by coming to a complete halt from motorway speeds to a round-about and getting out, without touching the pedals.
> Jaguar began offering a system in 1999; BMW's Active Cruise Control system went on sale in 2000[citation needed] on the 7-series and later in 2007, added a system called Stop-and-Go system to the 5-series.[13] Volkswagen and Audi introduced their own systems in 2002[citation needed] through the radar manufacturer Autocruise.
> In the United States, Acura first introduced Adaptive Cruise Control (ACC) integrated with a Collision Mitigation Braking System (CMBS) in the late calendar year 2005 in the model year 2006 Acura RL as an optional feature.[14] ACC and CMBS also became available as optional features in the model year the 2010 Acura MDX[15][not in citation given] Mid Model Change (MMC) and the newly introduced model year 2010 Acura ZDX.[16]
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by mahyarm on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:55PM
(#4577990)
In the medium term, you can manage fleets of electric cars which would be cheaper that any gas powered taxi. Parking fees would also be reduced. It should be cheaper than owning a car personally since those companies can use economies of scale that no one person can.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by jlgreco on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @05:29PM
(#4578160)
It is interesting to consider what removing human drivers could do for insurance rates too. If the machines are shown to be safer statistically (the only sort of reality that insurance companies care about), then insurance companies will love them.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by VMG on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @06:33PM
(#4578371)
Doubtful - insurance is about pooling existential risk. The probability of an accident might be lower if a computer is driving, the possible damage might still be to much to handle without insurance.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by jlgreco on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @05:34PM
(#4578178)
One can dream...
Though after we eliminate the need for insurance we still need to eliminate the legal requirements too. As long as those are in place I suspect they'll do fine. I don't know how you would even approach that problem though, since it doesn't even become a problem until safety is well and truly solved.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary...
by Qworg on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:08PM
(#4577740)
Until they can solve the sensor issues, they won't be. Heavy rain, snow and fog are still damnably difficult for them to deal with in a reasonable fashion.
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000087239639044352490457765...
by Dan Neil of the Wall Street Journal, published two days ago, is a good commentary on why "ordinary" people will mostly be glad to use driverless cars, and regulators and insurers will be glad to nudge drivers to use them.
"As a mature, postindustrial society, the U.S. has in many ways topped out economically (population growth, consumption) compared with younger competitors on the world stage. Americans are learning hard lessons about the value of their work in a race-to-the-bottom global economy.
"The one brilliant part of the U.S. economic profile is productivity. It turns out, Americans are a little nutty when it comes to work.
"If autonomy were fully implemented today, there would be roughly 100 million Americans sitting in their cars and trucks tomorrow, by themselves, with time on their hands. It would be, from an economist's point of view, the Pennsylvania oil fields of man-hours, a beautiful gusher, a bonanza of reverie washing upon our shores."
The statement in the article submitted here from Sergey Brin "You can count on one hand the number of years until ordinary people can experience this" is an ambitious prediction, and I wonder what that suggests about the cost of the self-driving system, as fewer and fewer cars look affordable to many "ordinary people" these days. I would especially like to see self-driving cars introduced in this state as soon as possible, where I expect they will perform on the roads much better than the typical licensed human drivers here.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finger_binary
Cars may never crash into each other again due to driver error. Cars will still need to be safe for the passengers because crashes will still happen.
If you count in binary, that could be 31 years. More if you count on knuckles and not just entire fingers as on/off. :)
Google has good support (including phone support) for the services that you pay for.
And if you want to contact the teams without using the product forum, try using Google+; I've seen that teams are often very responsive on there.
More seriously Brin is quoted "You can count on one hand the number of years until ordinary people can experience this." which is not equivalent to owning them, which I think the title baitingly implies.
Before robotic cars are viable, we'll first need cars that prevent human drivers from causing an accident. If a car can't stop a human driver from crashing, how can it stop itself?
And if people were to see accident rates plummeting for new cars, they would have the confidence that robotic vehicles will be safe too.
We can test robotic safety before the first robotic car takes to the road.
We already have cars today that can stop a human from crashing - there are cars that will automatically apply the brakes to avoid a collision (Volvo has one for pedestrians, Toyota for objects, some are in production), and can maintain a set distance to the car in front of them on a roadway (auto cruise control).
Those are both a form of automation / robotics, even if the car makers don't like to call it that.
The human eye is an amazing sensor, one we can't even get close to with our current technology.
The human eye is amazing, yes, but it has severe limitations relative to other types of sensors, which we have to compensate for with systems like headlights and street lamps. It's also backed by a recognition system that wasn't really ever designed to work at >20 MPH.
It's a pretty bad sensor. We can only see certain wavelengths need corrective devices, have a blind spot and can only focus on a small part of our visual field.
And if the system gets tired and the sensors shut down.
At night: much better than a human who can only see visible light
Stop for a dog: no problem at all
You haven't addressed the real problems:
In the snow: lane markers disappear
False positives: a load of snow falling off the car in front of you, or a garbage bag flying across the road, can both cause the car to go paranoid.
