News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kafka is Fast – I'll use Postgres by zozbot234 on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @12:16PM (#45748928)
Note that prior to its license change ScyllaDB was using AGPL. This is a fully FLOSS license but may have been viewed nonetheless as somewhat unfriendly by potential outside contributors. The ScyllaDB license change was really more about not wanting to expend development effort on maintaining multiple versions of the code (AGPL licensed and fully proprietary), so they went for sort of a split-the-difference approach where the fully proprietary version was made source-available.
Re:Kafka is Fast – I'll use Postgres by cyphar on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @12:27PM (#45749132)
I think AGPL/Proprietary license split and eventual move to proprietary is just a slightly less overt way of the same "freeloader" argument. The intention of the original license was to make the software unpalatable to enterprises unless you buy the proprietary license, and one "benefit" of the move (at least for the bean counters) is that it stops even AGPL-friendly enterprises from being able to use the software freely.

(Personally, I have no issues with the AGPL and Stallman originally suggested this model to Qt IIRC, so I don't really mind the original split, but that is the modern intent of the strategy.)

Re:Kafka is Fast – I'll use Postgres by kragen on Wednesday October 29, 2025 @01:24PM (#45750093)
I think the intention of the original license was to make the software unpalatable to SaaS vendors who want to keep their changes proprietary, not unpalatable to enterprises in general.
Re:Kafka is Fast – I'll use Postgres by cyphar on Thursday October 30, 2025 @08:13PM (#45766967)
Rightly or wrongly, large companies are very averse to using AGPL software even if it would cause them very little additional burden to comply with the AGPL. Lots of projects use it cynically.

Again, I'm happy to use AGPL software, I just disagree that the intent here is that different to any of the other projects that switched to the proprietary BSL.

Re:Kafka is Fast – I'll use Postgres by kragen on Thursday October 30, 2025 @11:25PM (#45768051)
I haven't actually talked with Henry Poole about the subject, but I'm pretty sure that was not his intent when he wrote it.