News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by coldtea on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @07:39AM (#45345587)
>with the justification that by making their citizens lives horrific, you encourage them to rise against their government.

That's the PR justification. The real one is "to hurt the countries and make them do as we say" and "because we can".

[dead]
Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by sporkxrocket on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @09:23AM (#45346667)
This is an ultra simplistic take. Iran does not like the role the US has in propping up Israel, entirely rational and understandable. Israel may not be recognized by our government as a "sworn enemy" but it's done infinitely more damage to the US and US citizens than Iran has. The only reason they're not sanctioned is because one of the ways Israel attacks the US is through bribery (AIPAC) and blackmail (Epstein).
Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by deanishe on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @12:13PM (#45349051)
> The only reason they're not sanctioned

Aren't a lot of your religious fundies Zionists because the believe Jesus isn't coming back unless there are Jews in the Levant?

[dead]
Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by sporkxrocket on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @10:10AM (#45347284)
Israel literally killed 4 Americans two days ago.
Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by vorpalhex on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @12:16PM (#45349082)
That statement is entirely false. None of the people killed in the Lebanon strike were American. DHS commented on it this morning, and Lebanon the day prior.

You really need to evaluate your news sources. That claim was suspect when it was made initially (there are VERY few Americans in Lebanon, especially in Hezbollah areas) and it has been debunked twice since it was made.

Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by sporkxrocket on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @12:57PM (#45349747)
Incorrect, Israel killed an entire American family:

https://www.msn.com/en-us/war-and-conflicts/military/four-am...

DHS nor the IDF are credible sources and neither have backed up their claims. That’s pure propaganda on their end.

Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by vorpalhex on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @05:29PM (#45352993)
Ah yes, The Daily Express, well known and very solid source.

Here's CNN: https://www.cnn.com/2025/09/21/middleeast/israeli-strike-leb...

Also from The Daily Express:

Cinnamon cures Alzheimers: https://www.msn.com/en-us/health/other/common-kitchen-spice-...

What time is Rapture today: https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/opinion/what-time-is-rapture-...

and no less than eight stories about the Presley family: https://www.msn.com/en-us/tv/celebrity/priscilla-presley-rev...

If you believe the AI slop news shop over government agencies, please make sure your psychiatrist is aware so they can dose your meds as appropriate.

Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by sporkxrocket on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @05:37PM (#45353077)
The CNN article is just parroting IDF propaganda about the killings being “disputed” (by the murderers) with zero proof to back up that assertion.
[dead]
Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by cramsession on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @11:07AM (#45348141)
Israel will be dissolved as the older generations die off. At that point we can fully remove ourselves from the Middle East. It's not our oil anyway, let's focus on other energy sources that don't require propping up synthetic states and causing worldwide terror.
[dead]
Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by bichiliad on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @10:06AM (#45347244)
This is extremely reductive. Just as OP doesn’t support Russia in its war against Ukraine, and just as many US citizens don’t support America’s actions abroad, there aren’t any countries that teach their kids to chant “death to America” for the fun of it. Not to mention the fact that there are options that aren’t “economic oppression” or “war.”
Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by simianparrot on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @10:19AM (#45347406)
Why would "for the fun of it" be a prerequisite for it to be bad..?

If someone shouts "death to <my name>" from across the street, I take it _very_ seriously.

I fully understand the history between Iran and the US, but you you can't have suicidal empathy with an enemy state that trains its people to want you dead.

Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by somenameforme on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @10:50AM (#45347888)
If you visit Iran (or pretty much anywhere) as an American you'll have zero issues with the people. Here [1] is a thread of various people visiting Iran, and it's 100% typical. The average Iranian has no problems with an American than anybody else - they have a problem with the American government. And the two are obviously two extremely different things.

The one piece of advice that shouldn't need to be said, but does, is that when traveling to Rome you need to do as the Romans do. You probably would have problems if e.g. you bring a homosexual partner along and make that relationship apparent in public, are a woman who tries go without a hijab, etc. Be respectful of the culture, and people will be respectful of you - regardless of where you happen to come from.

[1] - https://www.reddit.com/r/travel/comments/111xz3l/comment/j8p...

Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by simianparrot on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @12:18PM (#45349115)
And I wrote that the US is at war with an enemy _state_. The state represents its people, but it is not _all of_ the people. I always see people derailing these discussions in this manner when it's always patently obvious that we aren't conflating the two.
Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by somenameforme on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @01:29PM (#45350228)
But you are specifically conflating the two. Not only in your implication that Iranians, normal Iranians - children even, want Americans dead, but in your defense of sanctions. Sanctions have no meaningful affect on countries - as in the political leadership and military, but can have a substantially negative impact on the people within that country. In many ways they are even more barbaric than war, because at least in war there is a viable goal and you are targeting the state and its military. Civilians are unfortunate 'collateral damage', not the target.