It's still vastly better than ugly bags of mostly water
Volvo http://www.psfk.com/2012/05/volvo-driverless-cars-on-public-...
Mercedes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9-j0jXEGbGs
GM http://www.slashgear.com/the-driverless-cars-that-want-to-ru...
Given that the sensor tech is only theoretically going to become affordable as production ramps up, they may have to start there to keep pushing things forward.
This NY Times article from last year hints at the same: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/11/science/11drive.html
It'll inevitably happen, but there's a ton of legal battles that will need to be fought between now and then.
So long as this was pitched as a service for them as opposed to competing with them, I doubt they'd fight it.
The only place I think you'd see push-back, is where drivers are not medallion/contract-holders but have (union) contracts that protect their place as the vehicle operator. But that's far from universal.
I personally do not see Google going in that direction, but it is an option to offer add-on systems for all cars. It doesn't necessarily need to be a partnership with anyone.
"The regulations would allow vehicles to operate autonomously, but a licensed driver would still need to sit behind the wheel to serve as a backup operator in case of emergency."
It doesn't say great things about the reporting or fact checking here that they got the CEO of Google wrong in a publication entitled "Computerworld".
I don't care if they can't drive in the snow, heavy rain or fog. As long as the car can tell when driving conditions are too difficult for it and pull over to let me take over, I'm happy because 99% of my driving time is in decent conditions.
Even if I drive to Tahoe in the winter and have to deal with driving perhaps as much as 75% of the time, I'll still take automation the other 25%.
I bet the next quarter century will see this come to high end cars, not as self-driving, but as augmented safety, like a glorified cruise control that tracks other vehicles, intervenes when the driver is txting and fails to notice the cars in front are stopped, that kind of thing. Then very slowly the car will take on more and more of the role of driver and the cars the tech is installed in will eventually make its way down to the family Honda and computer augmented driving will be the norm. But that's probably mid century.
High end luxury cars already have exactly these things. I expect to see them trickle down to "regular" cars, as safety features in luxury cars usually do, rather soon.
In fact, there is already talk of requiring systems like AEB on certain classes of new vehicles: http://www.unece.org/press/pr2011/11trans_p10e.html
In addition to AEBs, driver monitoring systems have been in high end cars for years, as have autonomous cruise control systems and lane departure warning systems.
Luxury cars are already so close to driving themselves, it is pretty wild.
we don't have augmented vehicles yet, we have simple warning systems, there's no car that will slam the brakes on for you if you didn't already and the car in front is stopped. There's nothing that will steer you back into lane, the closest thing we have to augmented driving is the stupid self-parking mode on some cars for the parking challenged.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autonomous_cruise_control_syste...
> Mercedes introduced Distronic in late 1998 on the S-class.[12] For 2006, Mercedes-Benz refined the Distronic system to completely halt the car if necessary (now called 'Distronic Plus' and offered on their E-Class and S-Class range of luxury sedans), a feature now also offered by Bosch as 'ACC plus' and available in the Audi Q7, the Audi Q5, 2009 Audi A6 and the new 2010 Audi A8. The Audi A4 is available with an older version of the ACC that does not stop the car completely. In an episode of Top Gear, Jeremy Clarkson[citation needed] demonstrated the effectiveness of the cruise control system in the S-class by coming to a complete halt from motorway speeds to a round-about and getting out, without touching the pedals.
> Jaguar began offering a system in 1999; BMW's Active Cruise Control system went on sale in 2000[citation needed] on the 7-series and later in 2007, added a system called Stop-and-Go system to the 5-series.[13] Volkswagen and Audi introduced their own systems in 2002[citation needed] through the radar manufacturer Autocruise.
> In the United States, Acura first introduced Adaptive Cruise Control (ACC) integrated with a Collision Mitigation Braking System (CMBS) in the late calendar year 2005 in the model year 2006 Acura RL as an optional feature.[14] ACC and CMBS also became available as optional features in the model year the 2010 Acura MDX[15][not in citation given] Mid Model Change (MMC) and the newly introduced model year 2010 Acura ZDX.[16]
And yes, we do have augmented vehicles already. Autonomous cruise control, which is what you described, has been in cars for years: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autonomous_cruise_control_syste...
> "Full cruise control (able to bring the car to a complete stop):"
Your perspective on the automotive industry is a decade or more out of date.
Should early car manufacturers have considered the blacksmiths and horse farms they'd put out of work?
why would self-driven taxis be cheap? there's still the cost, the maintenance and the security issues.
Why constrained routes? They can drive on mountain roads in the dark.
Just say "I don't understand this, so I am against it"
Though after we eliminate the need for insurance we still need to eliminate the legal requirements too. As long as those are in place I suspect they'll do fine. I don't know how you would even approach that problem though, since it doesn't even become a problem until safety is well and truly solved.
edit: edited the wrong comment somehow.
Because robots don't expect to be paid. This effect has been observed in other industries.
Also there is a an additional seat available.
With self-driving cars (or buses), you can have completely dynamic routes for ride sharing optimization. Think Zipcars with carpooling.