News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by randyrand on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @10:17PM (#45284297)
Wow, Slack does not allow business customers to export their chats. WTF. Found this:

"Workspace Owners can apply for Corporate Export. This lets you export all messages (including DMs and private channels), but only if your company has legal or compliance requirements and Slack approves the request. Once approved, exports are scheduled and delivered automatically."

So they have the tech built, you just aren't allowed to use it. Who would use this piece of garbage?

Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by userbinator on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @10:21PM (#45284343)
IMHO "allow" is a rather moot term, when you already have access. Their API is surprisingly well-documented; when I worked at a place that used Slack, I had a logger hooked up to a local database, which was very useful when their not-quite-search failed to give any results for a comment that you and others very clearly remember making.
Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by edoceo on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @10:38PM (#45284530)
Yes. If you use Slack, make your own archive.

I, I just have to mention that IRC had these archives so repeat questions had a corpus to search. The walled gardens don't.

For my teams the "modern" solution is Mattermost. My (biased) feelings are that it's 10x better than free-slack and 100x better than paid.

Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by MontyCarloHall on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @11:05PM (#45284765)
>IRC had these archives so repeat questions had a corpus to search

It did? I used IRC pretty frequently back in the day, and the only logging I ever saw was through your own client. This was in the days of dialup, so you'd miss any conversations from when you weren't logged in. If you were fancy, you'd have a bouncer set up on an always-on remote server to log messages when you were away. But I never saw any centralized logging à la Slack/Teams/Mattermost. It's certainly not something supported by any IRCd I'm aware of. Maybe a few channels had custom bots that logged everything to a centrally searchable location, but I never saw such a thing.

Indeed, some here even tout the "ephemeral nature of IRC as a feature, not a bug." [0]

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32000415

Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by skydhash on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @11:23PM (#45284905)
The ephemeral is indeed a bug. Anything important should be saved somewhere else (notes, decisions, docs, wiki,..) IRC is the same as watercooler or quick group meeting, no one brings a recorder to have everything on file.
Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by edoceo on Thursday September 18, 2025 @12:51AM (#45285554)
Friend, back in the day many email and IRC rooms were archived. I wave my hat to a thing called MARC. One used to use Google (pre-stackoverflow) and see threads from the OGs. And one could find the core-expert lurking. Sometimes you could make a personal connection.

I miss the old Internet.

And get off my lawn!

Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by madaxe_again on Thursday September 18, 2025 @01:59AM (#45285979)
You can just run bots. We had one who was responsible for archiving everything so it was searchable, and would allow you to search, another which would allow you to do deployments, and another which complained about severe errors in the critical environments.

I still don’t understand what slack can do that IRC and a few bots can’t.

Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by userbinator on Thursday September 18, 2025 @02:15AM (#45286105)
Plenty of communities kept IRC archives.

Here's Ubuntu: https://irclogs.ubuntu.com/

Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by commandar on Thursday September 18, 2025 @10:58AM (#45290521)
>I just have to mention that IRC had these archives so repeat questions had a corpus to search. The walled gardens don't.

For many businesses, this is a feature, not a bug.

Internal communications are discoverable in litigation. If you have records, you can be compelled to turn them over.

I used to work in healthcare. Internal messages had a maximum retention of 30 days. That wasn't driven by IT or the users. That was a decision made by legal. In that space, you are always being sued by somebody. The lawyers want to minimize exposure and that's a fight they're basically always going to win.

To be clear: it's better if that's a decision made by the business. But it's also one of those cases where what the decision makers care about isn't necessarily aligned with what the users care about, so there's ultimately not a lot of incentive for Slack to care.

Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by coder543 on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @10:44PM (#45284586)
Zulip wrote a fun article about this a couple of months ago: https://blog.zulip.com/2025/07/24/who-owns-your-slack-histor...
Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by smelendez on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @10:24PM (#45284374)
Makes some sense to me.

In some cases, as Slack says, there may be a legal mandate to log employee conversations, but in other situations there may be legal restrictions on reading employee-to-employee conversations. That all probably varies by jurisdiction.

And then you have more complicated situations, like companies that use Slack to offer tech support to their customers, or random open-source projects or local volunteer projects using Slack. They might pay for a business license for various features, but it's probably not clear to every member that that would mean whoever set up the Slack account should get to read everyone else's correspondence.

You also want some kind of safety check to make sure that a random IT guy who set up the Slack system at a small company isn't reading through people's DMs and private channels to stalk people or access confidential information.

Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by ejstronge on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @10:36PM (#45284503)
> but in other situations there may be legal restrictions on reading employee-to-employee conversations.

In which US jurisdictions can employee-to-employee records (from employer-owned communication media) be denied to the employer/customer but maintained by an unrelated third party?

Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by zdragnar on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @11:01PM (#45284737)
Organizations aren't limited to a single country. My current client has employees in most of, if not every, time zone across the world.

As such, you need to be able to review the legal status of every pairing or group of people's private chats.

At any point in time a US based customer might invite a EU based customer, so looking specifically at US jurisdictions is irrelevant.

Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by ejstronge on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @11:10PM (#45284801)
> Organizations aren't limited to a single country. My current client has employees in most of, if not every, time zone across the world.

In a single legal entity?

> At any point in time a US based customer might invite a EU based customer, so looking specifically at US jurisdictions is irrelevant.

What case law are you considering when you insinuate that Slack must review the retention of records between users of a Slack business customer?

Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by swiftcoder on Thursday September 18, 2025 @03:23AM (#45286597)
The EU user's messages are governed by the GDPR, regardless of jurisdiction, surely?
Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by notpushkin on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @10:26PM (#45284405)
Yeah, but exporting public channels shouldn’t be a problem, no?
Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by smelendez on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @10:31PM (#45284447)
Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by notpushkin on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @10:48PM (#45284622)
Nice! I’d say most of the knowledge can be preserved that way then.

(But I would also start making backups regularly, because who knows if how long this would last)

Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by artursapek on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @10:26PM (#45284402)
Big soulless corps inevitably get greedy. It’s pretty depressing
Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by Kirth on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @10:41PM (#45284555)
Let's be honest; how many Slack messages or conversations older than 2-3 weeks still have value?
Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by novatea on Thursday September 18, 2025 @12:09AM (#45285283)
In Hack Club, a lot. I'm a teen in HC, many projects run for months and have very valuable messages for a long time.
Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by p-t on Thursday September 18, 2025 @08:12AM (#45288650)
Adding on to this, a lot of people don't want their personal chats deleted either!
Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by joshstrange on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @10:45PM (#45284598)
95% might have little value or zero but 5% of them are gold, it’s just not always clear which 5% is the gold until you need it.
Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by JambalayaJimbo on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @10:45PM (#45284588)
Slack is the first place I search for any issue at my company and I frequently take advantage of 3-4 year old threads
Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by mitthrowaway2 on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @10:46PM (#45284600)
In BC, engineering firms are legally required to maintain project documentation for 10 years, including slack messages.
Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by dzhiurgis on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @10:44PM (#45284577)
Slacks biggest value is ephemeral nature. Forces you to document in proper places.
Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by layman51 on Thursday September 18, 2025 @12:45AM (#45285510)
I'm actually part of some Slack workspaces that are on the free plan which hides messages (including DMs) older than 90 days. It is actually quite cumbersome then because if someone sends a valuable message, I have to remember to screenshot or better yet copy-paste it into a durable spot or else I'm going to have to ask again about the same thing.
Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by insane_dreamer on Thursday September 18, 2025 @01:00AM (#45285606)
We use Slack extensively and I'm searching for info in conversations from months or even years ago regularly.
Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by cj on Thursday September 18, 2025 @12:55AM (#45285579)
The application process is a short form and a few clicks. They don't have a high bar for being accepted.
Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by nbngeorcjhe on Thursday September 18, 2025 @02:40AM (#45286279)
> only if your company has legal or compliance requirements

clearly they need to sue themselves and demand their slack history in discovery

Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by Cort3z on Thursday September 18, 2025 @03:36AM (#45286705)
Makes some sense that the owner can't just eavesdrop on every conversation on the platform. That is very illegal many places in the world.
Re:Slack has raised our charges by $195k per year by bux93 on Thursday September 18, 2025 @04:24AM (#45287024)
In 30 places, it's also very illegal to do business with vendors who ransom your data, if you're in finance, i.e. an entity covered by the Digital Operational Resilience Act; NIS2 (27 places) doesn't spell it out but also requires business continuity planning. Natural persons in the EU+EEA also retain a right to data portability under GDPR and there are data access/portability provisions in the EU Data ACT and DMA. Many legal frameworks require the covered entity to be 'in control' of vendors and data. Proactive legalese allowing the vendor to ransom your data is not quite in line with that requirement; in many sane jurisdictions such clauses would be found unenforceable.