News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DC Taxi Commission Proposes New Rules to Shut Down Uber by ghshephard on Saturday September 22, 2012 @06:26PM (#4559200)
Non-driver here, so I use taxis and private car services almost exclusively in northern California (My many thousands of trips over 10 years have probably moved from the class of "anecdote" into "data").

I've used Uber a couple times. It's pricey ($49 for a $33 taxi trip) but fantastic for those who can afford it.

Uber is better than taxi's in many ways:

o Taxi will frequently not take a trip if it doesn't like where it's coming from ("Bad neighborhood") - Uber doesn't tell the driver where you are until they accept the trip.

o Taxi will ask where you are going, and decline the trip if they don't like how much they'll make. Uber driver asks you where you are going, after you are in the vehicle.

o Taxi will sometimes take a trip, while they already have one - resulting in 30-45 minutes extra delay - hard to do with Uber when you can see where they are traveling.

o Taxi on the peninsula is usually 30-45 minute wait. Uber is < 15 minutes on average

o Drivers in Taxi's can be somewhat "eccentric" on the peninsula (As in, some of them scare me, they are so crazy). Uber Drivers are professional, rated.

o Vehicles in Taxi's are pretty craptastic sometimes. I've had to have the driver open my door (god forbid we get in an accident) - ubers vehicles professional Sedans.

o Airport Drivers will sometimes try and scam you for a 50% surcharge when they are still "in zone". They even try and pull that on someone like me who flys in and out of SFO on a monthly basis - I can imagine how many just accept it. Uber charges are identified before you book your trip.

o Lots of taxis will not take credit cards, or (try to) charge you a 10% surcharge - some of them would even RETURN to SFO when they discover you don't have cash. Uber is 100% electronic. No cash/credit card required, just your Smart Phone.

I love the electronic receipts, rating on the driver, certainty about when the vehicle is arriving.

On the peninsula, you pay about a 50% premium (or more, depending on demand), which is represented in the much higher quality trip you get.

I think if Uber was prepared to stick with that "premium" market, then the commissions wouldn't have a problem with them. Their concern is that, much like AirBNB was a trojan horse to get into the Renting Apartments/compete with hotels market, Uber is going to start competing with regular taxis - and for someone who has paid > $1mm for a medallion (http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2011/10/21/why-taxi-me...) they are going to demand some sort of recompense and/or action be taken.

My guess is that there will be a strong correlation between cost of medallions and the resistance to Uber in any particular market.

What I would love to see, is that TAXI services adopt the uber model of source blind/closest taxi gets the trip/rate your driver/GPS location of Taxi/electronic receipts. It would be good for the industry, good for the customers, and good for the reputable drivers/services.

The only ones who would lose out would be the crappy services, with poorly maintained vehicles, and lousy drivers .

Re:DC Taxi Commission Proposes New Rules to Shut Down Uber by zobzu on Saturday September 22, 2012 @08:08PM (#4559436)
Already had a taxi assuring me the trip from the airport to my place was well under $20, as I had only a $20 bill and no active credit card. I asked him before hand if he was absolutely sure and that I wouldn't be able to pay more. I had 30Kg of luggage so I figured it was a good idea.

When we reached $20 at 70% of the way, he said "so ill bring you to the nearest ATM and you'll pay the diff ok?". I said no. He opened the door. I walked home. With my 30Kg. Yay.

I'd certainly take a non-taxi company whenever I wanna be sure. Sorry for honest taxi drivers.

Re:DC Taxi Commission Proposes New Rules to Shut Down Uber by ghshephard on Saturday September 22, 2012 @10:20PM (#4559754)
That's one I've never heard of before. Taxi drivers have a lot of flaws, but they are pre-programmed to take you to a safe-destination. Also - I do a lot of fare negotiation on longer trips (I rarely, if ever, pay meter from anywhere but the airport), and, in 10 years, I've never had a driver back out on a deal.

In particular, on a long fare, say, San Francisco to Mountain View, if it's a slow time with light traffic (weekend afternoons) - I can usually get a $150 trip for $75, and never more than $100.

Re:DC Taxi Commission Proposes New Rules to Shut Down Uber by zobzu on Sunday September 23, 2012 @10:38PM (#4562948)
Yeah I wasnt very happy that day. ;-)
Re:DC Taxi Commission Proposes New Rules to Shut Down Uber by Dylan16807 on Saturday September 22, 2012 @09:30PM (#4559644)
Did you give him the $20? He certainly tried to defraud you.
Re:DC Taxi Commission Proposes New Rules to Shut Down Uber by zobzu on Sunday September 23, 2012 @10:37PM (#4562946)
yes
Re:DC Taxi Commission Proposes New Rules to Shut Down Uber by robomartin on Saturday September 22, 2012 @09:45PM (#4559685)
Excellent post. Perfect example of why government should have nothing to do picking winners and losers as they are doing with Uber. They are trying to protect the mediocre at best. I used to think that the US was about excellence. That striving to be the best at something was actually rewarded. This is one example of how government can interfere to the benefit of the incompetent rather than promoting progress.
Re:DC Taxi Commission Proposes New Rules to Shut Down Uber by eli on Saturday September 22, 2012 @06:36PM (#4559219)
As an aside, many of these things you describe licensed cabs doing (refusing to pick people up or drop them off certain locations) is illegal in DC. Perhaps the Taxi Commission would be better off enforcing the rules against its own cabs than trying to keep out competitors.
Re:DC Taxi Commission Proposes New Rules to Shut Down Uber by jlgreco on Saturday September 22, 2012 @06:55PM (#4559281)
While those things are rightfully illegal, they are nevertheless a lot more prevalent than most people are comfortable recognizing. Any service which takes pains to eliminate the possibility of discrimination, not merely forbid it, is a welcome addition to the industry as far as I am concerned.
Re:DC Taxi Commission Proposes New Rules to Shut Down Uber by Nrsolis on Saturday September 22, 2012 @08:35PM (#4559493)
Man...you should go see what happens at Union Station on a weeknight right after 12AM.

