News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by Alex3917 on Saturday September 22, 2012 @05:14PM (#4559009)
"If medical errors were a disease, they would be the sixth leading cause of death in America—just behind accidents and ahead of Alzheimer's."

This is wrong, it's at least the third leading cause of death. And realistically if you don't smoke and you exercise once in a while, medical 'oopsy daisies' are probably your #1 risk of death:

C.f. The IOM's report To Err is Human: http://wps.pearsoneducation.nl/wps/media/objects/13902/14236...

And then also read Lucian Leape's commentary in JAMA on why it is probably a huge underestimate: http://jama.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=192842

(Leape is one of the authors of the original IOM report, and the report cites a lot of his own research, including his study estimating that only 5% of medical errors are ever discovered.)

C.f. also Barbara Starfield's estimate in JAMA: http://jama.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=192908#RE...

Realistically, all of these estimates are at the low end. In fact most of them only count deaths in hospitals (and severely undercount them), when at least half of all medical errors are thought to happen at local doctors offices, plastic surgery clinics, nursing homes, etc.

C.f. also the CDC figures for Hospital Acquired Infections, which IIRC the IOM report doesn't count as being medical errors:

http://www.cdc.gov/HAI/pdfs/hai/infections_deaths.pdf

My personal rule of thumb is to avoid taking any drugs or getting any non-trivial medical procedure unless I've read at least three books about it. The problem is that all the papers published in medical journals are basically complete bullshit (except the occasional well-done NIH ones), which means if you want real information about a given drug then the only way to get it is to subpoena the FDA, or read a book written by someone who has.

The way drug approval works is that you need 2 tests demonstrating that the drug is better than a placebo, but you're allowed infinite tries to get there. So often a drug will be better than a placebo in only 2 out of 10 trials, but it will still get approved and only those two trials will get published in medical journals. And then those journal articles will have very little in common with the actual data from the FDA trials because the pharma companies completely spin it, which is why the vast majority of the most popularly prescribed drugs are not only no more effective than placebos, but in fact significantly worse when you look at the total quality/length of life.

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by grueful on Saturday September 22, 2012 @08:31PM (#4559485)
I think one of the major turning points in the future will be to trigger a "space race" which makes a grand project of developing substantive improvements to medical care and quality of life.

There have been significant improvements here motivated by e.g. battlefield medicine, and great results out of academic or humanitarian labs, but much of our current work is stuck in a loop between patents and the FDA approval process. Good intentions aside, the system acts to motivate certain patterns of action in order to stay profitable and continue growing year-to-year which aren't optimal for our long-range interests.

How one would go about motivating such a grand project - I have no idea. Perhaps it's a matter of continuing to make such small improvements as we can until the system is primed for one giant leap. The road of progress was never a well-paved or straight one except in hindsight.

I think that small teams and open sharing of knowledge are both key ingredients. The amount of resources currently in play in medicine is staggering, but social systems tend to lose efficiency very quickly as they scale. Perhaps startup culture will be a key piece in making this happen, but the timescales involved in speculative medical research tend to be beyond the scope of the typical VC-backed endeavor.

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by ippisl on Sunday September 23, 2012 @11:12AM (#4561106)
At the academic level , there seems to be a "space race". Maybe it could be improved by making the NIH invest in more radical high risk stuff.

But the commercialization process sure sucks. Testing and verifying a drug is expensive, long and complex. But there seem to be some work going to improve that:

1. The FDA is becoming a bit more friendly[1]. 2. There are some new innovations in how to run clinical trials. One example is [2].They claim they might bring drugs 1-3 years faster to market. 3. Organs on a chip are starting to become available and this might be more accurate than the mouse models used today.

Since some of the new innovations in clinical trials do use web/mobile technology, i wonder what role startups can take in this area.

[1]http://www.xconomy.com/national/2012/09/10/the-fda-turns-fri... [2]http://disruptiveinnovationsinclinicaltrials.blogspot.co.il/...

