News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by pols45 on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @10:16AM (#45592934)
Ah Jaysus! Ireland’s has been running "basic income schemes" since the 6th century. "Modernity" is just a bit blind to how it worked. What we are seeing now is the secular attempts at institutionalizing it.

What we now call "Pastoral Care" emerged out of the behavior of some Irish monks in the sixth century embedding themselves in local communities exchanging advice for free mead and shelter. They started writing books about its effectiveness.

And so it became institutionalized world wide. So they would send a bloke to Ballykissangel, pay him to sit there, listen to the villagers’ woes on Sundays, and spend the rest of the week in the pub providing cultural enrichment.

Most importantly no numbers and report were used to justify these programmes. And this is what Sociologists say is the problem with modernity.

Corporate wonderland and McDonalds has convinced the "educated" numbers are somehow magic. And its easy to break that spell. Just ask a Kid to come up with a business plan to run a McDonalds. Its a super simple exercise involving costs and expenses. After they do that, ask them to scale it up so McDonalds can feed the world. Once you learn the McDonalds model cannot feed the world, the only path forward (for people who care about these things and most don't) is coming up with models that aren't built on top of numbers. There is a big reason the Church has outlasted corporations and empires. And its not numbers and reports. Its pastoral care.

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by dkarl on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @11:53AM (#45594477)
> There is a big reason the Church has outlasted corporations and empires. And its not numbers and reports

Right, the Catholic Church doesn't pay any attention to its finances. It doesn't have regularly financial reports full of numbers that are carefully reviewed by several levels of leadership. It doesn't zealously protect its tax exemptions and press people for donations each week. It just kinda wings it and hopes the checks don't bounce, which they magically don't because the Church does good work in the world?

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by overfeed on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @09:42PM (#45600584)
"The is a reason Usain Bolt won, and it is not because he is tall" does not imply he is short/not tall. You're arguing against a statement gp did not make
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by collingreen on Thursday October 16, 2025 @02:44PM (#45609143)
Ggp didn't make much of a point at all, just implied that the church had longevity because it wasn't obsessed with numbers and money and instead just cared about listening to people, with the ancient example of once a week in exchange for board.

Gp then sarcastically pointed out that they are, in fact, extremely obsessed with numbers and money and asking for money and growing that money.

I don't want to speak for gp too much but when I read that I thought it did a great job of pointing out why the implied causality of the church longevity wasn't correct (or at the very least wasn't enough of the picture).

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by epiccoleman on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @11:37AM (#45594210)
> And so it became institutionalized world wide. So they would send a bloke to Ballykissangel, pay him to sit there, listen to the villagers’ woes on Sundays, and spend the rest of the week in the pub providing cultural enrichment.

Good lord, how do I get that job?

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by jdpage on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @11:40AM (#45594266)
Seminary, then becoming ordained as a priest, at the very least.
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by dyauspitr on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @11:47AM (#45594380)
Priests usually have to perform multiple masses a day, every day of the week.
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by jandrese on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @12:41PM (#45595179)
They really have Monday morning and Monday afternoon mass? Friday afternoon? This seems like a lot more activity than the Catholic churches that I know.
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by epiccoleman on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @01:08PM (#45595586)
Growing up, the Catholic church which my family attended, and to which our grade school was attached, held the following masses:

* Wednesday evening mass

* Thursday morning mass (this was attended by the school kids, as well as a collection of retirees)

* Saturday evening mass

* Sunday 7am mass

* Sunday 10am mass

There was also a weekly or maybe biweekly Confession.

That was serving quite a small congregation too, so I wouldn't be surprised to learn that bigger parishes have more frequent masses (although in my experience larger parishes often have more than one priest).

Also, the job of a Catholic priest is definitely not limited to performing Mass. They're essentially on call for Last Rites 24/7, but apart from that there's also just various parish events they'll be involved with.

So anyway, I don't want that job, I want the one where you give out vaguely mystical advice and listen to problems once a week, and then during the rest of the week you're like a cool side character at the local pub.

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by swat535 on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @03:44PM (#45597440)
> They really have Monday morning and Monday afternoon mass? Friday afternoon? This seems like a lot more activity than the Catholic churches that I know.

