News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by doktrin on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:20AM (#4521725)
This disturbs me on the grounds of "bad habit" precedent alone. Getting accustomed to self-censorship is almost as bad as having it mandated.
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by nateberkopec on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:30AM (#4521759)
Hm, I don't know. This video is clearly hate speech, and I'm not sure Google should be required to keep content online that has literally caused the deaths of several people.

A 'slippery slope' argument doesn't hold up for me in this particular case.

EDIT: alright, maybe not literally. But I maintain that the video is hate speech, and that a different standard on "censorship" should apply here.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by dak1 on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:51AM (#4521893)
The idea that somebody shouldn't say something because it may elicit a violent reaction by somebody else seems to have dangerous logical conclusions that could include actually encouraging violent reactions to speech in order to silence it.

For example, the recent mural by the Taiwanese businessman in Oregon (http://usnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/09/12/13833952-china-as...) is clearly protected political speech, and obviously nobody died because of it. However, if it led to violent reactions in China that resulted in some deaths, should it be suppressed?

Now, religion could be argued to be in a different category; however, I have a hard time accepting that argument due to the politicization of religion. As long as a religion has political implications, speech critical of it should be protected in the same way other political speech is protected.

That doesn't mean you should be able to explicitly encourage violence against members of a religion, but it does mean that Southpark and a Danish cartoon should be allowed to parody religion to make a political point.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by andreasvc on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:37AM (#4521795)
That 'literally' is much too strong. The video was used as a convenient excuse for an attack which was probably already being prepared. Cf. http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/comment/2012/09/what-w...
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by ppod on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:56AM (#4521918)
Videos don't cause people to die, and definitions of 'hate speech' are difficult. Mocking Islam seems pretty hateful, since it is at the core of the belief system of a large proportion of the world's population. But what about mocking Scientology, or Mormonism? When is a belief system so ridiculous or unpopular that it no longer deserves protection?

You say that it should be taken down because it 'caused the deaths of several people' - the implication is that belief systems deserve more protection if their adherents are more willing to commit murder in retaliation.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by dbecker on Friday September 14, 2012 @12:08PM (#4522357)
I agree that the murderers are obviously to blame. But the film is like a kid who pokes a beehive with a stick with all his friends around.

We know you can't control all the bees once you get them riled up, so you're still an asshole if you intentionally put others at risk.

Free speech may give the film-maker the right to be an asshole, but it doesn't change the fact that he's an asshole.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by Dirlewanger on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:45AM (#4521834)
I think this is indeed a slippery slope. This is a VERY slippery slope because of the aftermath. A normal situation of censorship would have a platform (in this case, Google) censoring some sort of content released through them that was critical of the platform. This is almost the opposite; Google clearly is trying to assuage the seething anger for greater good. How far does one go though?

What if you have someone release a highly critical video of a massively corrupt leader of a country and its citizens begin to rage over it when the rest of the world knows they are just uneducated and don't know any better? A farfetched situation, but still. This is essentially what is happening: masses of uneducated people in somewhat-developing countries are upset over others desecrating their sacred religion. How much longer is this kowtowing to animals going to continue?

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by Robin_Message on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:55AM (#4521911)
I'm not sure you can say the video literally caused several deaths.

Obviously the middle east is very complicated place, but ultimately even people in a mob should be held accountable for their actions [1], so the blame lies with the killers, not the makers of a film; nor the leaders who espouse a hateful philosophy [2] that justified the killing, although I'd certainly blame them more than some film.

[1] See the widespread rioting and looting in the UK last year, some of which was justified by the perpetrators as political, but all of which was prosecuted as criminal.

[2] I mean, if one American does something you don't like, how does that mean you can (and should) kill another one (or more)? I want to think it's more nuanced than that, but I don't see how.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by theorique on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:48AM (#4521866)
This video is clearly hate speech,

Is that true? The video is alleged to insult Muhammad who is revered in Islam, but does it slander individual, living human beings or classes of human beings.

