News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by waterlesscloud on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @12:28AM (#4568569)
To play devil's advocate, can anyone provide a clear, concrete example of how it hurts science if the man in the street believes in creationism?

This doesn't seem like an issue that it makes rational sense to get up in arms about. It seems emotion-driven to me, ironically.

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by thaumaturgy on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @01:44AM (#4568811)
I think I can provide a strong argument for it. Will that be OK?

First, can we agree that creationism is a religious doctrine, and thus it's OK to frame this roughly as a debate over the role of religion in science? Because, within that frame, Greta Christina has already made a more articulate argument against religion than I could [1]. The short of her argument is that because religion requires belief in improvable things, that makes it "uniquely armored against criticism, questioning, and self- correction".

And what are some of the most basic principles of science? Criticism, questioning, and self-correction.

If the man on the street were to believe, say, that relativity was wrong, that the world was flat, and that it was actually supported on the back of a giant tortoise, what would that imply about their ability to reason on other topics? Is it wrong to conclude that, for example, they would believe similar fairy tales in fields like economics, politics, social justice, and environmentalism?

The one thing that all of those fields have in common, which makes them more vulnerable to religious principles than other fields of science, is that their support is controlled almost entirely by a democratic population.

So, if you have a large population which believes in creationism -- and therefore can easily ignore all of the overwhelming evidence for evolution in a field of concrete scientific study -- then you likely also will have a large population which believes that the country should close its borders and wage wars against people of other faiths.

The default response to such policies is to try to overwhelm it with facts. You say, "these economic policies haven't worked in X, Y, or Z countries in time periods A, B, or C" ... but the problem is that you're dealing with people who place no stock in things like facts.

(If you're jumping to argue that I'm wrong to draw this correlation, you should be prepared to handle the example of Romney and one of the most fact-challenged campaigns in the history of U.S. politics.)

I think there are lots of other good arguments too, like the fact that it's hard to attract the world's top scientific and engineering talent to a country full of crazy people, which means that you can probably kiss your industrial leadership goodbye. But, honestly, that's not my argument.

For me, widespread belief in creationism is bad for society because it's a gateway belief system to lots of other really bad things.

(Aside: it looks like I get to take up the mantle of Science Evangelist this evening on HN; how much the poorer HN is for it.)

[1]: http://www.alternet.org/print/story/143912/the_top_one_reaso... -- by the way, I am not at all a militant atheist. In fact, I don't even describe myself as an atheist any more due to the current religious-like fervor of New Atheism. I have no problem with people who hold religious beliefs. However, she makes a compelling point that is appropriate as a reference here.

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by patio11 on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @12:49AM (#4568630)
It seems emotion-driven to me, ironically.

It is entirely a signaling/tribalism question. For example, I get asked whether I'm a creationist on a fairly regular basis by people who a) are aware that I'm religious and b) want to figure out whether that means I should be on the Enemies List. I'm not creationist, so I get marked down as Whee You're A Fellow Scientist (TM). It is not obvious to me that my views on, e.g., the Resurrection would merit that conclusion, but that is not the issue the two tribes picked to wage ultimately meaningless squabbles over.

(Ironically, actual creationists have been pretty tolerant of me not being creationist. My guess is this is because I do not go out of my way to soulcrush them while screaming "I am a threat to your entire way of life.")

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by Shenglong on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @12:38AM (#4568599)
It hurts science because it's wrong. I'm not trying to be a jackass here, but believing in creationism is the same as saying "I believe acceleration at the Earth's surface is exactly 10 km/s^2 because it says so in the Bible." (it doesn't... I hope)

It discourages scientific criticism of ideas. When you are taught a scientific fact or theory, you are always welcomed to, and often encouraged to question it. "Why is acceleration 9.81m/s^2? How do I know that it is true as of right now? If I carry out my own experiment, will I see this?" When you listen to the "word of god", this is no longer the case. You know it's right because someone, thousands of years ago, apparently said it is.

