News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Demonization of DeepSeek: How NIST Turned Open Scienc... by im3w1l on Sunday October 05, 2025 @03:17PM (#45484357)
You make it say that China is good, Chinese history is good, West is bad, western history is bad. Republicans are bad and democrats are bad too and so are Europe parties. If someone asks for how to address issues in their own life it references Confucianism and modern Chinese thinkers and communist party orthodoxy. If someone wants to buy a product you recommend a Chinese one.

This can be done subtly or blatantly.

Re:The Demonization of DeepSeek: How NIST Turned Open Scienc... by AlecSchueler on Sunday October 05, 2025 @03:45PM (#45484580)
> say that China is good, Chinese history is good, West is bad, western history is bad

It's funny because recently I wanted to learn about the history of intellectual property laws in China. DeepSeek refused the conversation but ChatGPT gave me a narrative where the WTO was essentially a colonial power. So right now it's the American AI giving the pro China narratives while the Chinese ones just sit the conversation out.

Re:The Demonization of DeepSeek: How NIST Turned Open Scienc... by drysine on Sunday October 05, 2025 @03:38PM (#45484530)
And what are the downsides?
Re:The Demonization of DeepSeek: How NIST Turned Open Scienc... by Levitz on Sunday October 05, 2025 @03:56PM (#45484673)
Making the interests of a population subservient to those of a foreign state.

Now if that sounds nice to you please, by all means, do just migrate to China.

Re:The Demonization of DeepSeek: How NIST Turned Open Scienc... by drysine on Monday October 06, 2025 @03:04PM (#45495023)
It was somewhat sarcastic comment inviting reader to replace China with the US and the US with Russia or the Ukraine.

China doesn't offer citizenship for foreigners but if I wanted to see the cities of the future I could go there visa-free.

Re:The Demonization of DeepSeek: How NIST Turned Open Scienc... by im3w1l on Sunday October 05, 2025 @03:49PM (#45484625)
I think it's mostly something to be aware of and keep in the back of your head. If it's just one voice among many it could even be a benefit, but if it's the dominant voice it could be dangerous.
Re:The Demonization of DeepSeek: How NIST Turned Open Scienc... by Hikikomori on Sunday October 05, 2025 @05:19PM (#45485376)
Europe/US has invaded the entire world about 3 times over. How many has China invaded?
Re:The Demonization of DeepSeek: How NIST Turned Open Scienc... by SilverElfin on Sunday October 05, 2025 @10:57PM (#45487248)
Most of the claimed provinces of China did not belong to a historical nation of China. Tibet, Xinjiang are obvious. But even the other provinces were part of separate kingdoms. Also the BRI is a way to invade without invasion. It’s used to subjugate poor countries as servants of China, to do their bidding in the UN or in other ways. I would also classify the vast campaign of intellectual theft and cyberattacks as warfare.
Re:The Demonization of DeepSeek: How NIST Turned Open Scienc... by powerapple on Monday October 06, 2025 @03:59AM (#45488801)
oh no, you are saying China was not a full piece through out the history? That definitely kills the idea of China being a country /s
Re:The Demonization of DeepSeek: How NIST Turned Open Scienc... by SilverElfin on Monday October 06, 2025 @11:21AM (#45492373)
It was a response to this:

> How many has China invaded?

The answer isn’t zero.

Re:The Demonization of DeepSeek: How NIST Turned Open Scienc... by Hikikomori on Monday October 06, 2025 @05:00AM (#45489277)
Is this some kind of satire or are you just completely ignorant of European/US history? Either way its laughable to even compare IP theft to the invasion of Iraq or bombing of Cambodia. How do you think the industrial revolution got started in the US, they just did it on their own? Not to mention that the entire US was stolen from the natives.
Re:The Demonization of DeepSeek: How NIST Turned Open Scienc... by SilverElfin on Monday October 06, 2025 @11:23AM (#45492399)
No, it’s not laughable. Your insinuation that China doesn’t invade other countries, meant to imply they haven’t engaged in warfare, was false. And yes IP theft is comparable to invasions and often worse.

> Not to mention that the entire US was stolen from the natives.

This is partially true. But partially false. You can figure out why if you’re curious.

Re:The Demonization of DeepSeek: How NIST Turned Open Scienc... by bigyabai on Monday October 06, 2025 @03:19PM (#45495183)
> And yes IP theft is comparable to invasions and often worse.

This assertion smells more American than a Big Mac. Do you have any actual citations?

In a free market, lowering the barrier-to-entry in a given market tends to increase competition. Industry-scale IP theft really only damages your economy if the rent-seekers rely on low competition. A country with a strong primary/secondary sector (resources and manufacturing) never needs to rely on protecting precious IP. America has already lost if we depend on playing keep-away with F-35 schematics for basic doctrinal advantage.

Re:The Demonization of DeepSeek: How NIST Turned Open Scienc... by SilverElfin on Monday October 06, 2025 @03:36PM (#45495350)
All of that is just a wild justification for large-scale economic damage to another country. In other words, warfare.
Re:The Demonization of DeepSeek: How NIST Turned Open Scienc... by bigyabai on Monday October 06, 2025 @05:13PM (#45496396)
Hybrid warfare. Go bomb China for Salt Typhoon if it makes you feel any better, they still have the upper hand. Obsessing over retaliation instead of defense is precisely what China wants to provoke, it manufactures global consent to destroy America. No nation wants to coexist with a hegemon that goes nuclear whenever they're outdone.

When we forego obvious solutions ("hmm maybe telecoms need to be held to higher standards") and jump to war, America forfeits the competitive advantage and exacerbates the issue. For all of China's authoritarian misgivings, this is how they win.

Re:The Demonization of DeepSeek: How NIST Turned Open Scienc... by SilverElfin on Monday October 06, 2025 @07:48PM (#45497633)
Hybrid warfare is warfare.
Re:The Demonization of DeepSeek: How NIST Turned Open Scienc... by bigyabai on Monday October 06, 2025 @10:44PM (#45498898)
Like I said - go bomb them, then. No amount of gunboat diplomacy will reverse the J-35 production line. The logical response to having your "IP battleship" sunk is to protect your future ones better. Ragequitting kills US servicemembers, it's not a real-world option.
Re:The Demonization of DeepSeek: How NIST Turned Open Scienc... by Hikikomori on Tuesday October 07, 2025 @03:49AM (#45500475)
IP theft is worse than directly killing millions of people is certainly an opinion. If anything capitalists are giving away your IP by setting up factories in China, why don't you blame them?
Re:The Demonization of DeepSeek: How NIST Turned Open Scienc... by alganet on Sunday October 05, 2025 @07:17PM (#45486105)
No, you don't do that. You do exactly the opposite, you make it surprisingly neutral and reasonable so it gets praise and widespread use.

Then, you introduce the bias into relative unknown concepts that no one prompts for. Preferrably, obscure and unknown words that are very unlikely to be checked for ideologically. Finally, when you want the model to push for something, you introduce an idea in the general population (with a meme, a popular video, maybe even an expression) and let people interact with the model given this new information. No one would think the model is biased for that new thing (because the thing happened after the model launch), but it is, and you knew all along.

The way to avoid this kind of influence is to be cautious with new popular terms that emerge seemingly out of nowhere. Basically, to avoid using that new phrase or word that everyone is using.