News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by nailer on Friday September 12, 2025 @04:40PM (#45226508)
> If we could ask Charlie, I am sure he'd also think it was worth it!

Yes, agreed. He already did. He wouldn't want to disarm the nation to prevent his own death.

> I have no sympathy for white supremacists

Yes agreed, I sure Kirk would agree too, but that's offtopic here.

> Charlie once said that George Floyd was a "scumbag"

George Floyd was a scumbag. If you hold a gun to a pregnant woman's stomach, you're a scumbag.

> I am sure Charlie would have greatly appreciated me exercising my first!

Yes, agreed. He wouldn't share your opinion but he would support your right to free speech.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by ath3nd on Friday September 12, 2025 @04:55PM (#45226663)
> Yes agreed, but we're not talking about one.

Charlie Kirk was a white supremacist.

"Prowling Blacks go around for fun to go target white people -- that’s a fact" https://www.mediamatters.org/charlie-kirk/charlie-kirk-goes-...

"I have a very, very radical view on this, but I can defend it, and I've thought about it. We made a huge mistake when we passed the Civil Rights Act in the mid-1960s." https://ca.news.yahoo.com/fact-check-charlie-kirk-once-22340...

"Blacks were better off during slavery because they committed less crime. — Charlie Kirk." https://x.com/xagreat/status/1966149787780264107

Here is Charlie doing what appears to be...a White Power Sign (cause he is a white supremacist): https://cdn.bsky.app/img/feed_thumbnail/plain/did:plc:p5yoii...

> George Floyd was a scumbag. If you hold a gun to a pregnant woman's stomach, you're a scumbag.

I am extending the same courtesy to Charlie. He called for "stoning gay people" and many other hateful things for many many minorities and misinterpreted groups so I have no second thoughts on calling him a scumbag, and a douche.

https://www.yahoo.com/news/articles/stephen-king-charlie-kir...

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by nailer on Friday September 12, 2025 @05:30PM (#45226997)
> Prowling Blacks go around for fun to go target white people

"We now see a pattern of blacks prowling the streets going to harass whites and they feel as if they're untouchable"...(goes on to mentions the Daniel Penny good samaritan case in NY).

Read your own link. A woman rented a bike, the bike was pushed back into the machine by a group of black kids, and then she was targeted for harassment after they videod her pretending she was harassing them.

In terms of the general case of white people being targeted by race, very recently another person was stabbed by a black assailant who appeared to say "I got that white girl".

I'm not sure why you think Kirk discussing some black people being racist means Kirk was a racist, it pretty clearly means the people being racist were racist.

> "Blacks were better off during slavery because they committed less crime. — Charlie Kirk."

No, some guy called "xagreat the Duke of Nigeria" you linked to on X made that up, the first reply is someone pointing out that it's fake.

> > If you hold a gun to a pregnant woman's stomach, you're a scumbag.

> I am extending the same courtesy to Charlie.

He didn't hold a gun to a pregant woman's chest.

> He called for "stoning gay people"

No he didn't. You made that up. The article you linked to even has Steven King admitting it wasn't true after deleting the post where Steven King originally wrote it.

Edit: you added Kirk talking about the Civil Rights Act with a bunch of archived posts by other people, the actual source is a discussion about racism at: https://rumble.com/v4pvgc6-jeremy-carl-its-okay-to-be-white.... and Caldwell (which Kirk mentions) is

> Christopher Caldwell, in The Age of Entitlement (2020), argues the Civil Rights Act of 1964 created a "second constitution" mandating endless social reengineering via affirmative action and racial preferences, eroding liberty, social cohesion, and the original color-blind equality.

Kirk's opinions later are:

> "I have a very, very radical view on this, but I can defend it, and I’ve thought about it. We made a huge mistake when we passed the Civil Rights Act in the 1960s. … The most important thing when you look at any sort of legislation is, what are the fruit of it? What has happened since the Civil Rights Act of 1964? Well, since then, we’ve had a destruction of the black family. We’ve had an increase in racial tension in this country, not a decrease. We’ve had a complete distortion of what Martin Luther King wanted, which was a colorblind society. Instead, we’ve gone completely in the opposite direction where we’re now hyper-focused on race."

Titles VI and VII were used to create race based hiring and race based distribution of federal funds, ie DEI.

Edit: you also added the OK symbol lol ok.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by ath3nd on Friday September 12, 2025 @08:37PM (#45228271)
> He didn't hold a gun to a pregant woman's chest.

Yet he was a racist scumbag. Hitler also didn't hold a gun to a pregnant woman's chest for all we know yet he was also a racist scumbag.

> Kirk's opinions later are:

What makes you think I give a rodent's rear end about the opinions of an irrelevant dead youtuber white supremacist nobody?

> No he didn't. You made that up. The article you linked to even has Steven King admitting it wasn't true after deleting the post where Steven King originally wrote it.

