News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple accused of ripping off famous Swiss clock design by brink on Thursday September 20, 2012 @11:53PM (#4552127)
I can't downvote you. But I think that this is a prime example of the snarky comments that people are complaining about that are hurting HN's comment quality.
Re:Apple accused of ripping off famous Swiss clock design by mladenkovacevic on Friday September 21, 2012 @12:01AM (#4552151)
I absolutely agree. And I let myself sink to a bit of a troll here; but I don't expect much meaningful discussion can be had on this particular topic so I allowed myself (perhaps undeservedly) to express my indignation in a rather toxic way.
Re:Apple accused of ripping off famous Swiss clock design by mistercow on Friday September 21, 2012 @12:13PM (#4554320)
The way that snarky comments can hurt the community is by hurting people's feelings and making people feel reluctant to show off what they're up to. "Show HN" posts in particular are one of the coolest things about HN, and if people feel like they're going to get torn open just for putting themselves out there, they are unlikely to do so.

So there's nothing intrinsically wrong about snarky comments. It's when the snarky comments are targeted at individuals undeserving of such harshness that there's a problem.

If someone makes a "Show HN" post, and you think their work is incompetent, or that the problem they're solving isn't important, that doesn't excuse being snarky at them.

If, on the other hand, they have blatantly ripped off someone else's work, snarkiness would be fine (assuming you have damned good reason to believe that they did so intentionally, and that they did not ask permission).

We should be happy to make people worry about unethical behavior here before posting, because the ethics of your behavior can usually be assessed by introspection. We should not make people think twice about their work being incompetent before posting, because competence cannot easily be judged through introspection. Only by actually posting and seeing constructive feedback will someone be able to know how they can improve.

Of course, this applies to more than Show HN posts; people who read HN can also have their work posted by other people. The point is that we don't really need to worry about hurting Apple's feelings over blatantly ripping off someone else's work.

Re:Apple accused of ripping off famous Swiss clock design by damian2000 on Friday September 21, 2012 @12:34AM (#4552278)
One man's snarky comment is another man's sarcastic wit.
Re:Apple accused of ripping off famous Swiss clock design by lifthrasiir on Friday September 21, 2012 @01:32AM (#4552466)
Only when the comment is indeed intended to be a sarcasm. If you want to mark the comment sarcasm you have plenty of methods, e.g. </sarcasm>.
Re:Apple accused of ripping off famous Swiss clock design by jamesbritt on Friday September 21, 2012 @01:49AM (#4552508)
For years and years writers have been able to employ sarcasm and dark wit without resorting to blatant labels tipping off the reader, "Joke ahead!"

Why now is this linguistic bludgeon required?

Re:Apple accused of ripping off famous Swiss clock design by jmmcd on Friday September 21, 2012 @05:41AM (#4553029)
When I read your comment I agreed. After reading the many comments down-thread which missed rather obvious sarcasm, I reluctantly disagree.
Re:Apple accused of ripping off famous Swiss clock design by glhaynes on Friday September 21, 2012 @09:12AM (#4553572)
I hate to be all "in the old days", but, really, threads on HN didn't used to be full of snark and jokes, which obviated this problem. I miss that.
Re:Apple accused of ripping off famous Swiss clock design by jamesbritt on Friday September 21, 2012 @01:01PM (#4554547)
Perhaps we should all start assuming that any blunt, snarky comment is really meant as a piss-take. E.g., if you read "Apple is a bunch of blatant design thieves", assume that no one could intend that at face value, so it's really facetious joking meant to express the opposite.

We'll all feel a lot better, and the blunt and snarky will realize that their posts are having the reverse effect expected.

OK, well, we'll at least all feel better.

Re:Apple accused of ripping off famous Swiss clock design by epo on Friday September 21, 2012 @05:16AM (#4552943)
Because most people don't have the ability to write clearly enough to express their intent, and also because there are so many literal minded people out there. Labels and smileys serve the same purpose as laugh tracks on TV programmes, they tell the stupid how to react.
Re:Apple accused of ripping off famous Swiss clock design by adgar on Friday September 21, 2012 @12:42AM (#4552320)
Snarky comments have always existed on HN. Whether they are downvoted or upvoted is up to the community.
Re:Apple accused of ripping off famous Swiss clock design by nettdata on Thursday September 20, 2012 @11:59PM (#4552145)
I think you spelled "sarcasm" wrong...