It sounds like the book itself isn't nihilistic but there may be nihilistic characters in it, which doesn't seem like something worth criticizing it over.
How do you tell that a book with nihilistic characters isn't a nihilistic book? The difference is obvious in principle, but I'm not sure it is in practice.
Re:Cormac McCarthy's personal library
by justupvoting on Thursday October 02, 2025 @08:06AM
(#45448588)
I can't think of a single character in the book for whom nihilism is their defining trait, and certainly not the primary characters. The effort to preserve goodness in the world only really matters when it's hard, when it comes at cost. The book turns that up to 11, but that is why it is hopeful.
If you want to read McCarthy doing nihilism, maybe try the sunset limited.
Re:Cormac McCarthy's personal library
by philipallstar on Thursday October 02, 2025 @08:49AM
(#45448966)
> I think his detractors are right, it is violent, nihilistic, masculine and whatever else.
Thinking masculine is a criticism is quite a tell.
My daughter and I talk about the message in the book regularly. Though she has yet to read it. I see more clearly my purpose as a dad and as a member in my community. Totally worth the read.