News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IPhone 5 opens the door for Nokia, Samsung by melling on Friday September 14, 2012 @07:41AM (#4521126)
I love my iPhone but I really don't get this. Apple only has 31% of the smartphone market and Android has 59%, for example.

http://news.cnet.com/8301-13579_3-57510406-37/iphone-5-faces...

The market is already open. Apple has never dominated. They just make a really good product that's loved by millions. :-) It's also clear that even more people are happier choosing a different phone.

Re:IPhone 5 opens the door for Nokia, Samsung by stevoyoung on Friday September 14, 2012 @07:51AM (#4521154)
Market share is like "users" in a startup, it means nothing. Revenue is everything. Sometimes, market share is directionally proportional to revenues, in the phone wars case, it isn't.

Does any one really think Cook is loosing sleep at night because he wants customers from "android's share"? He wants users from the rite market segment aka the ones who spend money. I'm going to go out on a limb here and say they have quite a bit of those types.

-- Edit: spelling

Re:IPhone 5 opens the door for Nokia, Samsung by mtgx on Friday September 14, 2012 @08:02AM (#4521181)
For a company directly, yes. For a platform, market share is very important. It wasn't until recently that Android caught up and surpassed iOS in total user base, but given some of the problems of the Android ecosystem, iOS will probably remain the main platform for the time being. But eventually Android will become the main platform through sheer numbers. It's poised to have 3 billion devices on the market by 2016, while iOS only 1 billion.
Re:IPhone 5 opens the door for Nokia, Samsung by gonzo on Friday September 14, 2012 @08:57AM (#4521372)
"only"??

If your point is that there will be 3X as many Android devices, fine.

but a market of 1 billion? I'll take it.

Re:IPhone 5 opens the door for Nokia, Samsung by huxley on Friday September 14, 2012 @08:18AM (#4521238)
I think it's becoming clear that Android is winning over the majority of feature phone upgrades, which is great for raw numbers but I wonder if it will take a while for those people to buy into the eco-system. Is the existing wedge going to be less and less profitable?

A lot of people had feature phones that had Java ME or BREW, but aside from telephony and texting, many only ever played Snake on it. If the phone manufacturers aren't making much money off of the hardware bought by feature phone upgraders, how much will Google or other ecosystem vendors make much off of the software side?

Re:IPhone 5 opens the door for Nokia, Samsung by marknutter on Friday September 14, 2012 @08:09AM (#4521211)
Apple is one company. Android devices are made by a wide array of companies. So in terms of marketshare per company, yes, Apple has dominated (although I think they were recently surpassed by Samsung?).
Re:IPhone 5 opens the door for Nokia, Samsung by adsr on Friday September 14, 2012 @08:01AM (#4521179)
But Android is not a phone, look at market share by smart phone vendor instead of OS. It's a comparison that makes much more sense since there are many vendors, each competing with each other, all with individual market shares, all using the Android OS.
Re:IPhone 5 opens the door for Nokia, Samsung by andybak on Friday September 14, 2012 @08:21AM (#4521255)
I don't see that matter. To the extent that I am invested in a mobile platform, it's Android I'm invested in. My next phone will probably run Android so I can carry along my familiarity and my app purchases. It's only likely to be a Samsung specifically if they have the right combination of hardware features and price at that time.
Re:IPhone 5 opens the door for Nokia, Samsung by adsr on Friday September 14, 2012 @09:07AM (#4521411)
It matters since we (parent comment and the article) are talking about market share of phones.
Re:IPhone 5 opens the door for Nokia, Samsung by andybak on Friday September 14, 2012 @09:28AM (#4521501)
We are both responding to: "I love my iPhone but I really don't get this. Apple only has 31% of the smartphone market and Android has 59%, for example." and in turn the original article

In this context the interesting definition of 'market share' is the one that focuses on platforms. There isn't very much interesting to be gleaned by making the distinction that Apple has a bigger market share than Samsung as Samsung and other Android OEMs collectively benefit from Android's market share.

Re:IPhone 5 opens the door for Nokia, Samsung by adsr on Friday September 14, 2012 @09:42AM (#4521557)
No, because the article essentially asks: does the new iPhone have enough bells and whistles to keep it's position, and compares it to other handsets like Nokia Lumia and Galaxy Note. It's putting up iPhone 5's hardware features against a few competing phones. It does not take platforms, operating system or any software into account.
Re:IPhone 5 opens the door for Nokia, Samsung by stevoyoung on Friday September 14, 2012 @08:10AM (#4521214)
I agree. Are there any numbers available with this phone vs phone type analysis?