News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary... by stretchwithme on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:15PM (#4577781)
Can it drive in the rain and at night? Can it stop when a dog runs across its path?

Before robotic cars are viable, we'll first need cars that prevent human drivers from causing an accident. If a car can't stop a human driver from crashing, how can it stop itself?

And if people were to see accident rates plummeting for new cars, they would have the confidence that robotic vehicles will be safe too.

We can test robotic safety before the first robotic car takes to the road.

Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary... by tomkarlo on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:37PM (#4577897)
A robotic car can adjust to inclement conditions more effectively than a human will - not only can it use detection systems that are less hampered by rain than our vision, it also can adjust its driving to account for the change in braking distances, etc.

We already have cars today that can stop a human from crashing - there are cars that will automatically apply the brakes to avoid a collision (Volvo has one for pedestrians, Toyota for objects, some are in production), and can maintain a set distance to the car in front of them on a roadway (auto cruise control).

Those are both a form of automation / robotics, even if the car makers don't like to call it that.

Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary... by Qworg on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:55PM (#4577993)
No, sorry, it can't. It comes down to sensor systems. The Google Car uses a Velodyne - and it is terrible in heavy rain, snow, or fog. It has radar, but that isn't accurate enough to allow driving.

The human eye is an amazing sensor, one we can't even get close to with our current technology.

Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary... by tomkarlo on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @04:59PM (#4578009)
So you're taking the current state of the prototype, and projecting it out five-odd years to the capabilities of the final projection model? Google can make the sensors on the car better in each iteration, but our eyes aren't going to be changing.

The human eye is amazing, yes, but it has severe limitations relative to other types of sensors, which we have to compensate for with systems like headlights and street lamps. It's also backed by a recognition system that wasn't really ever designed to work at >20 MPH.

Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary... by VMG on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @06:36PM (#4578384)
> The human eye is an amazing sensor, one we can't even get close to with our current technology.

It's a pretty bad sensor. We can only see certain wavelengths need corrective devices, have a blind spot and can only focus on a small part of our visual field.

And if the system gets tired and the sensors shut down.

Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary... by Aloisius on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @06:27PM (#4578354)
I'd still take a self-driving car even if it pulled over to the side of the road and forced me to drive in heavy rain, snow and fog.
Re:Google's self-driving cars will be available to 'ordinary... by danielweber on Wednesday September 26, 2012 @05:08PM (#4578058)
In the rain: pretty good

At night: much better than a human who can only see visible light

Stop for a dog: no problem at all

You haven't addressed the real problems:

In the snow: lane markers disappear

False positives: a load of snow falling off the car in front of you, or a garbage bag flying across the road, can both cause the car to go paranoid.

It's still vastly better than ugly bags of mostly water