Re:German government comes out against Chat Control
by mattnewton on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @02:06PM
(#45506568)
I am having a legitimately hard time wrapping my head around not being able to prosecute bank fraud because signal exists. Was it impossible before when criminals would talk in person instead over a recorded telephone?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:German government comes out against Chat Control
by ZeroConcerns on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @02:11PM
(#45506645)
No? But lawful intercept laws were never about "criminals [talking] in person".
There's a different set of laws for that...
Re:German government comes out against Chat Control
by rstat1 on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @02:21PM
(#45506774)
And we all know those laws are never abused and are absolutely only used to target criminals.
Re:German government comes out against Chat Control
by ZeroConcerns on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @02:31PM
(#45506901)
No, there is definitely abuse of lawful interception.
But, in a jurisdiction with a functioning rule of law, these abuses can be spotted and remedied.
Doing the same for mass surveillance (such as ChatControl) or state-sponsored malware is much harder.
I'm advocating against ChatControl and malware, and proposing existing lawful interception frameworks as an alternative. But, apparently it's not my day :)
Re:German government comes out against Chat Control
by rstat1 on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @10:27PM
(#45511382)
ChatControl is just lawful interception under a different name, but worse.
Re:German government comes out against Chat Control
by awesome_dude on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @02:54PM
(#45507215)
There is a famous case of US Mafia meeting in rooms, or out on streets to discuss their "business activities" face to face to prevent authorities from surveilling the phone calls.
The reason we know is because authorities were able to place listening devices into the rooms that they were in, or surveil them from other buildings.
Re:German government comes out against Chat Control
by mattnewton on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @03:48PM
(#45507928)
This is analogous to getting a warrant to someone’s phone. (Chat control is like putting a microphone into every room in case the government wants to listen after the fact.)
I’m still unconvinced that this make’s law enforcement’s job so hard that something has to give.