It's essentially a free-fire zone on travelers. Taxis violate EVERY SINGLE RULE on fares that are supposed to protect the public.

If the DC Taxi Commission wanted to have a shred of credibility in this issue, they'd tackle that problem FIRST and leave UBER to the people that can afford the fare.

Re:DC Taxi Commission Proposes New Rules to Shut Down Uber by bmeckel on Saturday September 22, 2012 @07:32PM (#4559356)
This is great run down of uber. Here in NYC, where cabs are much more common-place I still use uber from time to time. The thing is it's not meant to replace taxis, it's more of a luxury item than anything. When I can't find a cab or just would feel better hopping in a nicer car, I'll use uber to get somewhere. Not to mention that the drivers are more than happy to wait while I run in to a store to grab some beer or whatnot, whereas a cabby would never be ok with that. I'm very happy that they've been licensed in NYC, as it means they will be around for a while.
Re:DC Taxi Commission Proposes New Rules to Shut Down Uber by 3143 on Saturday September 22, 2012 @09:52PM (#4559700)
How is promoting the Uber model better for drivers, if it forces them to pick up customers that are located in places they would rather not drive to and forces them to destinations they would rather not drive to?
Re:DC Taxi Commission Proposes New Rules to Shut Down Uber by ghshephard on Saturday September 22, 2012 @10:14PM (#4559748)
As an aggregate model, it would make taxis much more attractive for a lot of people who don't like the uncertainty, smelly cars, crazy drivers, poorly maintained vehicles, and long waiting times. Those people would be much more likely to hire taxis, increasing the business liquidity, reducing the uncertainty for taxi drivers in the business who might go a few hours without a ride. The advantage to drivers, is that an uber customer is identified before they get into the vehicle. They also have the means to pay. The ability to discriminate on source/destination is removed, but, in many taxi regions, they aren't, in theory, allowed to do that anyways.

I'm not arguing that 100% of all the uber rules are an advantage for drivers - in particular, the ability to turn down a $30 cab fare in order to wait for the $70 SFO trip will be to their economic disadvantage, but it will result in a healthier business overall.

Re:DC Taxi Commission Proposes New Rules to Shut Down Uber by jaylevitt on Sunday September 23, 2012 @03:13AM (#4560286)
Is that really allowed in CA? I know that in both NYC and Boston/Cambridge, a hailed cab can't refuse a destination. In fact, after being stranded in uptown Manhattan for an hour, I now make a point of not declaring my destination till I'm in the cab.
Re:DC Taxi Commission Proposes New Rules to Shut Down Uber by ghshephard on Sunday September 23, 2012 @05:56AM (#4560510)
What's "allowed" and what a cab driver will do are two different things, as you've already discovered. Also, on the peninsula in the bay area, you don't really "Hail" a cab, you have to call for one. And, it's while you are calling one, they can decided whether to send one. I've spent several hours at AMC Mercado in Santa Clara waiting for a cab for a short trip, and continually having it confirmed that they are "Waiting for someone to pick up the ride."
Re:DC Taxi Commission Proposes New Rules to Shut Down Uber by lsc on Sunday September 23, 2012 @08:01AM (#4560701)
>I've spent several hours at AMC Mercado in Santa Clara waiting for a cab for a short trip, and continually having it confirmed that they are "Waiting for someone to pick up the ride."

Which cab company was this? they sound way more reputable than any cab company I've rode with.

man, when I worked on the peninsula, it was maybe an hour walk to the caltrain. Now, they had a free shuttle, but I work late often.

I can walk for an hour, really, it's not that big of a deal, but if I can get a cab within 15 minutes? that would be my preference.

So I call the cab service, they tell me someone will be there in 15 minutes. I call again after half an hour. they say the same thing. I call to cancel the ride and "oh, they are almost there, just a minute"

I mean, if they would tell me that nobody was on it, I'd just start walking. It was pretty frustrating, and I finally stopped even trying, and walked every time I missed the shuttle.

Re:DC Taxi Commission Proposes New Rules to Shut Down Uber by jowiar on Sunday September 23, 2012 @12:18AM (#4559971)
People are willing to pay a higher fare for the service?