Yes! For Catholics, there are daily Masses (and the Priest performs them, even if no one shows up!) in addition there is all of the other services they perform: Baptisms, Confessions, etc.

Then there is pastoral administration tasks, writing Homilies, etc.. then you have many important months where additional work is required..

You also have all other programs that Church organizes, including charity works, various community groups, etc..

I can't speak for Protestants however, since I'm a Catholic but if there are any hanging around here, they can clarify.

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by devilbunny on Thursday October 16, 2025 @10:57AM (#45606185)
Protestant churches will vary, but I grew up in the American South, where religion is at least ostensibly important (and a major cultural fixture in the past, though less so today). Usually one or two morning services and some kind of Bible study in the evening on Sunday, and Wednesday nights usually had Bible studies and a sort of mini-service.

Other nights featured smaller study groups, athletic activities (a lot of casual adult sports like softball are organized by churches), or special events like musical performances, choir practice, etc. And then there's the daily pastoral care (officiating funerals, visiting the sick, etc.). But in the absence of Eucharist as a frequent component of worship, and where confession and last rites aren't even considered sacraments, there's little fundamentally different between a well-run Bible study and a full service except the scale. The actual things done aren't really different.

Note: Episcopal services would be much more familiar in structure to a Catholic mass, and I believe Lutherans are similar (but, y'know, not a ton of Lutherans in the South, so I can't speak with any authority on the matter).

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by michaelt on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @01:12PM (#45595639)
In some areas, with declining attendance and a reluctance to close any churches, many priests perform mass at multiple churches.

This is especially true in rural areas, where the density of churches was established in the pre-car era.

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by jandrese on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @01:15PM (#45595688)
How does that work? "Sorry this church is closed on Sunday, we hold mass on Monday instead because our priest is shared with a bigger church."?
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by HeWhoLurksLate on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @01:31PM (#45595896)
Could also do a 9AM mass at one church, a (9AM + mass duration + travel time + 30 minutes) mass at another, and so on
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by AlotOfReading on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @04:45PM (#45598200)
I spoke to a priest doing this when a family member passed. He'd perform the early Sunday service in town, then drive 1.5h to the next valley over and do a service there, then drive 45m to a third church before returning to the first for meetings and elderly care visits. Worse, each of these churches had different sermon schedules so he was preparing sermons customized to each on top of his other duties.
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by integralid on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @02:35PM (#45596694)
Probably depends on the region. In my country, the church i attended to had three masses during the week and i think 6 (back to back all day) during Sundays. This was only one of three churches within a walking distance, and the (mid-small) city probably had around 10-15.

Which is expected, since every adult was expected to go to church every Sunday, and many people, especially elderly, went during the week. Also there were four or five priests, and only Sunday masses has more than one attending at once, so the load probably wasn't that large as I make it sound.

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by bobthepanda on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @02:46PM (#45596809)
There are also regions where due to diversity of congregations, masses are held in multiple languages at the same church.
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by dyauspitr on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @02:46PM (#45596810)
Probably depends on the area. Where I am in North Carolina, the local Catholic Church has daily masses.
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by jdpage on Thursday October 16, 2025 @02:46PM (#45609168)
Oh, for sure, being a minister of any religion is a tough job that involves a lot more work than many people might assume. That's the role GP was clearly referring to, there, though.

More usefully, GPs point, or something adjacent to it, might be stated like this: in our modern age, certain roles that were previously fulfilled by religious groups are now either being commercialised, taken on by the government, or left to fall by the wayside. As we navigate modernity it's important to understand the larger context so we can make better decisions about how we handle the resulting changes in our social support structure, and what we might need to intentionally add back in.

But yeah, don't become a priest if you're looking for an easy job. I didn't mean to imply that.

Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by chermi on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @12:29PM (#45595004)
I think the church has a few other things going for it. Guilt, redemption, fear of rejection from community, ya know things of that sort. I'm sure you're glad to see corporations taking up such tactics with climate-shaming and such. As long as it's not money.
Re:Ireland Is Making Basic Income for Artists Program Permanent by LunaSea on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @01:36PM (#45595963)
The church would probably classify this program as marketing costs.