News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bill Nye warns: Creation views threaten US science by ChuckMcM on Tuesday September 25, 2012 @10:55AM (#4570650)
Ok, that helps me understand where we differ.

If I understand your statement correctly, you are classifying God as a kind of dogma, which makes the notion of God a sub-concept of religion.

Fair enough, I have the opposite relationship which is that God as an independent concept of religion. My claim was that since several religions share the same God, God is an independent variable.

One of the nice features of my taxonomy is that you can throw out the entire system of dogma for a given religion and still believe in God. This seems to be the underlying mechanism in a theological conversion as well.

I recognize that if you're understanding of God is entirely dictated though the teachings of a particular religion, that it can be difficult to reason about God independently of those teachings.

Not unlike trying to reason about how a computer's CPU works if your only exposure is through a single programming language. It is hard to know which constraints or features of the CPU are part of the architecture of the CPU and which are artifacts of the expressive power of the language.

There are no comments on this comment yet.