News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by JKCalhoun on Sunday September 21, 2025 @12:43PM (#45324346)
I'm surprised this needed to be a law. Or wasn't already one?

Or maybe I'm just surprised that a group of law enforcement officers would decide, "Hey, we don't want people to know who we are," and decide to wear masks.

"…I think this is what the state of California is trying to do. Establish limits as to how much the federal government can do within the jurisdiction of the state. It's an issue of state sovereignty."

More of the Cold Civil War playing out. (Also see coastal states forming health cooperatives (?) so that their citizens can get COVID vaccines, etc.)

Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by BugsJustFindMe on Sunday September 21, 2025 @12:48PM (#45324406)
> Or maybe I'm just surprised that a group of law enforcement officers would decide, "Hey, we don't want people to know who we are," and decide to wear masks.

It would be nice to be surprised. It _should_ be surprising. It's unfortunately not surprising at all.

Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by spwa4 on Sunday September 21, 2025 @02:00PM (#45325100)
Youth services has been hiding the names of their employees for more than a decade now. A few years back the final shoe dropped: now kids aren't even allowed to know the name of the judge that took them away from their home anymore.

They cite, of course, the same argument ICE makes: threats against them.

Is that legal? Well, their theory is that any kind of "family law" proceeding (including convicting minors of crimes, and locking them up without access to family or schooling for years) is considered civil law. Therefore none of the normal legal rights apply. I would think this is trivially a violation of the constitution, especially because it comes to imprisonment, but clearly it is not, since the justice department has no problems doing it. A child can be locked up for a crime (up to when they get 27 years old, yes, not 18, in some states), even if the present proof they didn't do it. The very, very, very basic legal right to not get convicted of a crime that you didn't do is openly violated by youth services. Right to have a trial? Nope. Right to having the state prove their case? Nope. Right to not get locked up without cause? No. Etc.

Needless to say, this was promptly exploited by some states who gave kickbacks to judges who "delivered" juveniles for private detention facilities. When caught doing this, the justice department promptly declared nobody had done anything wrong (except one of the judges who, in addition to having thousands of kids locked up for money, had lied on his taxes. He was never actually imprisoned, and finally pardoned by the president)

Oh and in case you don't know: locking minors away from school? Yes. Youth services does that. Parents aren't allowed to do that. Schools aren't allowed to do that. The police isn't allowed to do that (minor gets arrested, and wants to go to classes or do your homework? Police has to make it happen). Fucking death row isn't allowed to keep a minor out of school. But youth services IS allowed to do it.

So a secret police in the US? This is not new. What's new is that immigration enforcement started doing it on a large scale.

Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by _DeadFred_ on Monday September 22, 2025 @11:36AM (#45334930)
The US has used civil law to remove all kinds of rights. A person can make a plea deal (civil/contract law) that supersedes the government having to observe that persons constitutional rights and can erase all of their constitutional rights.

The government shouldn't be able to threaten you with 50 years in prison if you don't give up your rights. And they definitely shouldn't be able to tell a just that the agreement/plea wasn't coerced. But here we are.

Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by tjwebbnorfolk on Sunday September 21, 2025 @12:49PM (#45324415)
If my next door neighbor is having a warrant served, should I be able to walk over there and demand to see ID of the cops serving the warrant? That seems crazy to me.

If I am not a party to a law enforcement action, I'm not sure why I'd have any right to demand the identity of an officer at ICE or FBI or anywhere else.

Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by flufluflufluffy on Sunday September 21, 2025 @01:10PM (#45324632)
What about when your next door neighbor is walking down your street when an unmarked van pulls up and a bunch of masked men in plain clothes grab her off the street and throw her in the van? (Which literally is what is happening)
Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by johncarlosbaez on Sunday September 21, 2025 @01:19PM (#45324711)
Quoting https://thenieveslawfirm.com/do-police-have-to-identify-them...:

You’re minding your own business when a police officer approaches you. They start asking questions, but something feels off. You ask for their name and badge number, but they refuse. What do you do?

As a citizen, you want to trust and cooperate with law enforcement, but you also have rights that must be protected. The question of whether police officers are legally required to identify themselves when asked is a complex one, with no easy answers.

In general, no, a police officer does not have to identify themselves even if you ask them—making it even more important to invoke your right to silence no matter who you think you’re talking to.

California Penal Code Section 830.10 states:

“Any uniformed peace officer shall wear a badge, nameplate, or other device which bears clearly on its face the identification number or name of the officer.”

However, there are a couple of key issues with this law that limit its effectiveness in ensuring police accountability:

    The law only applies to uniformed officers, meaning that plainclothes officers or those working undercover are not required to wear any identifying information.
    Even for uniformed officers, the law doesn’t explicitly require them to make their badge number or name easily visible or accessible to the public. An officer could potentially wear their identifying information in a manner that is obscured or difficult to read.
Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by grayhatter on Sunday September 21, 2025 @01:59PM (#45325092)
> An officer could potentially wear their identifying information in a manner that is obscured or difficult to read.