In other words, while so-called "hate speech" is indeed offensive, not everything that offends some people is "hate speech".

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by LostInTheWoods2 on Friday September 14, 2012 @11:05AM (#4521977)
I'll say it, because no one else seems to want to: It's time for muslims to grow the f--- up already. We have something in America called freedom of speech, its a cornerstone of our society. Sometimes people use that right to say stupid and hurtful things. It doesn't mean all Americans agree or condone what was said.
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by nhebb on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:48AM (#4521864)
I understand that it's anti-Muslim, but is that "hate speech"? If it were an anti-Christian video that showcased Jesus as a pedophile and philanderer, would it be labeled as such? It's free speech.
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by DanBC on Friday September 14, 2012 @11:03AM (#4521962)
In the UK: Yes, it probably would be labelled as hate speech. If someone was subject to violence and were called insults based on their Christianity the crime would be dealt with as a hate crime and the sentence would be more severe.

Also: The UK for years[1] had laws dealing with Blasphemy (a crime that could only be committed against the Christian church) and laws that dealt with racial prejudice. Since Islam is not christian, nor a race, muslims were left unprotected.

You may argue that Christians and jews should not have those protections. I hope you'd agree that it's iniquitous for one group to be left out of the protection of the law.

[1] This was changed in 2006 with the controversial Racial and Religious Hatred Act. Blasphemy was later repealed. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racial_and_Religious_Hatred_Act...)

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by kbolino on Friday September 14, 2012 @12:27PM (#4522463)
The iniquity of failing to punish blasphemy against Islam is far outweighed by the injustice of punishing blasphemy in the first place.

No set of beliefs should be so sacrosanct that the government must act to shield their fragile believers' minds from the criticism of others.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by DanBC on Friday September 14, 2012 @01:35PM (#4522880)
I'd agree. But the fact remains that there was a discrepancy where one group was left without any protection.

> No set of beliefs should be so sacrosanct that the government must act to shield their fragile believers' minds from the criticism of others.

Let's not forget that 3,500 people died (and 47,000 were injured) during "the Troubles" which had sectarian religious aspects. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Troubles)

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by bliving on Friday September 14, 2012 @12:43PM (#4522548)
In Canada, the slope is very slippery. Hate speech, under the Canadian Human Rights Act, is anything "likely to expose a person or persons to hatred or contempt". For better or worse, it certainly has a chilling effect.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech_laws_in_Canada

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by tomjen3 on Friday September 14, 2012 @11:17AM (#4522053)
The video has not caused the death of a single person.

Muslims have (I could say religious extremists, but the killers are mulims) caused the death 6 or 7 by now, plus insane property damage.

And Google should not be required to remove or keep the video online. It is their service, which means it is their property.

But removing it means that the next time somebody else can claim that 'you did it with this movie' which could result in bad PR.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by mbell on Friday September 14, 2012 @11:12AM (#4522016)
How is that video hate speech? I only saw the trailer but it struck me as a really poorly done comedy. If that video is hate speech then I can think of a large number of movies and documentaries released in the past decade that must also be hate speech (which is silly).
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by bradleyland on Friday September 14, 2012 @11:16AM (#4522043)
If we're headed down the 'slippery slope' of taking the microphone away from people like Sam Bassil (or whatever his real name is), then please allow me to grab some sunscreen and an inner-tube, because I'm coming along for the ride.

There's a lot of fallacious thinking going on here. There's probably some sophisticated name for this type of fallacy, but I don't know what it is. Just because the attackers were wrong for killing innocent people, doesn't make this hate video "right". False dichotomy, maybe?

Freedom of speech is about serving truth. It is an expression of the idea is that no one should be silenced for speaking about the truth. If someone is saying something demonstratively false, and that speech is endangering the public, then they should be silenced. This is the same reason you can't expect first amendment protection if you walk in to a theater shouting "FIRE".

