News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by DanBC on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:23AM (#4521738)
Do you shout "HELLO CUNTS!!!" every time you enter a building?

Why is that form of self-censorship acceptable to you?

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by jakeonthemove on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:32AM (#4521770)
You'd shout that if you hated the persons in that building, and you'd be the one affected in the end.

Youtube self-censoring "for the right reasons" now can easily lead to them censoring things in the future not only on the basis that it's "for the right reasons", but also because "we did it before, why not now?", which is among the worst excuses/reasons to do anything...

And Google will not not affected - it will be the thousands/millions of people who will not be able to watch the video (which will most likely be somewhat important - they wouldn't censor a cat playing with a tennis ball).

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by brianchu on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:38AM (#4521801)
That analogy is false because what YouTube is doing is blocking video clips that were posted by other people.

In your analogy, only you are censoring yourself. Nobody else is censoring you from shouting whatever you want to shout. It would be perfectly fine if individual users voluntarily chose not to upload certain clips.

An accurate rhetorical question would be: Do you shout "HELLO CUNTS!!!" every time you enter a building and before a single sound has emerged from your mouth someone gags you?

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by edoloughlin on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:55AM (#4521910)
> An accurate rhetorical question would be: Do you shout "HELLO CUNTS!!!" every time you enter a building and before a single sound has emerged from your mouth someone gags you?

Don't property rights trump free speech rights? (IANAL) I.e., it's ok for you to shout whatever you want in public, but I get to throw you out of my house if I don't like what you're saying? Aren't Google just exercising their property rights in this case, common carrier considerations aside?

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by icebraining on Friday September 14, 2012 @11:49AM (#4522259)
Don't property rights trump free speech rights? (IANAL)

Legally? Free speech has a right is mostly about freedom from governmental interference. Private companies usually can censor whatever they want.

But I'm pretty sure people are discussing the moral aspect of this, not the legal. And one can consider that Google shouldn't do this, even if they have the legal right to do so.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by Evbn on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:42AM (#4521821)
Or you know, locked you out before you came into the building.
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by andreasvc on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:34AM (#4521786)
That's a straw man, because the grandparent probably does not feel inclined to shout that regardless, so no censorship is necessary. What's more, the troubling aspect here is that a third party is doing the censorship. IMHO they shouldn't legitimize the outrage over this video which is nothing more than amateurish satire.
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by DanBC on Friday September 14, 2012 @11:14AM (#4522030)
The gp probably does not feel inclined to shout that, but why? Is it because they've lived a life where they condition themselves to self-censor to some degree? Do we just blurt out everything we think when we meet people?

"Hello Bob. My word you're fat! And really rather ugly!"

No. We live our lives self censoring to some extent. We don't want to go out of our way to insult someone. There are some exception. We don't mind insulting people for humour. We really don't care about insulting people when politics is involved.

There are real reasons why religions need to be challenged. Some bits of religion do very great harm to many people.

Doesn't that mean we need to be careful with the offence we cause? Not to avoid any offence, but to make sure it serves some purpose? Causing offence to achieve a goal is probably acceptable. Otherwise you're just yelling "HELLO CUNTS!!!".

And to suggest that Youtube is censoring something is -in my opinion- vaguely ridiculous. They're choosing not to distribute a video. They're an international business and they suppress many videos every day. There are very many other online video services which could carry this film. I can't display nipples on Youtube. I can't display HoboFights on Youtube. Why should this video be any different?

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by andreasvc on Friday September 14, 2012 @11:42AM (#4522214)
I think self-censorship is somewhat of a misleading term. Self-control is central to human psychology, but it is different from the idea of censorship where one party prevents the voice of another to be heard because it is against the interests of the former.

I certainly agree that this video is not prudent, and hence will not achieve anything. It is quite another question whether this means a company like Google should judge this and take action on it without a court order.

The reason to call this censorship is because the decision not to distribute is probably politically motivated. Compared to the examples you cite, this video is very much relevant to public interests, i.e., people will want to know what all the fuss is about. This does not hold for your examples of 'hobo fights' and nipples.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by icebraining on Friday September 14, 2012 @11:46AM (#4522249)
Why should this video be any different?

It's not: those are also examples of censorship.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by anamax on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:43AM (#4521825)
When I don't yell "HELLO CUNTS", it's not because someone 1000 miles away might be offended.

As far as this particular offense goes, "piss Christ" and so on....

Some animals are more equal than others.

Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by pstuart on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:28AM (#4521751)
That's different and you (should) know it.
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by Cushman on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:31AM (#4521761)
How?
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by astine on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:47AM (#4521849)
Meta Comment: pstuart is technically correct, but I think it's much more useful to explain why something is the case than to simply accuse someone of willful ignorance. There's always the possibility that they, or someone else, genuinely does not know.
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by pstuart on Friday September 14, 2012 @10:57AM (#4521926)
Because your example doesn't give the members of the crowd a choice if they want to hear it. Nobody was forced to watch the movie.
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by Cushman on Friday September 14, 2012 @11:19AM (#4522066)
I was expecting something a little more convincing. That's a complete red herring; you never have the choice not to hear something once you've heard it. Does it help if I don't insult you unless you make eye contact with me? After all, if you didn't want to hear what I think about you, you didn't have to catch my eye.
Re:Is this a first? Google voluntarily censors anti-Islam vi... by pstuart on Friday September 14, 2012 @05:55PM (#4524184)
You might be trolling but I'll play along. The choice occurs when one goes to youtube, searches for the video and clicks play.

You should research the "goatse" case right now for more information about this.