Yeah... but they could also not wear a badge. I doubt that'll fly

> or other device which bears clearly on its face the identification number or name of the officer.

Any reasonable court would find that wearing a badge in a manner that obscured the number or name would not be "clearly wearing" said badge. Is the officer an ethical person who makes a good faith attempt to follow the law they're hired to uphold, and will the court be reasonable are both questions that don't change what the law clearly expects and requires.

Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by puppycodes on Sunday September 21, 2025 @04:04PM (#45326159)
Sorry but this is bootlicker logic.

Yes you should.

Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by lazide on Sunday September 21, 2025 @12:54PM (#45324465)
Typically, you wouldn’t need to - they are supposed to have their names and ID’s on their badges.

And as long as you’re not actively interfering with something they are doing, yes you can and should be able to do exactly that.

Because you’re a member of the public, and you should be able to complain and if they are doing something bad, they should actually be held accountable to it.

Crazy eh?

ICE and the like know what they’re doing, and why.

[dead]
Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by BugsJustFindMe on Monday September 22, 2025 @07:40AM (#45332036)
> Show me the law that says

Ignoring your obvious straw man about criminal allegation details, surely you are aware that the law and morally correct or societally important behavior patterns are not the same thing. Indeed, there's no law saying that the law need align with what's actually good for the electorate. Waving your hands at "the law" when discussing ethics, justice, fundamental rights, societal good, and the prevention of falling directly into a boots-on-necks martial state is a stupid game that leads nowhere. Laws change.

Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by BugsJustFindMe on Sunday September 21, 2025 @12:57PM (#45324492)
Hiding their identity completely undermines accountability.

It's also an extremely glaring public safety risk to normalize people who refuse to identify themselves using force and guns to grab and pull people off the street with nothing more than a "trust me, bro".

Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by tjwebbnorfolk on Sunday September 21, 2025 @01:00PM (#45324520)
We have a court system to adjudicate these things. It is up to the detainee's lawyers and the courts to decide if the action was justified, not some rando on the street whose only knowledge of the situation consists of "I don't like what I'm seeing and it makes me feel bad"
Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by fknorangesite on Sunday September 21, 2025 @01:20PM (#45324719)
How a I supposed to know that the masked person hauling off my neighbour is, in fact, actual law enforcement? How can I be sure they will ever even see that courtroom?

Did I just witness an arrest or a kidnapping? Who knows! And when the police become secret police, is there a difference?

Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by pandaman on Sunday September 21, 2025 @04:08PM (#45326192)
Call the police and report? It's not like you know every LEO by face and only masks prevent you from identifying them.
Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by fknorangesite on Sunday September 21, 2025 @06:58PM (#45327431)
Awesome now they know who I am, too.

This your first encounter with a chilling effect?

Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by pandaman on Sunday September 21, 2025 @08:49PM (#45328050)
No, I've been observing hysterical redditors on this site since January.
Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by sixothree on Sunday September 21, 2025 @01:05PM (#45324575)
This country was founded on the concepts of checks and balances. And there are no checks "law enforcement".
Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by JKCalhoun on Sunday September 21, 2025 @05:47PM (#45326966)
Are worried when they are arresting you and are masked and without ID?
Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by FirmwareBurner on Sunday September 21, 2025 @12:52PM (#45324443)
>I'm surprised this needed to be a law. Or wasn't already one?

SWAT officers also wear masks when on mission, for their own protection, so why should ICE have to unmask by law?

Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by sigwinch on Sunday September 21, 2025 @12:59PM (#45324516)
I think you have it backwards: this applies to SWAT and is very unlikely to be respected by ICE.
[dead]
Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by sigwinch on Sunday September 21, 2025 @01:05PM (#45324582)
Well, the governor of California represents 14% of the US economy, more than the smallest 25 other governors added together. Something about California works for free market capitalism and thats easier to cover than a big group of other states.
Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by FirmwareBurner on Sunday September 21, 2025 @02:58PM (#45325608)
Is California 14% of the US economy BECAUSE of who is the governor of California TODAY?
Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by LeafItAlone on Sunday September 21, 2025 @11:13PM (#45328759)
https://www.ppic.org/publication/californias-economy/

Here is some data on California’s economy. You tell me how to interpret it.

Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by sigwinch on Sunday September 21, 2025 @11:30PM (#45328825)
Well, he’s chosen by the people of California. And those people have a per-capita GDP higher than the top four economies.
Re:California bans masks meant to hide law enforcement offic... by jyounker on Monday September 22, 2025 @05:41AM (#45331066)
Not any more.