So, to get this straight, speech is not protected by our first amendment ideology when it:

* Is demonstrably untrue

* Endangers the public

It's pretty easy to see that both of these conditions are met with regard to this video.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by icebraining on Friday September 14, 2012 @11:40AM (#4522205)
Who decides what's the "truth"? Who decides the criteria for qualifying something as demonstratively false?

And what about fiction? What if the film just include(d|s) a line saying all the events are fictional? Should it still be silenced?

Maybe 1984 influenced me too much, but such arguments make me extremely uneasy.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by ppod on Friday September 14, 2012 @11:35AM (#4522180)
Lets suppose that a group of atheists (and I am one) get together and make the following announcement:

* Much of the content of the Catholic mass is demonstratively false

* If any Catholic mass is celebrated, these atheists will attempt to murder the participants

By your ridiculous interpretation of the first amendment, the Catholic mass should now be silenced.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by bradleyland on Friday September 14, 2012 @11:43AM (#4522229)
Speaking of ridiculous...

You've got it entirely backwards. In your scenario, the atheists would be risking their first amendment protections because they're the ones threatening to murder someone. Even in that case, it is unlikely that any law enforcement agency would garner enough support to actually silence them until they'd gone out and hurt someone. See also: Westboro Baptist. The day that anyone associated with Westboro acts on their hateful speech is the day that they'll be shut down.

The best argument against silencing this ridiculous video isn't the fact that it's full of false claims and nut-job ideology, but that there are serious doubts as to whether it is the "true" driving factor behind the attacks. There are suspicions that the attacks were orchestrated separately, and the video is just a red herring.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by uvdiv on Friday September 14, 2012 @12:02PM (#4522330)
You've got it entirely backwards. In your scenario, the atheists would be risking their first amendment protections because they're the ones threatening to murder someone.

No, the parallel was accurate. The guy in California threatened no one, and his freedom of speech is on the line because other guys, who disagreed with him, committed murder.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by ppod on Friday September 14, 2012 @11:52AM (#4522274)
>whether it is the "true" driving factor behind the attacks

Can't you see the analogy between my scenario and this scenario? You make it sound as though if the video was the true motivating factor, then it should be banned. This is analogous with the Catholic mass in my scenario - by following the same logic, if the mass were the true driving factor behind the atheist's violence, then the mass should be banned. You can't let threats (or acts) of violence influence what is protected speech and what isn't.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by bradleyland on Friday September 14, 2012 @12:32PM (#4522501)
I see the correlation of the actors now, but I still don't agree with this:

"You can't let threats (or acts) of violence influence what is protected speech and what isn't."

We can, and we do. Look at the suicide of Tyler Clementi and the resulting sentencing of Dharun Ravi [1]. Look at the case of the anti-abortion wanted-posters [2].

The protection of free speech is not black and white. I understand that this makes people uneasy, but you can't have black & white distinctions in a population greater than one.

[1] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Jersey_v._Dharun_Ravi

[2] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-abortion_violence#Physicia...

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by rada on Friday September 14, 2012 @12:04PM (#4522340)
So, to get this straight, speech is not protected by our first amendment ideology when it:

- Is demonstrably untrue

- Endangers the public

It's pretty easy to see that both of these conditions are met with regard to this video.

Your statement is factually wrong on so many levels.

One, your understanding of what first amendment covers or doesn't cover is incorrect. Hate speech in particular is protected (which this video may or may not even be - I would call it distasteful but legitimate satire). This has been expressly addressed many, many times: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech#United_States

Two, the words "demonstrably untrue" mean that someone has audiovisual proof of what happened. I am not agreeing or disagreeing with the video's interpretation of the history of Islam but fact is, no one has the video of Muhammad getting religion. This is why it's called "faith".

