News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by belter on Monday October 13, 2025 @09:32AM (#45568153)
Predictable...but are those aholes wrong...? :-) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44013692

Economics violates Popper demarcation criterion. Economic theories can't be falsified because you can't run controlled experiments on economies, rewind history, or isolate variables.

When models fail, economists adjust assumptions ...

Unfalsifiable = Unscientific.

Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by rtsil on Monday October 13, 2025 @09:47AM (#45568295)
Neither are litterature and peace.
Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by belter on Monday October 13, 2025 @10:55AM (#45568999)
They are not pretending to be sciences.
Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by immibis on Monday October 13, 2025 @07:25PM (#45574426)
Or astrophysics (not a Nobel prize but obviously a real science despite being non-replicable).
Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by IAmBroom on Monday October 13, 2025 @10:19AM (#45568607)
> When models fail, economists adjust assumptions ...

When models fail, physicist adjust hypotheses ...

Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by belter on Monday October 13, 2025 @10:56AM (#45569005)
Physics can test those hypotheses under controlled conditions...
Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by RandomLensman on Monday October 13, 2025 @11:11AM (#45569211)
Not always/limited in some areas (astrophysics come to mind where we, e.g., cannot (yet) create a star under controlled conditions). Testing hypotheses or predictions vs observations is also a valid method.
Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by belter on Monday October 13, 2025 @01:51PM (#45571297)
Science is not about where you test hypotheses, but how. Astrophysics builds falsifiable models and checks them against reality like spectra, gravitational waves, etc... When predictions fail, theories change.

If these were economists, they would check if their equations match the economic universe they live in. :-) Instead, they conclude the agents just “did not behave rationally enough”.

Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by genericresponse on Monday October 13, 2025 @02:43PM (#45571890)
That's just not true. The models have real predictive power, they just have limitations. Behavioral economics, which tackles this frontier is still a growing field. Thaler, Kahneman, and Taversky won the prize in 2017 for building the bridge between economic theory and individual decision-making.

At the risk of being inflammatory-- These arguments are the equivalent of saying that Newton didn't really do physics because his models of mechanics break down at high enough speeds and small enough scales.

Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by RandomLensman on Monday October 13, 2025 @02:40PM (#45571850)
Not about controlled conditions then necessarily.

Not really my experience with economics - a lot of awareness of reality vs model (regardless of how "beautiful" they are).

Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by JumpCrisscross on Monday October 13, 2025 @03:39PM (#45572480)
> Physics can test those hypotheses under controlled conditions

I genuinely have no idea why so many commenters on HN will spout nonsense based on high school curriculum with the confidence of a PhD when it comes to economics, but won’t embarrass themselves in other fields.

Yes, economics—particularly microeconomics—is constantly subject to experimentation. Macroeconomics is closer to astronomy, in that models are developed, novel data sources sought, old models tested and then validated or rejected. Also like astronomy, or perhaps more accurately fundamental physics, it’s currently off in a loop of DSGE optimizations which are mathematically pretty for the field but not super interesting outside it. (This work is not in that category.)

Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by belter on Monday October 13, 2025 @05:35PM (#45573585)
That comparison collapses instantly. Physics has invariants...Economics does not. You can’t rerun the economy under controlled conditions, so “experiments” are mostly natural or quasi experiments...statistical patchwork with fragile assumptions.

Macroeconomics isn’t like astronomy :-) Stars don’t change behavior when you model them. Economies do. There are no stable primitives, no conservation laws, just shifting behavior and feedback loops.

DSGE models are equilibrium sandcastles calibrated to past data. In physics that’s failure while in macro it’s tenure.

Economics is interesting and sometimes useful but calling it an experimental science is self-flattery.

  “One thing we are not going to have, now or ever, is a set  of models that forecasts sudden falls in the value of financial assets.”

   -- Robert E. Lucas

 "As a policy-maker during the crisis, I found the available models of limited help. In fact, I would go further: in the face of the crisis, we felt abandoned by conventional tools."

   -- Jean-Claude Trichet - https://www.ecb.europa.eu/press/key/date/2010/html/sp101118.en.html

 "How Conventional Wisdom Failed Us" - https://youtu.be/c8LMWCko4d0?t=138
Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by JumpCrisscross on Monday October 13, 2025 @06:45PM (#45574134)
> You can’t rerun the economy under controlled conditions, so “experiments” are mostly natural or quasi experiments

...you can't rerun the universe under controlled experiments. That's the whole point of the "controlled" part. It's an artificially isolated environment designed to model a specific phenomenon.

If you want examples of thoroughly experimental economic disciplines, look to auction, bargaining and game theory.

> Macroeconomics isn’t like astronomy :-) Stars don’t change behavior when you model them. Economies do

Stars don't change, but the ways we look at them do. This sort of endogeneity in data collection and research methods is a constant source of noise and errors in the physical sciences.