With sanctions you just inflict suffering on the people for no realistic reason or goal. The idea it'll drive people to overthrow their government and align themselves with the people inflicting mass suffering on them is just so inexorably stupid. It's not even illogical - it is anti-logical. I expect that one day it will be looked upon in the same way that today we might look back on drawing and quartering people as a punishment.

Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by simianparrot on Wednesday September 24, 2025 @03:53AM (#45357515)
Any warfare hurts civilians. And there's no kinetic warfare that is guaranteed to not hit civilians. In fact we can observe how impossible that is all throughout the world, today.

I'm fairly sure given the choice, civilians would rather their country be sanctioned than bombed. Obviously the best option is no conflict at all, but that's utopian.

Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by somenameforme on Wednesday September 24, 2025 @04:41AM (#45357800)
The Lancet just released a study on this exact question. [1] From 1971 to 2021, "unilateral, economic, and US sanctions" were associated with some 564,258 deaths per year, disproportionately affecting children under 5, who are most sensitive to disruptions in healthcare or food. That's 1,544 deaths per day - for 30 years.

By contrast as of August 31st 2025, the UN has assessed a total of 14,116 civilian deaths in Ukraine [2], about 10 per day, in one of the largest land wars in quite some time, and one where military casualties are certainly in the millions. War will always be with us - it's simply the final stage of irreconcilable differences. But I think sanctions will go down as one of those things people look back at wondering how we could ever do that to each other. Again I think the parallel with random forms of torture before execution are apt. One can support the death penalty and be completely disgusted by drawing and quartering. It's just unnecessary sadism and cruelty that serves no purpose.

For some related comic relief I recommend this skit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h242eDB84zY

[1] - https://www.thelancet.com/journals/langlo/article/PIIS2214-1...

[2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casualties_of_the_Russo-Ukrain...

Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by simianparrot on Wednesday September 24, 2025 @07:48AM (#45359036)
I'll put the blame on the sanctioned countries' leadership.

If Iran wants to avoid sanctions, all they have to do is not flirt with nuclear weapons.

Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by somenameforme on Wednesday September 24, 2025 @08:52AM (#45359601)
As of March 2025, the US intelligence had assessed that Iran was neither building nor pursuing a nuclear a weapon. [1] Claims to the contrary can from Netanyahu who is increasingly obviously an unstable individual. Notably the 'flip flop' when Trump decided to invade Iran was precipitated on very careful language that Iran could have a weapon if they chose to pursue it, under a likely exaggerated timeline. It's not really a flip flop as both statements can be, and probably were, true.

So why was Iran so close to a nuclear weapon in the first place? What happened is that after years of enriching at a normal level Iran suffered yet another attack from the US/Israel in 2021 that caused significant damage to their nuclear facilities. [2] Following this they increased enrichment to 60%, which is just below weapons grade, to make a point that they were entirely capable of making a nuclear weapon, but had made a conscious decision not to.

Following the latest US/Israel attacks on them, I think it's fairly certain that they will develop a nuke, if not only because it's increasingly obviously the only way they can stop the endless US/Israel attacks. Ultimately, you're not going to be able to stop a country full of brilliant individuals from building a nuke if they want it. It seems likely that Iran was negotiating in good faith, and then we literally launched an invasion on them mid-negotiation. What's the point of negotiating?

[1] - https://www.newsweek.com/tulsi-gabbard-iran-nuclear-weapon-2...

[2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Natanz_incident

Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by simianparrot on Thursday September 25, 2025 @06:12AM (#45371123)
And then they got new intel. Iran is also the primary sponsor of international terrorism, and the entire EU is aligned on sanctioning Iran. I know history of western intervention in the Middle East is full of terrible mistakes, but that doesn't mean we should turn the other cheek. I'd argue we've been to lenient on that front, in many ways.

I don't want us directly interfering in the Middle East, but I also don't want us supporting regimes that are diametrically opposed to our own ways of life. And sanctions are the way to do this.

Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by somenameforme on Thursday September 25, 2025 @09:42AM (#45372544)
No, they did not get new intel.

The reason the US acts the way it does in the US is not based on any immediate logic. There's a great paper, "Rebuilding America's Defenses" that describes US foreign policy in extremely straight forward language. It was written during Bush's era, but many of the people with their names on it are part of the effectively permanent political establishment.

Their goal was (and perhaps if they're delusional - still is) to maintain hegemonic control over the entire world. The main motivation for things like attacking Iran is 'projecting force.' It's supposed to work to intimidate other countries into deference and compliance without having to actually get involved in a battle with them. Basically mimicking how school bullies work.

So you're looking for a reasonable explanation based on superficial pretexts, but there is none. The same is true of Iraq. It's not like we really thought there were WMD. But it was simply an opportunity to project power and keep the military industrial complex churning.

Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by simianparrot on Thursday September 25, 2025 @01:34PM (#45376074)
I'm well aware of Iraq and the US military industrial complex. But two wrongs don't make a right.

I'm all for sanctioning Iran until they capitulate. The end.

Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by coldtea on Wednesday September 24, 2025 @05:23AM (#45358003)
>And I wrote that the US is at war with an enemy _state_

The US toppled it's democratically elected leader in the 50s, installed a brutal "king" dictator, and when they finally overthrew him it armed their neighborhood Iraq to wage war on them killing millions, then enforced global sanctions to it (causing tremendous damage to its economy and operation), and still meddles in the region.

Them saying some slogans like that is not even a blip on the radar, compared to the murderous shit the US has done to them for profit and spite.

The nerve for the US to play the victim here...

Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by simianparrot on Thursday September 25, 2025 @01:36PM (#45376109)
First off I'm not American, just to be clear. But I don't see the US playing the victim. They're involved in a conflict.

Iranians are playing victims, and they are, but they're victims to their own government's actions, being the foremost funder of anti-west terrorism and sentiment.

If they want things to change, I'd look at the closer threat -- their theocratic government.

Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by somenameforme on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @10:19AM (#45347402)
I don't think this needs much "teaching." We overthrew their secular democracy in 1953 and installed an extremely unpopular autocratic monarchy. They were then overthrown in a "real" revolution in 1979 which is when they became an Islamic Republic. Since then we've spent decades trying to overthrow their government, actively assassinating their leaders and scientists, bombing their country, providing material support to Israel to regularly go batshit over there and so on. And I haven't even touched on sanctions. We're not exactly coming off as the good guys here.

Beyond this, it's a very poor analogy because the overwhelming majority of sanctions would be a war crime as they intentionally target civilians with no military value.

Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by simianparrot on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @12:23PM (#45349188)
Sanctions are not war crimes by any definition.

I am fully aware of the US' history in the middle east, as well Europe's role and my own country within Europe. But that doesn't mean we should accept this kind of rhetoric from enemy states.

If you go down this rabbit hole of "historical rights", where does it end? The truth it it never ends. You go far enough back and we're all the assholes.

So all we can do is move forward and respond to threats like these the best we can.

Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by somenameforme on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @01:20PM (#45350123)
This doesn't require any lengthy history. We're still killing Iranians regularly and pretty much arbitrarily, as well as backing Israel doing the same in a borderline psychotic fashion. And you're here fear mongering about them saying 'Death to America' which is pretty much the equivalent of waving a stick at somebody after they just burnt down your house with your family in it.
Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by simianparrot on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @02:23PM (#45350891)
And Iran has waged proxy wars on Americans, civilians and military personnel alike, for four decades.

The countries are at war. It's just not kinetic, ie. with troops on the battlefield. That is reality. I know it sucks, but you can't expect the US to just let the threat be. It's not like US is alone in wanting to suppress Iran's threat anyway; you can blame most European countries for aiding in that suppression.

I won't get into the religious underpinnings but they are significant. This isn't resolved by the US just letting Iran be.

Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by somenameforme on Tuesday September 23, 2025 @11:45PM (#45356065)
Iran has not been attacking US civilians. This is nonsense. The best you're going to come up with there is the Iran hostage crisis. And what was that? That was when Iranian students stormed and occupied the US embassy, almost 50 years ago, demanding that the US extradite Mohammed Reza Pahlavi - the tyrant that the US had installed in Iran after overthrowing their government, who was then granted asylum after he was overthrown and fled to the US following events like the Jaleh Square massacre. [1]

In the end 0 civilians were harmed and it led to the Algiers Accords [1] under which its chief provision is that the US would not intervene politically or militarily in Iranian internal affairs. Besides the US obviously endlessly violating that, we also violated another section of the treaty (related to the settlement of litigation) almost immediately after it was signed.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Friday_(1978)

[2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Algiers_Accords_(1981)

Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by simianparrot on Wednesday September 24, 2025 @07:48AM (#45359041)
They have by proxy, that's why I used that word specifically.
Re:Delete FROM users WHERE location = 'Iran'; by somenameforme on Wednesday September 24, 2025 @09:11AM (#45359826)
No they haven't. A proxy war is what we have going on between the US and Russia in Ukraine. You instead have autonomous groups, largely affiliated primarily by religion (like Hezbollah), that receive support from Iran. It's more akin to the situation with Saudi Arabia where extremists of their flavor of Islam, including Al Qaeda, often find material and personnel support. For instance 15 of the 19 attackers from 9/11 were Saudi.

And I doubt you'd call Al Qaeda a 'Saudi proxy' or 9/11 a Saudi-US proxy war. It's nonsensical.