Three, inflammatory words = violence equation is no more valid than slutty dress = rape equation. Violence is always squarely on the perpetrators, however provocative the trigger may be. I don't see why Muslims - or people of other faiths - should get special treatment when it comes to their religious feelings being offended.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by uvdiv on Friday September 14, 2012 @11:27AM (#4522125)
So, to get this straight, speech is not protected by our first amendment ideology when it:

* Is demonstrably untrue

* Endangers the public

The first amendment guarantees freedom of religion.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by bradleyland on Friday September 14, 2012 @11:33AM (#4522168)
Touché :) However, I will attempt a rebut (despite the fact that I am a card carrying atheist).

First, we should be clear that the two conditions above are bound by a logical "AND", not "OR". This means that both must be true in order to circumvent first amendment protection.

Also, all expressions of "freedom of religion" do not endanger the public. First amendment protection is about acts, not ideologies. Ironically, it is difficult to prove the second condition until some negative consequence has already occurred. This is the case with many of our laws. Look how hard it is to stop a stalker prior to their actual assault on a victim.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by uvdiv on Friday September 14, 2012 @11:53AM (#4522280)
I'll evade your difficult idea with a more pragmatic rebuttal: give almost any government in the world some legal speech model like what you describe, and you will be in prison for spreading the "false, dangerous delusion of atheism". The inability of government to determine, and enforce, truth is the only thing protecting your highly unpopular beliefs from censorship.

Free speech is in principle the right to speak the truth; in practice it's the right to assert falsehoods which enables it.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by othermaciej on Friday September 14, 2012 @09:33PM (#4524886)
First amendment law is pretty clear that there is no "heckler's veto" - the angry reaction of others does not make speech unprotected (except in the case of "fighting words" that are intended to and likely to cause imminent violence).
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by DanBC on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:23AM (#4521738)
Do you shout "HELLO CUNTS!!!" every time you enter a building?

Why is that form of self-censorship acceptable to you?

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by jakeonthemove on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:32AM (#4521770)
You'd shout that if you hated the persons in that building, and you'd be the one affected in the end.

Youtube self-censoring "for the right reasons" now can easily lead to them censoring things in the future not only on the basis that it's "for the right reasons", but also because "we did it before, why not now?", which is among the worst excuses/reasons to do anything...

And Google will not not affected - it will be the thousands/millions of people who will not be able to watch the video (which will most likely be somewhat important - they wouldn't censor a cat playing with a tennis ball).

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by brianchu on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:38AM (#4521801)
That analogy is false because what YouTube is doing is blocking video clips that were posted by other people.

In your analogy, only you are censoring yourself. Nobody else is censoring you from shouting whatever you want to shout. It would be perfectly fine if individual users voluntarily chose not to upload certain clips.

An accurate rhetorical question would be: Do you shout "HELLO CUNTS!!!" every time you enter a building and before a single sound has emerged from your mouth someone gags you?

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by edoloughlin on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:55AM (#4521910)
> An accurate rhetorical question would be: Do you shout "HELLO CUNTS!!!" every time you enter a building and before a single sound has emerged from your mouth someone gags you?

Don't property rights trump free speech rights? (IANAL) I.e., it's ok for you to shout whatever you want in public, but I get to throw you out of my house if I don't like what you're saying? Aren't Google just exercising their property rights in this case, common carrier considerations aside?

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by icebraining on Friday September 14, 2012 @11:49AM (#4522259)
Don't property rights trump free speech rights? (IANAL)

Legally? Free speech has a right is mostly about freedom from governmental interference. Private companies usually can censor whatever they want.

But I'm pretty sure people are discussing the moral aspect of this, not the legal. And one can consider that Google shouldn't do this, even if they have the legal right to do so.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by Evbn on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:42AM (#4521821)
Or you know, locked you out before you came into the building.
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by andreasvc on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:34AM (#4521786)
That's a straw man, because the grandparent probably does not feel inclined to shout that regardless, so no censorship is necessary. What's more, the troubling aspect here is that a third party is doing the censorship. IMHO they shouldn't legitimize the outrage over this video which is nothing more than amateurish satire.
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by DanBC on Friday September 14, 2012 @11:14AM (#4522030)
The gp probably does not feel inclined to shout that, but why? Is it because they've lived a life where they condition themselves to self-censor to some degree? Do we just blurt out everything we think when we meet people?