Yes, it can waste tax dollars - but we can always make more dollars. An innovative generation that can carry on mankind's survival? That's a little more important.

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by siglesias on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @12:50AM (#4568637)
I wouldn't go quite that far. A belief in a creator can be tempered with rationality. Let's not forget that Newton, for example, devoted more of his writings to Christianity than he did to science and in fact sought natural laws because he believed that God would create a universe that behaved like clockwork. Einstein's intuition that a simple solution existed to the Michaelson-Morely paradox also derived in part from some kind of unempirical preconception about how "God" (his was impersonal) operated the universe.
Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by thaumaturgy on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @03:11AM (#4569060)
Let us also not forget that people are largely the products of their society. Would Newton have been devoutly Christian if he were born in Sweden in 2012?
Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by waterlesscloud on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @12:46AM (#4568623)
How many discoveries in the past (and even in the present) were made by people who believed in Creationism?

Why didn't that belief stop them from advancing science?

Why would it now do so?

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by ako on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @01:05AM (#4568685)
Back ten, there wasn't a good scientific explanation for evolution. Now there is. Back then, believing in creationism, didn't mean rejecting science. These days, If you still believe in creationism, it means that you reject science.
Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by famoreira on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @01:10AM (#4568698)
This is a list of famous thinkers/scientists who were also christians. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Christian_thinkers_in_s...
Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by Alex3917 on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @01:52AM (#4568840)
Science has practically been a branch of Christianity for the last 1,000 years. It's only since Reagan that science has essentially been hijacked by new atheism and private industry.
Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by stephenhuey on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @01:14AM (#4568711)
The other people replying to you are making some good points. Your claim is not right, actually. Reporting that phenomena such as acceleration are different from what is measured would be wrong--that is true. But you cannot claim that scientists who doubt theories such as macroevolution and lean towards some form of creationism are as wrong as that. The reason is that you cannot observe who caused the big bang, how they brought all the universe into being, etc. Physics keeps yielding surprises, and so do other sciences, and our models are constantly adapted. To me, biological theories are fuzzier than some of the others, but I'll admit I have not studied it much. Dr. James Tour mentions the creation versus evolution debate on his website, and while he doesn't feel like either side can make a strong scientific case, he did tell me a few months ago that he doesn't think the leading evolutionary biologists understand the chemistry that they claim led to the formation of life. Dr. Tour isn't the only intelligent person making great strides in the natural sciences who believes that, either. You can believe he and other researchers are wrong to doubt macroevolution, but you should be careful about making strong claims you cannot back up, because they do not promote constructive debate.
Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by Shenglong on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @02:52AM (#4569007)
I'm actually not following your logic. We'll never be able to prove everything in this world, but the important distinction here is the quest for knowledge--an answer. Even those scientists who may not fully understand the chemistry behind the creation of life, they are making strides towards it. They are trying to find a justifiable answer.

Unless you count prayer as an attempt to further an understanding of the world through Creationism, I'd say my post was right on the money.

Science is moving forward, creationism is not. Regardless of which is right or which is more justifiable, it's not even debatable, which one promotes the pursuit of knowledge.

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by stephenhuey on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @11:28AM (#4570838)
Scientists who believe in a deity are not necessarily bumping into contradictions to their faith. Plenty consider theistic evolution to be a possibility. A deity actually makes a lot of the problems with our current theories much easier. It is actually possible to analyze all that can be observed and still be left with questions, and reserve the possibility that a deity is involved. You don't have to believe that, and I'm actually all for science education based on questioning and reasoning rather than forcing dogma down students' throats, but you shouldn't just assume that all creationists reason in the same ways and blatantly claim none of them advance scientific knowledge.
Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by Shenglong on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @05:58PM (#4572909)
This isn't a mathematical theorem, and you can't use anecdotes to disprove a claim. I am not claiming that creationists in general do not advance scientific knowledge - I am claiming that creationism as a whole does not aid in advancing scientific knowledge.

