News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TikTok removing posts for violating the "joy of TikTok" by nomel on Friday October 10, 2025 @09:49PM (#45545863)
This is, fundamentally, what made TikTok a success.

This is why TikTok is not a lens you should perceive the world through, or get "controversial" news from. It's a highly curated feed to maximize long term engagement and profits. Cortisol, the stress hormone, is the "situational avoidance" hormone [1].

> High glucocorticoid stress-responses are associated with prolonged freezing reactions and decreased active approach and avoidance behavior in animals.

Increasing a chemical that is tied to avoiding an activity is in complete odds with the goals of TikTok.

[1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15854783/

Re:TikTok removing posts for violating the "joy of TikTok" by kragen on Friday October 10, 2025 @10:04PM (#45545958)
That's the opposite of what Facebook notoriously found—but, either way, is maximizing long-term engagement in the best interest of the users?
Re:TikTok removing posts for violating the "joy of TikTok" by nomel on Friday October 10, 2025 @10:16PM (#45546004)
> That's the opposite of what Facebook notoriously found

Consider that Facebook's conclusions are why they don't have anything remotely as successful as TikTok, for engagement.

> in the best interest of the users?

I don't understand this. Is this some moral motive? TikTok is an independent for profit company that has a product with better engagement than any other in the world. Within that context, yes, it's in the best interest for the user, measured by engagement.

Re:TikTok removing posts for violating the "joy of TikTok" by dangus on Friday October 10, 2025 @11:01PM (#45546225)
Exactly, let’s not forget that Facebook is currently losing users. A shrinking business.
Re:TikTok removing posts for violating the "joy of TikTok" by kragen on Saturday October 11, 2025 @07:19PM (#45553601)
You cannot answer the question of whether maximizing engagement with TikTok is in the best interest of the user by pointing out that maximizing engagement maximizes engagement.
Re:TikTok removing posts for violating the "joy of TikTok" by nomel on Sunday October 12, 2025 @12:57PM (#45559727)
I was answering in the context of video watching, where “interest” is literally how interested the videos are to the person, which could be measured as a global max of long term engagement.

As I said, I don’t understand the question. To understand I would be to know what “best interest” means to you, and in what specific context?

Re:TikTok removing posts for violating the "joy of TikTok" by brazukadev on Saturday October 11, 2025 @08:51AM (#45548772)
Facebook is kinda dead now proves the point
Re:TikTok removing posts for violating the "joy of TikTok" by thesmtsolver on Saturday October 11, 2025 @09:47AM (#45549120)
Re:TikTok removing posts for violating the "joy of TikTok" by techjamie on Saturday October 11, 2025 @10:54AM (#45549628)
3b monthly users would mean nearly half of the entire world's population is on Facebook at least once per month. No matter how you shake it, that's simply not a realistic number, even before you consider people that live in areas with no internet, or regimes that disallow sites like Facebook, children too young to even possibly use Facebook, so on.

It wouldn't surprise me if the total number of real users, not counting bots and alt accounts, is probably ~1b or less.

Re:TikTok removing posts for violating the "joy of TikTok" by thesmtsolver on Monday October 13, 2025 @08:20PM (#45574823)
HN lives in a bubble. Almost everyone I know uses FB daily. These are legal numbers and shouldn’t be too much off.
Re:TikTok removing posts for violating the "joy of TikTok" by brazukadev on Saturday October 11, 2025 @09:52AM (#45549160)
That's not growth, it's just logged in users navigating the web and FB counting anybody that hits their APIs. Facebook is dead.
Re:TikTok removing posts for violating the "joy of TikTok" by thesmtsolver on Monday October 13, 2025 @08:20PM (#45574827)
Growth can be gained from the shape of the graph.
Re:TikTok removing posts for violating the "joy of TikTok" by brazukadev on Thursday October 16, 2025 @11:15PM (#45613001)
Sure, you can buy the lies you want
Re:TikTok removing posts for violating the "joy of TikTok" by 93po on Saturday October 11, 2025 @12:48PM (#45550598)
also a difference for approaches, possibly, for maximizing engagement (commenting) versus maximizing time on app
Re:TikTok removing posts for violating the "joy of TikTok" by bhouston on Friday October 10, 2025 @10:07PM (#45545968)
> This is, fundamentally, what made TikTok a success.

The algorithm optimizes for engagement.

This is outside of that optimization because it is outright just removing this content, not even considering it for display.

Re:TikTok removing posts for violating the "joy of TikTok" by nomel on Friday October 10, 2025 @10:12PM (#45545987)
> This is outside of that optimization because it is outright just removing this content, not even considering it for display.

This is based on what? Another assumption could be that the algorithm identified this as "net negative".

Re:TikTok removing posts for violating the "joy of TikTok" by morkalork on Friday October 10, 2025 @10:39PM (#45546121)
>TikTok moderators were told to suppress videos from users who appeared too ugly, poor or disabled, as part of the company’s efforts to curate an aspirational air in the videos it promotes, according to new documents published by the Intercept.

https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2020/mar/17/tiktok-tr...

Re:TikTok removing posts for violating the "joy of TikTok" by nomel on Friday October 10, 2025 @10:45PM (#45546146)
Could you explain how this is related? This is evidence they've always curated for what they deem as "undesirable" things, related to engagement.

> who appeared too ugly, poor or disabled

From the engagement perspective, you'll find that movie stars, social media stars, CEOs, and even politicians (with some famous presidential results [1]) are, nearly without exception, attractive and fit. Why?

[1] https://www.history.com/articles/kennedy-nixon-debates

Re:TikTok removing posts for violating the "joy of TikTok" by Noumenon72 on Friday October 10, 2025 @10:48PM (#45546166)
I would say removing political rage bait is a sign that they are not optimizing for engagement but enjoyment. TikTok is a feed of stuff that's interesting, funny, and wholesome, not the slop and doomscrolling that chasing engagement gets you. Just from looking at the thumbnail in the article you can tell it would never be shown on TikTok, regardless of political content.
Re:TikTok removing posts for violating the "joy of TikTok" by jazzyjackson on Friday October 10, 2025 @10:35PM (#45546099)
huh? Doesn't tiktok engagement increase as a person becomes more avoidant of whatever it is they'd have to do if they weren't scrolling on tiktok?
Re:TikTok removing posts for violating the "joy of TikTok" by nomel on Friday October 10, 2025 @10:55PM (#45546196)
A logical way to achieve that would be to minimize cortisol and maximize dopamine, providing a stress free escape from the stress inducing real world. ;)