Nah, what Stephen King said is actually true. Here is the actual video from Charlie's talk with Ms. Rachel: https://youtu.be/QWKF5EU1Cig?t=322 (and even if that video is taken down, now I have the raw footage).

I quote:

"And it says, by the way, Ms. Rachel, you might wanna crack open that bible of yours, in a lesser referenced part of the same part of scripture as in Leviticus 18 is that thou shall not lay with another man, less you shall be stoned to death. Just saying."

It's in the video. Stephen King's post might be taken down by pressure, but the truth is one. Charlie himself said it, on his own clown show.

As for the white supremacist white power sign, next to Daniel Schmidt, another white supremacist praised by neonazis like Nick Fuentes, it's fine. https://cdn.bsky.app/img/feed_thumbnail/plain/did:plc:p5yoii...

Those who needed to understand what it means and what it stands for, understood what it stands for. Now excuse me while I go play Bella Ciao on repeat and watch Indiana Jones for no particular reason. The lyrics go like this:

Una mattina mi son svegliato. O bella ciao, bella ciao, bella ciao ciao ciao...

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by nailer on Saturday September 13, 2025 @10:58AM (#45232611)
> What makes you think I give a rodent's rear end about the opinions of an irrelevant dead youtuber white supremacist nobody?

Because you hate him? It’s really clear you do care a lot about his opinions.

> He called for "stoning gay people"

No he didn’t, he quoted the bible saying that - thanks for posting a video to clear it up. It’s true. The bible does say that.

I suspect you’re very young and not good at arguing so I’m going to bow out now.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by ath3nd on Saturday September 13, 2025 @12:18PM (#45233267)
> Because you hate him? It’s really clear you do care a lot about his opinions

I don't care about a dead white supremacist nor their fascist opinions. Republicans sure like to shoot one another and others (Tyler Robinson's parents are registered Republicans) https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cp8wl2y66p9o. My hot conspiracy theory is that maybe Charlie's death stems from a lover's between him and Tyler.

Actually, Charlie's death does give me some ideas, so maybe something good did come out of his existence. He gave me a great idea for a Halloween costume! I think this year I am gonna go with a costume as a hole in the throat: https://www.nydailynews.com/wp-content/uploads/migration/202...

> No he didn’t, he quoted the bible saying that - thanks for posting a video to clear it up. It’s true. The bible does say that.

Job 34:26-27: "He punishes the wicked for their wickedness out in the open where everyone can see it"

https://www.bible.com/bible/compare/JOB.34.26-27

Charlie was struck out in the open in front of his family and televised for the whole world to see. Make your own conclusions. Just saying.

> I suspect you’re very young and not good at arguing so I’m going to bow out now.

Yup, take the L. Lot of the people on the right (including Charlie) are taking in a lot of things at these turbulent times. Thoughts and prayers.

I realize I didn't share this catchy song that I found recently: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4CI3lhyNKfo. God bless!

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by dang on Sunday September 14, 2025 @10:35PM (#45245503)
Your comments stand out as aggressive and abusive, even in this hellish flamewar thread. Considering how awful it has been, that's really saying something.

Since, in addition to that, your account has a history of breaking the site guidelines, using HN primarily for political battle, and ignoring our repeated requests to stop, I've banned the account.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by dang on Sunday September 14, 2025 @10:33PM (#45245485)
We've asked you many times to stop perpetuating flamewars on Hacker News. You've unfortunately continued to do it, and you did it very badly in this thread. If you keep this up, we're going to end up banning you.

It's particularly dismaying to have to say this to an account that has been around here for so long. If users like you can't use the site as intended, and instead revert to abusing it and vandalizing it, what hope do we have?

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by nailer on Monday September 15, 2025 @02:11PM (#45253049)
> We've asked you many times to stop perpetuating flamewars on Hacker News.

What do you define as perpetuating flame wars?

I was responding to a troll, fairly politely - the most heated it got was when I pointed out that someone that holds a gun to a pregnant woman's chest is a scumbag, but that's a fairly common viewpoint.

> abusing it and vandalizing it

How am I abusing and vandalizing HN? I am politely responding to a troll after a terrorist attack. That's more than you'll get on most discussion sites.

On the topic of abuse:

1. You've mentioned you're manually unflagging article submissions recently. How is that not abusing the site? Do you think that's made HN better, or worse?

2. While I have your attention Dan: why is this correction to a hoax (a boy was supposed killed when he was alive) that was on the front page of the site https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45130174 marked as a duplicate? What was it a duplicate of? Why was there no comment with a link to the article it was a duplicate of? When a previous story about malnutrition in Gaza was revealed to be a hoax, why was the WSJ article revealing that hoax also marked as a duplicate? What was it a duplicate of? Why was there no comment with a link to the article it was a duplicate of submitted?

