News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by littlecranky67 on Thursday October 09, 2025 @05:03AM (#45525234)
Pretty sure it is NOT the definition of that law, but my own definition is: You make a meal only of basic ingredients. A basic ingredient is something that does not have an ingredient list on its packaging. I.e. Fruit, vegetables, eggs, meat and fish does not come with an ingredient list. There are some exceptions like dairy products (butter, yoghurt, cheese) which are okay to use.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday October 09, 2025 @05:37AM (#45525449)
> basic ingredient is something that does not have an ingredient list on its packaging

These are unprocessed foods [1].

From them you get processed culinary ingredients, like olive oil, vinegar, honey and butter. As long as you’re minimally vigilant with these, you should be fine, though some production methods may still add preservatives or use solvents in their manufacture.

After that one has processed foods, which may still have a good amount of Group 1 and 2 ingredients, before we get to Group 4, UPFs, what California is banning in school lunches.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nova_classification

Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by UncleMeat on Thursday October 09, 2025 @07:53AM (#45526368)
That's not true. The law does not define UPF as Nova Group 4 foods.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by littlecranky67 on Thursday October 09, 2025 @05:49AM (#45525536)
Thanks for that Link to the Nova classification. TIL there is even a database that lets you lookup the Nova level: openfoodfacts.org
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by lithocarpus on Thursday October 09, 2025 @04:15PM (#45532534)
Much "olive oil" out there is actually ultra processed. Not real extra virgin olive oil, but the cheaper more common olive oil including fake evoo can be either cut with soybean oil or is refined processed olive oil following the same process used in making refined soybean oil.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by jbstack on Thursday October 09, 2025 @05:42AM (#45525484)
Sounds like you're defining processed food, whereas this is about ultra processed food.

For me, processed food might include something like unsweetened peanut butter where while the only ingredient is peanuts, it's still been through a process of grinding so that it's no longer in its natural form.

At the other end of the spectrum an example of ultra processed food would be a factory packaged item with a long list of ingredients which includes ones you don't recognise e.g. chemical names or E numbers.

Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by gabrielsroka on Thursday October 09, 2025 @12:06PM (#45529627)
The peanuts might be roasted, too. Roasting is a process.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by lithocarpus on Thursday October 09, 2025 @04:16PM (#45532550)
Look into the process involved in making soybean or canola or sunflower oil. One named ingredient that sounds natural but is itself ultra processed and not real food.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by eisen_matrix on Thursday October 09, 2025 @05:07AM (#45525255)
This is based on Nova definition probably.

- Unprocessed or minimally processed foods (fresh or frozen products, yoghurts, etc)

- Processed culinary ingredients (oil, vinegar)

- Processed foods (foods created from combining elements of the first 2 groups using typical cooking processes, like bread, pasta, some meats, canned vegetables)

- Ultra-processed foods (foods requiring industrial processing).

Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by DrewADesign on Thursday October 09, 2025 @06:01AM (#45525601)
I imagine it’s got more to do with ingredients than processing. Local restaurants might make fresh bread with a bleached flour product that has various dough conditioning agents added to it, while puffed rice absolutely requires an industrial process to create and has one ingredient.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday October 09, 2025 @06:03AM (#45525618)
> puffed rice absolutely requires an industrial process

“Traditional methods to puff or pop rice include frying in oil or salt. Commercial puffed rice is usually made by heating rice kernels under high pressure in the presence of steam, though the method of manufacture varies widely” [1].

If I had to guess, the commercial stuff is more thoroughly and homogeneously gelatinized. That, in turn, probably raises its glycemic index.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Puffed_rice

Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by DrewADesign on Thursday October 09, 2025 @04:30PM (#45532710)
The texture is completely different. The industrial method involves heating it under very high pressure with steam and releasing the pressure extremely quickly. The closest non-industrial analog is a Chinese popcorn cannon… but it’s much more controlled. It incorporates much more air into the final product without imparting any flavor from the heat source.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by hshdhdhehd on Thursday October 09, 2025 @06:08AM (#45525648)
So processedness is a proxy for healthiness. But raw sugar and guacamole would both count as processed.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday October 09, 2025 @06:15AM (#45525695)
> raw sugar and guacamole would both count as processed

No. Processed culinary ingredient (Group 2) and minimally processed (Group 1). (Obviously, both can be turned into a UPF through fuckery.)

Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by gusgus01 on Thursday October 09, 2025 @06:48AM (#45525887)
Guacamole would count as Group 3 I believe. You use Group 1 and Group 2 ingredients to create it unless you're just grinding up avocados, in which case that's not a guacamole. If you really want to get interesting, you could even say homemade guacamole uses citric acid (from limes) to extend shelf life and enhance the flavor, which is on top of the sodium chloride (salt) that you use to do the same.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by IAmBroom on Thursday October 09, 2025 @10:06AM (#45527914)
TIL the No True Scotsman fallacy can be used by guac snobs! :)
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by gusgus01 on Saturday October 11, 2025 @10:36PM (#45554679)
I mean... different dishes have different names. Mashed avocados would probably just be called mashed avocados. Guacamole has many many regional versions, but I do think salt would be considered an essential ingredient in most of them. Salt would be a Group 2 ingredient. Nova calls out adding salt or sugar to Group 1 makes it Group 3, and specifically calls out Group 1 does not contain added salt.

"Minimally processed foods, that together with unprocessed foods make up NOVA group 1, are unprocessed foods altered by industrial processes such as removal of inedible or unwanted parts, drying, crushing, grinding, fractioning, roasting, boiling, pasteurization, refrigeration, freezing, placing in containers, vacuum packaging or non-alcoholic fermentation. None of these processes add salt, sugar, oils or fats, or other food substances to the original food." https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10260459/

Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday October 09, 2025 @03:49PM (#45532228)
> Guacamole would count as Group 3 I believe

Too minimally processed-I’d say it’s Group 1. You’re taking Group 1 ingredients (avocado, jalapeño, lime, onion, maybe tomato and cilantro) and chopping, squeezing and pounding them. It can entirely be done with stone tools.

Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by hshdhdhehd on Friday October 10, 2025 @01:55AM (#45535716)
Can be done with just your hand.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by gusgus01 on Saturday October 11, 2025 @10:32PM (#45554655)
Salt is Group 2, isn't it? (Salt is present unless you make a low sodium guacamole or it's a recipe I've never seen)

Salt is the Group 2 ingredient that I was mentioning. Nova calls out adding salt or sugar to Group 1 makes it Group 3, and specifically calls out Group 1 does not contain added salt.

"Minimally processed foods, that together with unprocessed foods make up NOVA group 1, are unprocessed foods altered by industrial processes such as removal of inedible or unwanted parts, drying, crushing, grinding, fractioning, roasting, boiling, pasteurization, refrigeration, freezing, placing in containers, vacuum packaging or non-alcoholic fermentation. None of these processes add salt, sugar, oils or fats, or other food substances to the original food." https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10260459/

Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by robertlagrant on Thursday October 09, 2025 @05:55AM (#45525562)
What's the minimally processed food that bread is made of?
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday October 09, 2025 @06:02AM (#45525606)
> What's the minimally processed food that bread is made of?

Flour is minimally processed, Nova Group 1, if it’s simply milled and separated. If it’s prepared with industrial solvents, or bleached, it goes straight to Group 4.

Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by robertlagrant on Thursday October 09, 2025 @06:07AM (#45525644)
Is flour considered food at all? It sounds more like an ingredient than a food.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday October 09, 2025 @06:13AM (#45525685)
> sounds more like an ingredient than a food

Nova doesn’t distinguish between ingredients and food [1]. (It needs to be able to do this. UPFs are defined, in part, by almost lacking low-Nova inputs.)

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nova_classification

Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by IAmBroom on Thursday October 09, 2025 @10:07AM (#45527932)
You can eat it and survive.

Cooking it first is a big improvement, but the same is true of carrots, IMO.

Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by chithanh on Thursday October 09, 2025 @06:30AM (#45525778)
Bread is a bit of an exception here, as it undergoes extensive mechanical (milling), biochemical (fermentation) and thermal (baking) processing. Yet it does not count as ultra-processed.

Bread is made from dough, which is mainly made from flour (the "minimally processed" food), which is made from grains (the unprocessed food)

Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by robertlagrant on Thursday October 09, 2025 @06:35AM (#45525800)
It definitely stood out as a bit of a confounding example. That combined with the emotive language used in the classification names makes me a bit wary of this way of classifying food.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by eisen_matrix on Thursday October 09, 2025 @06:02AM (#45525607)
AFAIK, whole-wheat flour is considered minimally processed. Of course bread is not equal, so it was more about home-made/sourdough types, not high-processed, shelf-stable ones.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by danielheath on Thursday October 09, 2025 @05:59AM (#45525596)
Flour is processed from grains
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by dpassens on Thursday October 09, 2025 @06:04AM (#45525626)
Flour, presumably.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by woadwarrior01 on Thursday October 09, 2025 @05:52AM (#45525543)
Biscuits and crisps are generally considered to be ultra processed foods, despite containing only basic ingredients.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday October 09, 2025 @05:56AM (#45525568)
> Biscuits and crisps are generally considered to be ultra processed foods, despite containing only basic ingredients

Depends on if they’re ultra processed or not.