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by agumonkey on Sunday September 23, 2012 @03:05PM (#4561739)
I was just wondering if there was or were companies like google or spacex/tesla for medicine. One that do away with the status quo. Things like chuck pell opener http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=txVM07D4bbA . And aiming at a smaller 'time to market', practical effects.
Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by derleth on Saturday September 22, 2012 @10:28PM (#4559771)
> a "space race" which makes a grand project of developing substantive improvements to medical care and quality of life.

How about a "space race" to destroy destructive nonsense like homeopathy, anti-vaccine idiocy, reiki, and all of the other non-scientific crap people try to use instead of real medicine.

Getting rid of quackademic medicine would be a good first step.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quackademic_medicine

http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/quackademic-me...

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by grueful on Saturday September 22, 2012 @10:48PM (#4559793)
I'm all for that. The key problem is defining it. There exist historical examples of quackery which wasn't, e.g. hand washing.

Stricter rules about null hypothesis testing would be a start, but the bigger problem is one of education. We're still plagued by government that gives the nod to creationism and horrifically distorted sex ed in public schools.

I'd like to say we've become empirical enough about what practices we place belief in that we could just treat all cases of quackery as malicious fraud - but the very prevalence of such issues tends to support the opposite conclusion.

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by derleth on Saturday September 22, 2012 @11:14PM (#4559833)
> I'd like to say we've become empirical enough about what practices we place belief in that we could just treat all cases of quackery as malicious fraud - but the very prevalence of such issues tends to support the opposite conclusion.

There are enough cognitive biases I can't support this conclusion. Confirmation bias alone accounts for a lot of this crap, I'm sure.

Fundamentally, though, there's a big difference between crap we know doesn't and can't work, like homeopathy, and therapies that are in the pipeline and might be accepted or rejected on their merits.

Homeopathy has had its turn and it failed. That goes for everything else I called quackery. Don't confuse that with something we haven't tried yet.

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by grueful on Sunday September 23, 2012 @03:32AM (#4560315)
Failed according to you, me, and the prevailing majority of the medical community isn't equivalent to failed in the minds of the overwhelming majority of the public. The segment which believes or doesn't strongly disbelieve things like homeopathy is manifestly non-negligible.

Anti-vax nuts wouldn't be the public health threat that they are if there were two of them in a pool of hundreds of millions. The segment acting on these beliefs is manifestly large enough to enable outbreaks of diseases we otherwise could suppress almost totally.

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by stfu on Sunday September 23, 2012 @12:29PM (#4561286)
For the sake of the argument let me try to defend Homeopathy for a moment. Sure, people can bash it all day long and it might have very little "measurable" effects. But as long as people believe in it, I expect that it leads to the same results as placebo effects.

Placebo effects have been proven in many cases extremely strong and a main obstacle for the pharmaceutic industry to prove the statistical significance of their products. And as long as people get better, even if it is just by the believe in the effect, it is in my view a legitimate approach.

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by derleth on Sunday September 23, 2012 @02:32PM (#4561635)
> And as long as people get better, even if it is just by the believe in the effect, it is in my view a legitimate approach.

So fraud isn't really fraud if people are going to get better anyway?

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by stfu on Thursday September 27, 2012 @08:20PM (#4583665)
If the believe in an illusion makes the symptoms improve I think it is completely legitimate. Maybe the same would have been achieved by a psychologist sitting down with them for a few sessions. But if the same result can be achieved by a placebo pill, I am all for it. Ultimately I see the goal of medicine to improve the conditions of the patient and if simple psychological triggers like placebo-similar medicine can achieve this, I am all for it.
Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by derleth on Sunday September 23, 2012 @02:31PM (#4561632)
> The segment which believes or doesn't strongly disbelieve things like homeopathy is manifestly non-negligible.

It doesn't matter. Science doesn't work by popular acclaim.

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by Alex3917 on Saturday September 22, 2012 @10:57PM (#4559802)
"There exist historical examples of quackery which wasn't, e.g. hand washing."