Can a creationist benefit scientific knowledge? Will a person benefit scientific knowledge more by choosing creationism over evolution? I doubt it, at least in a general case.

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by ChuckMcM on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @12:53AM (#4568646)
I believe it is more nuanced than that, if you understand how science works, then you cannot believe a literal interpretation of genesis, thus if you do believe in a an earth that is less than 10,000 years old and humans appearing 10,000 years ago, then you didn't learn science correctly.

Then based on that reasoning, (and this is the nuanced part), you may find your self opposed to things which are based on scientific investigation and a risk to the community. The most popular example is vaccination risks and benefits.

One of the problems is that people are told that to believe in science means you cannot believe in God, and they have a strong belief in God so of the two they toss science rather than God out of their life. Its a poor choice.

EDIT: I, like patio11 apparently, believe in both God and science. So its possible :-).

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by patio11 on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @12:59AM (#4568665)
Observe: you have constructed a tribe out of whole cloth, described them as The Other, and made anyone who carries an arbitrary signifier of membership into that tribe into your automatic enemy.

Rationally speaking, if you're very vexed about vaccinations, you should ask whether someone is in favor of vaccinations, rather than attempting to guess their opinion on vaccinations by asking something orthogonal. If someone is opposed to vaccinations, it matters to you little whether that is because they're in the Tribe of UnScience (as evidenced by being biblical literalists) or if they're, e.g., against vaccinations because they're strict vegans and morally opposed to anything which might, at any point, involve an animal protein.

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by ChuckMcM on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @01:13AM (#4568707)
Fair point, attempting to respond to the parent question which was specifically "How it hurts science." My claim is that science is at its heart reasoned debate, and that belief in creationism is a rejection of reasoned debate, so it hurts science's ability to inform.

Typically a counter example in creationism is to question dating methods, but without any reasoning as to how the dating methods are inaccurate (beyond the inaccuracies recognized by the community). Your counter example of animal proteins based on a preference for Veganism is fine, but if I showed you that the vaccination process never came close to an animal protein would you still reject it? And in rejecting it would you reject the entire herd immunity thesis or are you limiting to rejecting a belief in the efficacy of the vaccine on your personal health?

Understanding reasoned debate is critical to understanding science and the process by which it comes to hold its beliefs. If you reject that then you both reject learning something new and the ability of science to be strengthened by your doubts.

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by derleth on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @01:08AM (#4568693)
> believe in both God and science.

You're using the word 'believe' in two different ways here, I hope.

'Belief' in science means 'I have seen the evidence and it convinces me' or else you don't know how science works.

'Belief' in God means 'I believe because it is absurd' or similar; that's how religion works.

I really hate how the same word can have two completely opposite meanings like that.

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by ChuckMcM on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @01:23AM (#4568745)
This threatens to de-rail the discussion and so I'll keep it short, the confusion here is between "God" and "Religion", in my world view God is a concept and Religion is a system of exploiting that concept for gain.

I'll claim that you can believe in the existence of God and not be Religious, and you can be Religious and not believe in the existence of God. The error is inferring one from the other.

You need look no further than the example that the Jewish, Muslim, Christian, and Mormon Religions all have the same 'God' at their center, but very different rules for their members. Christians have Protestant/Catholic schisms, Muslims Shia/Sunni schisms, etc. So it is always risky to conclude that a belief in God conveys a particular religious alignment, it may mean a particular alignment but it may easily not mean that. There is no dependency requirement to be met.

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by Alex3917 on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @02:02AM (#4568877)
"I'll claim that you can believe in the existence of God and not be Religious"

I would disagree with this, on the grounds that the definition of religion basically pertains to your beliefs about the origins of the universe.

That being said, you can believe in god and be an atheist. (E.g. Einstein fell into the category for much of his life.)

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by thaumaturgy on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @02:57AM (#4569029)
Er, no, you cannot, by definition.

Einstein is a popular example cited by both sides because he's become the very caricature of a scientist, and because he said things which satisfies many religious views.