If they won’t stale for weeks, they’re ultra processed with preservatives and/or solvents. If they go stale and have a simple ingredients list, they probably aren’t.

(And kids don’t need to be habituated to having either with every lunch.)

Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by fingerlocks on Thursday October 09, 2025 @06:36AM (#45525808)
Salt is a preservative, vinegar is a solvent. Individually or combined they can prevent spoilage indefinitely.

So no, it’s a lot more arbitrary than that.

Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday October 09, 2025 @12:53PM (#45530209)
> Salt is a preservative, vinegar is a solvent.

Sure. But they’re commonly in kitchens and simply produced, making their status as Group 1 and 2 Nova foods unambiguous.

Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by otikik on Thursday October 09, 2025 @06:06AM (#45525636)
Well that is because there's two very different things, both called "cookies".

When a grandma bakes some cookies for their grandchildren she uses only some basic ingredients - eggs, flour, butter, sugar.

For the product that food industries calls as cookies however, the list of ingredients looks like a git SHA.

Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by gusgus01 on Thursday October 09, 2025 @06:16AM (#45525701)
Man, you're missing a bunch of ingredients to actually make tasty cookies. Definitely need some salt. She's probably also using vanilla extract or purchased chocolate chips (or chunks) or cinnamon. Plus the leavening agent, so baking powder (or baking soda and another acid). That's all just for the basic cookies, there's so many options out there using stuff like malted chocolate powder, and that's ignoring making palatable gluten-free cookies.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by otikik on Thursday October 09, 2025 @12:18PM (#45529802)
It was just an example of the kinds of ingredients, not a complete list. Granma is not going to add Potassium bromate, for example.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by gusgus01 on Saturday October 11, 2025 @10:53PM (#45554760)
Yeah, but the point is adding salt raises the "Classification" to processed. Using store bought chocolate chips raises it to ultra processed because it contains ultra processed ingredients.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by bevesce- on Thursday October 09, 2025 @11:11AM (#45528800)
Is there any evidence that those are any healthier? If I'm going to overeat the same amount of calories eating store-bought cookies or grandma-made cookies - is my health outcome any different?
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by otikik on Thursday October 09, 2025 @12:17PM (#45529783)
Depends on where you are. There's food additives that are used in the US that are forbidden in Europe [1]

> The E.U. says that if they can’t dismiss the possibility of harm, they can’t find an additive safe,” Galligan says. In the U.S., the bar is much lower; companies can add new ingredients to their foods without even informing the FDA. “In the U.S., it feels like the FDA is waiting to act until harm is definitely proven,” says Galligan.

[1] https://time.com/7210717/food-additives-us-fda-banned-europe...

Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by throwawaymb on Thursday October 09, 2025 @12:04PM (#45529596)
Absolutely. calories dont tell you much.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by bevesce- on Thursday October 09, 2025 @12:34PM (#45529991)
So what's the evidence? I couldn't find anything. What do they not tell? I assume that macros in homemade and bought cookies are roughly the same.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by lithocarpus on Thursday October 09, 2025 @04:19PM (#45532592)
Yes.

Look into the process used to make soybean oil vs the process used to make butter.

Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by bevesce- on Thursday October 09, 2025 @05:11PM (#45533129)
I'm not sure how is that relevant. My guess would be that saturated fat in butter is worse for health outcome.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by lithocarpus on Thursday October 09, 2025 @08:18PM (#45534351)
We're talking about what makes ultra processed foods unhealthy - the process used to make each ingredient is exactly what is relevant.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by lithocarpus on Thursday October 09, 2025 @04:18PM (#45532579)
Soybean or canola oil is not a basic ingredient.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by b00ty4breakfast on Thursday October 09, 2025 @06:14AM (#45525692)
that would preclude basic ingredients like salt with anti-caking agents or spice blends. Seems kinda silly and arbitrary.
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by defraudbah on Thursday October 09, 2025 @05:11AM (#45525274)
nestle downvoted you
Re:California passes law to ban ultra-processed foods from s... by defraudbah on Thursday October 09, 2025 @12:42PM (#45530085)
whelp, nestle is on me, you will not believe guyz how many upvotes and downvotes i get on this one