And homeopathy, which even James Randi admits was more effective than western medicine in the 1800s. (In the video that was submitted to HN recently.)

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by carbocation on Saturday September 22, 2012 @11:31PM (#4559868)
That's very misleading without providing proper context.

In Hahneman's time, medicine was actively harmful and virtually never actively helpful. The risk benefit analysis would not come out in favor of getting treatment.

In contrast, homeopathy does nothing. It's placebo. And giving placebo, it turns out, is safer than actively sticking dirty instruments into your patient's bloodstream and giving them bacteremia.

In that context, the statement makes sense, but is still obviously tongue in cheek. Homeopathy never worked, but medicine at the time actively harmed.

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by Alex3917 on Saturday September 22, 2012 @11:52PM (#4559915)
"In contrast, homeopathy does nothing. It's placebo."

Well, yes and no. It is a placebo, but the research seems to show that placebos do significantly more than nothing, at least for some diseases (pain, depression, etc.).

The comment I was replying to was asking for examples of where things that were once believed to be quackery were later vindicated. At the time homeopathy was believed to be quackery. In fact the reason the AMA was launched was to combat homeopathy because it was cutting into their profits; one of their first acts was to launch a 'propaganda department' to scare people off of homeopathy. (Essentially the AMA was founded to kill people. They knew they were less effective than homeopathy at the time and they knew they were killing people, but they just didn't care because they wanted the money.)

The point is though that at the time homeopathy was actually significantly better than western medicine. Now if the definition of something not being quackery is if it's the best treatment available to us at the time, then homeopathy couldn't have been quackery by definition, since it was in fact the most scientifically advanced (or however you'd phrase it) form of medicine available at the time.

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by carbocation on Sunday September 23, 2012 @12:47AM (#4560027)
> Now if the definition of something not being quackery is if it's the best treatment available to us at the time,

I do not believe that to be the common definition of quackery.

>then homeopathy couldn't have been quackery by definition, since it was in fact the most scientifically advanced (or however you'd phrase it) form of medicine available at the time.

Again, this is misleading. Homeopathy was and still is completely scientifically bogus. It was never and is not now advanced. It is misleading to say that a field that unintentionally had no effect was scientifically advanced. It's simply the (undisputed) truth that their outcomes were better because of their lack of real intervention, not because of any scientific merit whatsoever.

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by Alex3917 on Sunday September 23, 2012 @01:09AM (#4560082)
@carbocation

You can call it whatever you want, but the fact remains that if homeopathy was quackery then western medicine was the whole duck.

Also, it's not really fair to say that homeopathy was better merely by accident or that it wasn't scientific, since they're the ones who pioneered evidence based medicine. It might have been completely wrong, but it was scientific. They at least tested their ideas empirically unlike western medicine at the time, which by any reasonable definition must make it more scientifically advanced than the alternative.

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by carbocation on Sunday September 23, 2012 @01:28AM (#4560132)
I am surprised to see that we disagree on the facts as well as the interpretation of them.

I don't think the literature is nearly as scientific as you seem to think it is, nor do I credit Hahnemann with the shift to empiricism in medicine, which came later.

Again, just saying that medicine was harmful and that Hahnemann was observant does not make homeopathy of the time scientific.

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by Alex3917 on Sunday September 23, 2012 @02:02AM (#4560187)
"I don't think the literature is nearly as scientific as you seem to think it is, nor do I credit Hahnemann with the shift to empiricism in medicine, which came later."

Well I should admit that I'm not an expert on this, but if you read the JAMA book review of the book I mentioned above:

"By taking the homeopathy of that period seriously himself, Haller is able to remind readers that 19th-century homeopaths pioneered systematic drug-testing research, challenged the dangerously depleting procedures of mainstream physicians at that time, established rigorous professional standards, and valued advanced education at least as highly as their mainstream counterparts did. It was not without reason that homeopaths considered the bases of their approach to medical problems to be more logical and more promising than the inherited tradition of the ancients, upon which mainstream physicians still based their practices."