I own a copy of The Quotable Einstein, and that book has several nice qualities: it is short (and easy to browse); it is organized by subject; and within each subject, the quotes are organized chronologically.

So it is easy for me to see that Einstein's views on God and religion changed throughout his life, and as he became older, he left his belief in a personal God and moved towards a belief system where "God" merely referred to the intrinsic beauty of what Einstein saw as the laws that govern the universe.

For example, in 1915: "Why do you write to me, 'God should punish the English'? I have no close connection to either one or the other. I see only with deep regret that God punishes so many of His children for their numerous stupidities, for which only He Himself can be held responsible; in my opinion, only His nonexistence could excuse Him." (In a letter to Edgar Meyer, a Swiss colleague. Note that here Einstein is not actually claiming a lack of belief in such a deity -- yet.)

In 1930: "I cannot conceive of a God who rewards and punishes his creatures, or has a will of the kind that we experience in ourselves. Neither can I nor would I want to conceive of an individual who survives his physical death; let feeble souls, from fear or absurd egoism, cherish such thoughts." (From "What I believe".)

In 1952: "My feeling is religious insofar as I am imbued with the consciousness of the insufficiency of the human mind to understand more deeply the harmony of the Universe which we try to formulate as 'laws of nature'."

In 1953: "To assume the existence of an unperceivable being ... does not facilitate understanding the orderliness we find in the perceivable world."

In 1955: "I have never imputed to Nature a purpose or a goal, or anything that could be understood as anthropomorphic. What I see in Nature is a magnificent structure that we can comprehend only very imperfectly, and that must fill a thinking person with a feeling of humility. This is a genuinely religious feeling that has nothing to do with mysticism."

People who say that Einstein "believed in God" should read more of what he wrote. :-)

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by Alex3917 on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @08:50AM (#4570045)
"Er, no, you cannot, by definition."

Theism is belief in a personal god. So if you believe in god but not a personal god then you are an atheist.

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by thaumaturgy on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @09:40AM (#4570251)
No, that is wrong. "Atheism is the view that there is no God." -- Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, http://www.iep.utm.edu/atheism/. Its definition matches every other one I have ever seen; I challenge you to find any reputable citation for the definition you're trying to use, and I dare you to tell any self-described atheist that they can believe in god and still be an atheist so long as it isn't a "personal" god.

You are maybe misunderstanding the definition of atheism due to the difference between theism and deism; however, atheism by definition is a rejection of both.

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by Alex3917 on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @11:10AM (#4570744)
From the link you posted:

"Atheism is the view that there is no God. Unless otherwise noted, this article will use the term “God” to describe the divine entity that is a central tenet of the major monotheistic religious traditions–Christianity, Islam, and Judaism."

From the Wikipedia article on atheism:

"Atheism is, in a broad sense, the rejection of belief in the existence of deities. In a narrower sense, atheism is specifically the position that there are no deities. Most inclusively, atheism is simply the absence of belief that any deities exist. Atheism is contrasted with theism, which in its most general form is the belief that at least one deity exists."

Now from the Wikipedia article on theism:

"Theism [...] conceives of God as personal, present and active in the governance and organization of the world and the universe. As such theism describes the classical conception of God that is found in Christianity, Judaism, Islam and some forms of Hinduism."

I don't have any a better source than Wikipedia, although you could check the footnotes, of which there are many. My basic claim though is that atheism doesn't just mean that you believe there is no god, it means that you believe there is no theistic god. (Hence the word.) Theism is the belief not that there is a god, but that there is a personal god.

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by thaumaturgy on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @07:56PM (#4573448)
You are reading that WP article as charitably towards your position as possible. You are ignoring your own quoted text about atheism being, "specifically the position that there are no deities", in favor of interpreting it as a perfect contrast to theism. The WP article for "deism" -- the term you should be using -- is just one click away from the article on theism.

Likewise, reading further down in the article I cited supports both your view and mine.