"Hello Bob. My word you're fat! And really rather ugly!"

No. We live our lives self censoring to some extent. We don't want to go out of our way to insult someone. There are some exception. We don't mind insulting people for humour. We really don't care about insulting people when politics is involved.

There are real reasons why religions need to be challenged. Some bits of religion do very great harm to many people.

Doesn't that mean we need to be careful with the offence we cause? Not to avoid any offence, but to make sure it serves some purpose? Causing offence to achieve a goal is probably acceptable. Otherwise you're just yelling "HELLO CUNTS!!!".

And to suggest that Youtube is censoring something is -in my opinion- vaguely ridiculous. They're choosing not to distribute a video. They're an international business and they suppress many videos every day. There are very many other online video services which could carry this film. I can't display nipples on Youtube. I can't display HoboFights on Youtube. Why should this video be any different?

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by andreasvc on Friday September 14, 2012 @11:42AM (#4522214)
I think self-censorship is somewhat of a misleading term. Self-control is central to human psychology, but it is different from the idea of censorship where one party prevents the voice of another to be heard because it is against the interests of the former.

I certainly agree that this video is not prudent, and hence will not achieve anything. It is quite another question whether this means a company like Google should judge this and take action on it without a court order.

The reason to call this censorship is because the decision not to distribute is probably politically motivated. Compared to the examples you cite, this video is very much relevant to public interests, i.e., people will want to know what all the fuss is about. This does not hold for your examples of 'hobo fights' and nipples.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by icebraining on Friday September 14, 2012 @11:46AM (#4522249)
Why should this video be any different?

It's not: those are also examples of censorship.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by anamax on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:43AM (#4521825)
When I don't yell "HELLO CUNTS", it's not because someone 1000 miles away might be offended.

As far as this particular offense goes, "piss Christ" and so on....

Some animals are more equal than others.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by pstuart on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:28AM (#4521751)
That's different and you (should) know it.
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by Cushman on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:31AM (#4521761)
How?
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by astine on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:47AM (#4521849)
Meta Comment: pstuart is technically correct, but I think it's much more useful to explain why something is the case than to simply accuse someone of willful ignorance. There's always the possibility that they, or someone else, genuinely does not know.
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by pstuart on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:57AM (#4521926)
Because your example doesn't give the members of the crowd a choice if they want to hear it. Nobody was forced to watch the movie.
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by Cushman on Friday September 14, 2012 @11:19AM (#4522066)
I was expecting something a little more convincing. That's a complete red herring; you never have the choice not to hear something once you've heard it. Does it help if I don't insult you unless you make eye contact with me? After all, if you didn't want to hear what I think about you, you didn't have to catch my eye.
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by pstuart on Friday September 14, 2012 @05:55PM (#4524184)
You might be trolling but I'll play along. The choice occurs when one goes to youtube, searches for the video and clicks play.

You should research the "goatse" case right now for more information about this.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by s_henry_paulson on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:43AM (#4521824)
If Google was a government, or youtube was a service that you were paying for, this would be a valid argument.
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by ori_b on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:49AM (#4521873)
There's nothing wrong with debating what the most moral course of action for a private company is, even if you have no right to demand them to change.
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by doktrin on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:49AM (#4521874)
Google is a major provider of online content. If a major provider of online content begins restricting said content, that is potential cause for concern.

You read my post as "Google owes it to me to keep this content available", which is simply not the case.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by joesb on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:58AM (#4521928)
Google does not host porn either. There are other website for those explicit content.
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by vixen99 on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:59AM (#4521933)
Presumably we are not forgetting that Google is simply a business responding to the overall reaction of its customers in Libya and Egypt. Why do some people appear to believe as a subtext message that it's a community service of some kind? It is, of course, but only incidentally.