You have to remember also that 'scientific' is a relative term. Placebo controlled trials weren't invented until the 50s. And doing properly controlled placebo trials (with active placebos) is very rare even today.

Homeopathy of the 1860s and 1870s might not seem at all scientific by today's standards, but that doesn't mean it wasn't a significant advance in science at the time. (And by the way this was well after Hahnemann, who did most of his work on homeopathy in the 1810s and was already long dead by this time.)

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by aswanson on Sunday September 23, 2012 @12:25PM (#4561272)
Saying homeopathy was more advanced than regular medicine at the time is akin to saying rain dancing was more advanced than irrigation of crops from a polluted water source. At least the latter method is based on the assumption of certain evidenced-backed empirical principles. The former method has no correlation or effect on reality under any assumption beyond pleasing the rain gods and associated bullshit.
Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by Alex3917 on Sunday September 23, 2012 @12:34AM (#4560000)
@Derleth

Read the book Homeopathy: The Academic Years. Even the AMA admits that this is true, and they give the book a very favorable review on their website. (And also the AMA talks about their propaganda department on their own timeline of their history.)

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by derleth on Sunday September 23, 2012 @12:25AM (#4559982)
> At the time homeopathy was believed to be quackery.

It still is believed to be quackery, because it still is quackery.

> In fact the reason the AMA was launched was to combat homeopathy because it was cutting into their profits; one of their first acts was to launch a 'propaganda department' to scare people off of homeopathy. (Essentially the AMA was founded to kill people. They knew they were less effective than homeopathy at the time and they knew they were killing people, but they just didn't care because they wanted the money.)

This sounds like conspiracist nonsense. Do you have a single cite for any of it?

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by frobozz on Sunday September 23, 2012 @08:58AM (#4560804)
Homeopathy was more effective in the 1800s because the patient was only under threat from their ailments, rather than having to worry about the doctor killing them as well.

Early medicine was in a large portion, quackery. Some of it was actively harmful. Something that has no effect whatsoever will be more effective than something that harms and doesn't cure.

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by TillE on Saturday September 22, 2012 @11:15PM (#4559839)
The placebo effect is remarkably powerful. But there's nothing special about homeopathy.
Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by derleth on Saturday September 22, 2012 @11:12PM (#4559830)
> homeopathy, which even James Randi admits was more effective than western medicine in the 1800s

I hope you realize how worthless this statement is in a discussion of modern medicine.

Also, it's incredibly racist to call 'medicine that works' 'Western medicine'. Do you also call 'math that works' 'Western mathematics'?

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by Alex3917 on Sunday September 23, 2012 @12:00AM (#4559936)
"Also, it's incredibly racist to call 'medicine that works' 'Western medicine'."

I assure you that's not how I'm using the phrase.

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by derleth on Sunday September 23, 2012 @03:52PM (#4561842)
> I assure you that's not how I'm using the phrase.

Except it is. Medicine can be practiced by anyone who knows how, not just people with the right-colored skin.

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by gizmo686 on Saturday September 22, 2012 @11:09PM (#4559819)
When you say subpoena the FDA, do you mean that you need to get a court order compelling the FDA to show you the results?
Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by Alex3917 on Sunday September 23, 2012 @12:28AM (#4559991)
I meant filing an FOIA request, my bad. From what I hear the FDA is usually pretty good about complying with requests for basic results, so a court order shouldn't be needed most of the time.
Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by gruseom on Sunday September 23, 2012 @03:34PM (#4561806)
Suppose some well-funded nonprofit filed FOIA requests for all the unpublished data from every single clinical study, with the intention of putting it online. What would happen?