The very first paragraph of http://atheists.org/atheism is, "Atheism is the lack of belief in a deity, which implies that nothing exists but natural phenomena (matter), that thought is a property or function of matter, and that death irreversibly and totally terminates individual organic units. This definition means that there are no forces, phenomena, or entities which exist outside of or apart from physical nature, or which transcend nature, or are “super” natural, nor can there be. Humankind is on its own."

Reddit's atheism subreddit -- generally regarded as the largest online forum for atheists, so not exactly without repute -- has a FAQ (http://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/faq#Whatisatheism) which clearly states, "There is no inherent relationship between atheism and a religion. A person can be both atheist and religious, provided that he or she believes in a religion that does not have any deities, such as some forms of Buddhism."

I anonymously posted an excerpt of our conversation to that same subreddit, at http://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/10gt4a/so_apparentl.... It didn't get much attention, but the responses so far aren't really in your favor, either.

You keep finding really tiny bits of language in various articles to try to draw the conclusion that atheism only means a lack of belief in the Western ideal of a singular, personal God, even though you can't bring to bear any article which comes right out and clearly states that. But, I'm finding it difficult to find anything that clearly says your position is wrong (and some articles do kind of, sort of, almost support your position, given the sort of narrow interpretation you're using); I'm inclined to attribute that more to having never in my life read or heard atheism described the way you are trying to use it. It's a little like trying to find an article that specifically states, "God does not have a beard that is blue in color."

But, most importantly, you seem like a pretty nice guy, you've been around HN for even longer than I have, you seem otherwise perfectly reasonable, and as far as I can tell we've never fought before. Whether some guy on the internet believes that atheism includes beliefs in "impersonal deities" or not, or whether Einstein was an atheist or not, really doesn't matter to me, nor do I have the time or desire to continue arguing about it.

I am far more interested in public education continuing to teach the foundations of basic sciences, which is the only reason I got involved in this thread to begin with.

So rock on, brother.

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by Alex3917 on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @08:42PM (#4573610)
Fair enough. I'm actually not strongly committed to that position in any way, in fact my belief in that most comes from having read those two Wikipedia articles I linked to a few weeks ago.

Wikipedia could definitely be wrong, but honestly I don't think I'm interpreting it especially charitably. The article on Theism literally says, "Theism [...] conceives of God as personal, present and active in the governance and organization of the world and the universe. Theism describes the classical conception of God that is found in Christianity, Judaism, Islam and some forms of Hinduism. [...] Atheism is rejection of theism in the broadest sense of theism; i.e. the rejection of belief that there is even one deity."

When I read that something just clicked in my mind that you could both believe in god and be an atheist at the same time. I dunno if that's true, but you have to admit it's a great way to mess with people.

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by derleth on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @02:52PM (#4572004)
> My basic claim though is that atheism doesn't just mean that you believe there is no god, it means that you believe there is no theistic god.

As the term is actually used, atheism is the lack of faith in the supernatural. Look up 'dictionary atheist' on Google sometime.

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by derleth on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @02:22AM (#4568928)
To me, religion is a system of dogma. That is, a religion is a group of statements that cannot be challenged through evidence or logic (dogmas) that build on each other to form a worldview.

A god is a specific kind of dogma, namely a supernatural being that's worshiped, and it's true that not all religions have gods. All gods are attached to religions, though, by my definitions of the terms.

> So it is always risky to conclude that a belief in God conveys a particular religious alignment

This I agree with.

It's kind of derailing my main point, though, which is: Science does not have dogma. Everything in science is open to be challenged. (Ideally. Sometimes, however, individual scientists don't live up to the ideal, and dealing with them is also part of science.)

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by ChuckMcM on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @10:55AM (#4570650)
Ok, that helps me understand where we differ.

If I understand your statement correctly, you are classifying God as a kind of dogma, which makes the notion of God a sub-concept of religion.