Do you think manually allowing hoaxes and conspiracy theories onto the front page, and marking correction as dupes, makes HN worse or better?

Feel free to email if you want to take this offline.

[deleted]
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by nailer on Monday September 15, 2025 @06:19PM (#45255655)
> I define as perpetuating flamewars is posting comments that add to a flamewar and thereby provoke other people into continuing the flamewar.

HN has changed since the flagged submissions are being manually unflagged. The site now has a huge amount of political content on the front page. This is not my doing. It is yours. You are the moderator Dan. You have said you are unflagging political posts. Stop blaming others for participating in this shitshow you're responsible for.

> > There is certainly a racist piece of shit in this conversation but you may wish to look closer to home.

That's a very reasonable response to someone labelling someone a 'racist piece of shit'.

> > I suspect you’re very young and not good at arguing

That's quite calm and reasonable.

> > if you’re not going to read when I respond to you there’s no point having this conversation.

And likewise. It's entirely reasonable to point out someone you are conversing with is not responding to the the points you make. Why on earth would you find this abusive?

> > Yes, that's how I feel. I mentioned he was standing up to racist hiring practices, you ignore and don't reply.

Again. That's very civil and reasonable to write.

Regarding:

> Worse you've continued to post in this style after I asked you to stop

HN doesn't have a notify option, people have to scan replies. I responded to you as soon as I noticed your reply.

> Moreover, your account has been using HN primarily for political and ideological battle for quite some time.

As I have previously discussed, you've been manually unflagging posts sent to the front page, increasing the amount of flamebait and conspiracy theory content on HN. The site is combatative Dan because you have made it combatative.

I have previously discussed what you're doing to the site at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45253049. Please respond.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by [deleted] on Tuesday September 16, 2025 @04:16PM (#45267397)
Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by nailer on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @12:55PM (#45278361)
> HN hasn't changed in that way

You have written you've manually unflagged stories, and from the tone of it that seems like a change.

I know 'HN has gone downhill' is an old meme but manually unflagging seems to be a new moderation behaviour and the amount of political posts is high. Hence people commenting on them.

> it wouldn't make it ok to break the rules

What rules have I broken? You seem to think I've been uncivil, I've been incredibly civil as previously discussed. The best example is me responding to a troll with their own language back at them.

> Pointing the finger at other users is not a good way to respond when you have been breaking the rules.

I raised what you were doing with moderation weeks ago and you didn't respond.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by dang on Wednesday September 17, 2025 @01:43PM (#45278975)
I've given you examples. I get that you disagree, and interpretations can differ of course, but it's the same standard we'd apply to anyone's posts.

Since those seem like obvious calls to me, I wonder whether you are experiencing the rather common skew in perception where people underestimate the negativity in their own posts and overestimate the negativity coming from others: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

> me responding to a troll with their own language back at them

If you think that another user is trolling, you shouldn't be responding in the first place. This is in the guidelines: "Don't feed egregious comments by replying; flag them instead." a.k.a. please don't feed the trolls.

And you certainly shouldn't be responding with "their own language back at them" - that's precisely the perpetuation of flamewar we're talking about.

If I didn't respond to an earlier question, the most likely reason is that I didn't see it. Either way, pointing the finger at others is a poor way to respond about your own rule breakage.

Re:Charlie Kirk shot at event in Utah by nailer on Monday September 22, 2025 @02:50PM (#45337797)
> If you think that another user is trolling, you shouldn't be responding at all. This is in the guidelines: "Don't feed egregious comments by replying; flag them instead."

It's really hard to do that in the current HN environment. We've had a number of confirmed hoaxes put straight onto the front page - the disabled boy that was presented as starving, the Anthony Aguillar allegations, the dead boy that's still alive. https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=nailer

How can we not respond to trolls when the trolls submissions are being manually unflagged?

The HN guidelines also state:

> Off-Topic: Most stories about politics... unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon.

The manual unflagging and influx of political chat created as a result recently makes it seem like the guidelines have been suspended.

> And you certainly shouldn't be responding with "their own language back at them" - that's the perpetuation of flamewar we're talking about.

OK, I won't do that again.

> If I didn't respond to an earlier question, the most likely reason is that I didn't see it. Either way, pointing the finger at others is a poor way to respond about your own rule breakage.

Do you want to respond now? If it is unclear, I understand that you are making that point, I disagree that I am pointing the finger at your in response to you discussing the combatative environment on HN and I am suggesting the environment has changed on HN due to the unflagging of stories that would have been dead anytime from 2-18 or whatever it is years ago.

The best way to handle this:

_____

Tell HN: most political submissions will now be removed

8000 points by dang

We recently started manually unflagging political discussions from the HN front page. This has caused a huge increase in the amount of combatative political discussion on the site and the we can see the change has not been for the betterment of HN. The HN guidelines state "Off-Topic: Most stories about politics... unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon." and we're now going to go back to enforcing that rule.