(Edit: oh, this was already discussed: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4560263)

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by jonchang on Sunday September 23, 2012 @12:51AM (#4560047)
> The way drug approval works is that you need 2 tests demonstrating that the drug is better than a placebo, but you're allowed infinite tries to get there. So often a drug will be better than a placebo in only 2 out of 10 trials, but it will still get approved and only those two trials will get published in medical journals.

This is incorrect. All clinical studies must be registered before they are started, precisely so that negative results are reported.

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by gruseom on Sunday September 23, 2012 @01:15AM (#4560093)
You say "reported", but that's ambiguous. The question is, are all registered clinical studies published? If they are, why did Kirsch and Sapirstein have to sue under the Freedom of Information Act (and wait years) to see the unpublished studies of antidepressants?

http://www.thedailybeast.com/newsweek/2010/01/28/the-depress...

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by jonchang on Sunday September 23, 2012 @01:50AM (#4560170)
Registration wasn't mandatory until around 2007 or so. The studies from the article you linked are much older than that.
Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by gruseom on Sunday September 23, 2012 @01:56AM (#4560176)
I can't tell if you're evading the question. Is every registered study a published study?
Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by jonchang on Sunday September 23, 2012 @02:20AM (#4560208)
If, by published you mean published in a peer-reviewed journal, then no. Studies are registered before they start, but clinical trials fail or are withdrawn for various reasons (like safety problems, lack of funding, etc).

I imagine that registered studies that are completed are published if they have positive results, or negative results that contradict other well-known positive results. There's no reason not to publish if you get a good or interesting result. But publication can take years, so I don't think it's particularly unusual to see a completed study without a corresponding publication.

But again, the specific cases you linked predate the current registration and reporting requirements.

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by disgruntledphd2 on Sunday September 23, 2012 @05:53AM (#4560506)
Sorry, but publication of negative results only happens in a number of cases.

1) Research is carried out by academics with no ties to phamaceutical companies. 2) The negative results make a competitors drug look even worse.

If neither of these things are true, then negative results just sit in a file-drawer somewhere. Compulsory registration (clinicaltrials.gov) will help with this for new medicines, but this will take years before we have any decent information

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by Alex3917 on Sunday September 23, 2012 @12:59AM (#4560069)
That's wrong. They are registered so that they can't hide the data from the FDA. But once the FDA has the data the drug companies aren't required to publish it anywhere, nor does the FDA publish it themselves.
Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by joering2 on Sunday September 23, 2012 @03:03AM (#4560263)
Hmmm.. Could i FOIA FDA on hundreds of clinical studies of well known drugs and publish them online?

Seriously asking.

And for some weird reason this feels like wikileaks for drugs...

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by Alex3917 on Sunday September 23, 2012 @02:02PM (#4561548)
"Could i FOIA FDA on hundreds of clinical studies of well known drugs and publish them online?"

Absolutely, but you would need to pay their costs, which could be several thousand dollars per drug and several million dollars overall. At some level though you probably would need to go to court to win. And even if you were successful, no one would believe you anyway. Books like Goldacre's or reports like this are published all the time, well-researched and true, but they're no match for the billions of propaganda dollars spent by the medical industry and big pharma each year, and the complete ownership of the media, congress, medical education, hospitals, and the FDA.

Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by jonchang on Sunday September 23, 2012 @01:10AM (#4560083)
Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by Alex3917 on Sunday September 23, 2012 @01:43AM (#4560159)
...Which supports what I said, as only a small number of the studies listed as completed show the results, and even the ones that do don't show the raw data.
Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by jonchang on Sunday September 23, 2012 @01:58AM (#4560180)
Results aren't reported immediately. http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/info/results
Re:How to stop hospitals from killing us by Alex3917 on Sunday September 23, 2012 @02:12AM (#4560194)
Interesting, this is more than I thought was required. But even still, it's much less than the amount of data the FDA actually gets. Not to mention that of the 1508 drugs the FDA has approved since 1940, this only useful for the 50 or so approved in the last couple years.

Also, the last time I heard phase IV trials didn't need to be registered at all, except for when they were required as a condition of approval.