You're correct in that it's much more pronounced in economics, since humans are agents. That puts boundaries on how much one can predict. But that doesn't make it unknowable through the scientific method.

> DSGE models are equilibrium sandcastles calibrated to past data. In physics that’s failure while in macro it’s tenure

I'm not going to defend DSGE any more than I will string theory. (I know a lot more about the former to be able to properly critique it than I do the latter.)

> Economics is interesting and sometimes useful but calling it an experimental science is self-flattery

I'm not an economist. But I apparently know more economics than a lot of people who make confident statements on this board about the field.

Several fields of economics are rigorously empirical. Others are strictly observational. And others are total nonsense. The fill of nonsense is higher than other fields, but that's mostly due to the relevance of the work. If the rise and fall of nations rode on the spectral pattern of Sagittarius A*, you'd probably have a lot of nonsense work around that, too.

Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by yard2010 on Monday October 13, 2025 @05:35PM (#45573598)
Ha. Controlled conditions.
Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by astrange on Monday October 13, 2025 @07:46PM (#45574585)
Adjusting your hypothesis because your experiment failed has unintended consequences.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HARKing

Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by lanfeust6 on Monday October 13, 2025 @10:45AM (#45568873)
Argentina managed to save itself from hyperinflation by drastically cutting spending. By your logic, this could not be in the least bit predictable and inflation as a phenomenon doesn't even matter.

Supposing it did was fairly predictable that not setting money on fire would help recovery, what does it matter that there is no controlled scientific experiment involved? Or to put it another way, are there no facts to be gleaned from data?

Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by thrance on Monday October 13, 2025 @11:52AM (#45569740)
Argentina didn't manage shit, else they wouldn't have to be bailed out by the Trump admin. This should come as a surprise to no one, "General AnCap" may have artifically and temporarily given the impression of good numbers by destroying his country's public infrastructure, but this is at the direct cost of the future. Now they're starting to pay the price.
Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by lanfeust6 on Monday October 13, 2025 @12:02PM (#45569887)
> Argentina didn't manage shit

You're deflecting. Curtailing inflation was an outcome of policy. The U.S. had fuck-all to do with it. Unless you're willing to acknowledge something so basic there's nothing else to say to someone disinterested in good faith discussion

Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by genericresponse on Monday October 13, 2025 @02:52PM (#45571981)
Ehh... you're both wrong. Argentina ended 2024 with an annual inflation rate close to 100%. That's significantly lower, but still hyperinflation. It should be lower this year, but how much is the question.

Whether that's maintainable long term is probably the decisive judgement. Argentina has had many cycles of hyperinflation, reset, hyperinflation again. The current bailout is not exactly a positive indicator.

Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by lanfeust6 on Tuesday October 14, 2025 @12:24PM (#45581943)
It's all relative, but yes, they're still in trouble. Currency manipulation is also unsustainable. The markets are reacting poorly now in anticipation of the Peronists winning the next govt as well.
Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by atwrk on Monday October 13, 2025 @10:06AM (#45568493)
Do you think Poppers demarcation criterion is falsifiable?
Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by AnimalMuppet on Monday October 13, 2025 @01:33PM (#45571087)
Nice use of recursion...
Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by belter on Monday October 13, 2025 @02:06PM (#45571499)
It is not falsifiable because it is not a hypothesis but a framework for recognizing science.

Rejecting Popper for that is like rejecting reasoning itself because you can’t run a control experiment on it...but then one turns into an economist...

Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by atwrk on Tuesday October 14, 2025 @04:03AM (#45577387)
> It is not falsifiable because it is not a hypothesis but a framework for recognizing science.

And if the source of that framework is not (part of your definition of) science, how do we know whether that framework is true?

That was sort of my point: Poppers criterion is nice, but only works for a small subset of (natural) science - and even there has to face criticism because it is simply too naive for many edge cases.

Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by belter on Wednesday October 15, 2025 @08:45AM (#45591567)
Popper’s rule is not falsifiable for the same reason a definition can’t define itself. Falsifiability judges claims, not the rules for judging claims. Mixing those levels is like asking whether the rules of chess can checkmate themselves.

In category theory terms, it’s a type error, applying a rule defined within a system to the meta-level that defines the system itself.

https://www.lesswrong.com/w/object-level-and-meta-level

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metatheory

Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by yard2010 on Monday October 13, 2025 @05:31PM (#45573550)
These are all people using made up words to throw shit on other people.
Re:The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memor... by astrange on Monday October 13, 2025 @07:45PM (#45574567)
> Economic theories can't be falsified because you can't run controlled experiments on economies, rewind history, or isolate variables.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Econometrics

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Credibility_revolution

Economists are practically the only social scientists capable of doing this (even if it involves a lot of rainfall IVs). Everyone else p-hacks and calls it a day.