News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Should we maybe add header "X-Electricity-Used: 4... by wmf on Friday October 10, 2025 @11:26PM (#45546353)
There's a whole mini-industry around carbon accounting but (A) it's very hard to estimate accurately, (B) it will be gamed like any other metric, and (C) energy is good. We should focus on making energy cleaner and cheaper so that people can use it without guilt.
Re:Ask HN: Should we maybe add header "X-Electricity-Used: 4... by comprev on Saturday October 11, 2025 @12:46PM (#45550576)
"carbon offset" is big business in the aviation world although I feel it's just virtue signalling.

If they were serious about aiming for "carbon neutral" the plane would never take off in the first place!

I admit this is a very simplistic view and likely I just don't understand the bigger picture about economics of carbon offsetting.

Re:Ask HN: Should we maybe add header "X-Electricity-Used: 4... by wmf on Saturday October 11, 2025 @06:49PM (#45553335)
Aviation is one of the easiest cases because the amount of fuel burned is tracked and ~100% of the carbon in the fuel becomes CO2. Since there's currently no good alternative to hydrocarbon fuel, it's also a good case for biofuel or carbon capture (not offsets which are mostly fake).
Re:Ask HN: Should we maybe add header "X-Electricity-Used: 4... by subject4056 on Friday October 10, 2025 @09:50PM (#45545872)
I don't think adding 20 bytes to every response, which are never read in practice, will improve the energy efficiency of the internet. Not to be mean, there's just a lot of stuff in most responses that effectively nothing acts on.
Re:Ask HN: Should we maybe add header "X-Electricity-Used: 4... by delopsu on Friday October 10, 2025 @09:56PM (#45545904)
hm, right, it will probably burn more energy, than add sense
Re:Ask HN: Should we maybe add header "X-Electricity-Used: 4... by Bender on Friday October 10, 2025 @10:34PM (#45546094)
Perhaps I have spent too much time around curious, creative and even devious people but I suspect they would try to see which sites they could jack that number up as high as possible similar to how people share speed test results. If it became popular enough I could see Cloudflare one day doing metrics on this and making blog posts about how much power they saved.
Re:Ask HN: Should we maybe add header "X-Electricity-Used: 4... by benoau on Friday October 10, 2025 @09:57PM (#45545908)
Couldn't even compute this value on most infrastructure.
Re:Ask HN: Should we maybe add header "X-Electricity-Used: 4... by ManlyBread on Saturday October 11, 2025 @05:22AM (#45547742)
Automated slacktivism, soon available in your http headers!
Re:Ask HN: Should we maybe add header "X-Electricity-Used: 4... by bjourne on Saturday October 11, 2025 @12:31PM (#45550433)
no
Re:Ask HN: Should we maybe add header "X-Electricity-Used: 4... by aristofun on Saturday October 11, 2025 @12:41PM (#45550533)
Why, god, why??!
Re:Ask HN: Should we maybe add header "X-Electricity-Used: 4... by cpach on Sunday October 12, 2025 @06:08AM (#45556958)
IMHO it’s better to bake this information into the price of the resource and then include the externalities for polluting by using a Pigou tax, or as in the EU, with a cap and trade system (EU ETS).

And that’s probably one of the reasons that you need to pay for using the best version of ChatGPT and similar products.

Re:Ask HN: Should we maybe add header "X-Electricity-Used: 4... by johneth on Sunday October 12, 2025 @11:37AM (#45558992)
It's an interesting idea, but how would you actually calculate that value? It seems to border on impossible.
Re:Ask HN: Should we maybe add header "X-Electricity-Used: 4... by moomoo11 on Monday October 13, 2025 @01:09AM (#45564862)
Cringe