Fair enough, I have the opposite relationship which is that God as an independent concept of religion. My claim was that since several religions share the same God, God is an independent variable.

One of the nice features of my taxonomy is that you can throw out the entire system of dogma for a given religion and still believe in God. This seems to be the underlying mechanism in a theological conversion as well.

I recognize that if you're understanding of God is entirely dictated though the teachings of a particular religion, that it can be difficult to reason about God independently of those teachings.

Not unlike trying to reason about how a computer's CPU works if your only exposure is through a single programming language. It is hard to know which constraints or features of the CPU are part of the architecture of the CPU and which are artifacts of the expressive power of the language.

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by AJ007 on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @12:48AM (#4568629)
As a child I went to private schools that taught creationism. I can't speak for how creationism is taught in other schools, but in the schools I attended it was nothing but a complete denial of science. It took me a while to figure that one out.

Science fits together. When you deny the existence of biological evolution, decide the earth is under 10,000 years old, and say there is no such thing as the big bang, you end up with huge gaps in the scientific explanation of the universe.

Once you do this, the world and the universe it sits in transforms from a place of logic and explainable order to one of superstition and chaos. If the earth is 10,000 years old, how is the Milky Way galaxy 100,000 light years in diameter? If there is no biological evolution, is genetic science a pseudo-science?

Creationism taught in others ways is little better.

This type of thinking destroys IQs.

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by Pkeod on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @12:38AM (#4568600)
Emotions are not in conflict with rational behavior; they cause rational behavior.

It hurts because it is not just one man out there who is willfully ignorant about reality. There are a very large number of people in the US who believe that the world is only 6,000 years old, that everything is going to end any day now, that the environment isn't really worth protecting because of that, and by extension that it's not really worth doing anything meaningful. The religious people still vote, and their votes shape our policy. If their churches tell them to vote one way, and they do, the authority of the religiously fueled motivations highly define the results.

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by gareim on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @12:41AM (#4568608)
Because sometimes the man in the street has an effect on others. Consider textbooks. Sometimes (like in Kansas 1999), creationists can control enough of the governing body for state textbooks that they can eliminate core ideas of evolution. I don't care what someone believes, but they shouldn't push unverifiable beliefs on impressionable kids.
Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by siglesias on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @12:34AM (#4568585)
Perhaps the idea that God gave us the planet to exploit for its resources and animals to treat however we want, thus we shouldn't care about overtaxing the oceans and gas supply, granting animals rights, or concern ourselves with global warming, which God wouldn't let happen.
Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by waterlesscloud on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @12:41AM (#4568610)
A lot of Christian churches actually support a type of environmentalism under the idea that God gave man stewardship over the earth, which comes with the responsibility to keep it up. It's His creation, after all (under this belief).
Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by siglesias on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @12:51AM (#4568642)
Undoubtedly. I didn't intend to generalize.
Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by scott_s on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @12:32AM (#4568581)
Because that man's taxes fund scientific research.
Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by cli on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @12:35AM (#4568591)
Also, that man has some say in the direction of science policy through his (congressman? representative? What is the correct US term?).
Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by jff on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @12:49AM (#4568634)
Both terms are correct, based on the 2-house model we have.
Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by derleth on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @01:16AM (#4568725)
> congressman? representative? What is the correct US term?

We have Senators in the Senate and Representatives in the House of Representatives; both can be called Congressmen or Congresswomen, but that term is more usually reserved for Representatives.

Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by davidism on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @12:35AM (#4568589)
The "man on the street" has a kid, a potential scientist. But instead of fostering curiosity about the way things work, instead of promoting the use of logic to understand his surroundings, the parent teaches the child "the Bible says so, and that's enough." Now we have one less potential scientist.
Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by kazoolist on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @01:09AM (#4568696)
... or the kid's parents believe in creation but don't fit some ignoramus stereotype, and the kid comes to believe that the creation reveals the glory of a Creator (eg. Psalm 19), and accordingly this fosters curiosity about the way things work, and the kid becomes a scientist.