News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kafka is Fast – I'll use Postgres by kragen on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @11:46AM (#45748426)
This sounded interesting to me, and it looks like the plan is to make Redpanda open-source at some point in the future, but there's no timeline: https://github.com/redpanda-data/redpanda/tree/dev/licenses
Re:Kafka is Fast – I'll use Postgres by PeterCorless on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @11:57AM (#45748605)
Correct. Redpanda is source-available.

When you have C++ code, the number of external folks who want to — and who can effectively, actively contribute to the code — drops considerably. Our "cousins in code," ScyllaDB last year announced they were moving to source-available because of the lack of OSS contributors:

> Moreover, we have been the single significant contributor of the source code. Our ecosystem tools have received a healthy amount of contributions, but not the core database. That makes sense. The ScyllaDB internal implementation is a C++, shard-per-core, future-promise code base that is extremely hard to understand and requires full-time devotion. Thus source-wise, in terms of the code, we operated as a full open-source-first project. However, in reality, we benefitted from this no more than as a source-available project.

Source: https://www.scylladb.com/2024/12/18/why-were-moving-to-a-sou...

People still want to get free utility of the source-available code. Less commonly they want be able to see the code to understand it and potentially troubleshoot it. Yet asking for active contribution is, for almost all, a bridge too far.

Re:Kafka is Fast – I'll use Postgres by zozbot234 on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @12:16PM (#45748928)
Note that prior to its license change ScyllaDB was using AGPL. This is a fully FLOSS license but may have been viewed nonetheless as somewhat unfriendly by potential outside contributors. The ScyllaDB license change was really more about not wanting to expend development effort on maintaining multiple versions of the code (AGPL licensed and fully proprietary), so they went for sort of a split-the-difference approach where the fully proprietary version was made source-available.
Re:Kafka is Fast – I'll use Postgres by cyphar on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @12:27PM (#45749132)
I think AGPL/Proprietary license split and eventual move to proprietary is just a slightly less overt way of the same "freeloader" argument. The intention of the original license was to make the software unpalatable to enterprises unless you buy the proprietary license, and one "benefit" of the move (at least for the bean counters) is that it stops even AGPL-friendly enterprises from being able to use the software freely.

(Personally, I have no issues with the AGPL and Stallman originally suggested this model to Qt IIRC, so I don't really mind the original split, but that is the modern intent of the strategy.)

Re:Kafka is Fast – I'll use Postgres by kragen on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @01:24PM (#45750093)
I think the intention of the original license was to make the software unpalatable to SaaS vendors who want to keep their changes proprietary, not unpalatable to enterprises in general.
Re:Kafka is Fast – I'll use Postgres by cyphar on Thursday October 30, 2025 @08:13PM (#45766967)
Rightly or wrongly, large companies are very averse to using AGPL software even if it would cause them very little additional burden to comply with the AGPL. Lots of projects use it cynically.

Again, I'm happy to use AGPL software, I just disagree that the intent here is that different to any of the other projects that switched to the proprietary BSL.

Re:Kafka is Fast – I'll use Postgres by kragen on Thursday October 30, 2025 @11:25PM (#45768051)
I haven't actually talked with Henry Poole about the subject, but I'm pretty sure that was not his intent when he wrote it.
Re:Kafka is Fast – I'll use Postgres by kragen on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @12:00PM (#45748644)
Right, open source is generally of benefit to users, not to the author, and users do get some of that benefit from being able to see the source. I wouldn't want to look at it myself, though, for legal reasons.
Re:Kafka is Fast – I'll use Postgres by cyphar on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @12:22PM (#45749024)
You are obviously free to choose to use a proprietary license, that's fine -- but the primary purpose of free licenses has very little to do with contributing code back upstream.

As a maintainer of several free software projects, there are lots of issues with how projects are structured and user expectations, but I struggle to see how proprietary licenses help with that issue (I can see -- though don't entirely buy -- the argument that they help with certain business models, but that's a completely different topic). To be honest, I have no interest in actively seeking out proprietary software, but I'm certainly in the minority on that one.

Re:Kafka is Fast – I'll use Postgres by rplnt on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @01:05PM (#45749777)
You can be open source and not take contributions. This argument doesn't make sense to me. Just stop doing the expensive part and keep the license as is.
Re:Kafka is Fast – I'll use Postgres by kragen on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @01:34PM (#45750265)
I think the argument is that, if they expected to receive high-quality contributions, then they'd be willing to take the risk of competitors using their software to compete with them, which an open-source license would allow. It usually doesn't work out that way; with a strong copyleft license, your competitors are just doing free R&D improving your own product, unless they can convince your customers that they know more about the product than the guys who wrote it in the first place. But that's usually the fear.

On the other hand, if they don't expect people outside their company to know C++ well enough to contribute usefully, they probably shouldn't expect people outside their company to be able to compete with them either.

Really, though, the reason to go open-source is because it benefits your customers, not because you get contributions, although you might. (This logic is unconvincing if you fear they'll stop being your customers, of course.)

Re:Kafka is Fast – I'll use Postgres by zX41ZdbW on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @02:54PM (#45751365)
The statement is untrue. For example, ClickHouse is in C++, and it has thousands of contributors with hundreds of external contributors every month.
Re:Kafka is Fast – I'll use Postgres by kragen on Thursday October 30, 2025 @03:28AM (#45757302)
I think it's reasonably common for accepting external contributions to an open-source project to be more trouble than it's worth, just because most programmers aren't very good.
Re:Kafka is Fast – I'll use Postgres by zX41ZdbW on Tuesday November 04, 2025 @04:09PM (#45815913)
I often use a different approach - assume by default that external contributors are smarter than our employees. This is needed to prevent arrogance and entitlement during code reviews. A reasonable pull request from an external contributor is more valuable than one from an employee.