there was lovely border crossing with egypt. this is till hamas started to export terror to sinai and egypt build a wall on border with gaza. and another wall in last year. open air prison narrative is boring. 100k palestinians left gaza after oct 2023. prior to oct 7th there were videos talking about gaza as vacation destination.
there is significant hamas presence in west bank. in fact there are cities that PA can't go to. About half year-year ago PA tried to remove Hamas from Jenin but got it ass kicked and had to ask Israel to clean it from Hamas. In fact, PA still in "control" of areas A/B because Israel works on suppressing hamas and pij in west bank. Latest may polls show that hamas support in west bank is higher than for any other party (which is one of the reasons that PA doesn't hold elections in past 20 years).
Also Israel never left Gaza. They had complete control over the sea air and land entry and exit points. Gaza was essentially an open-air concentration camp. They even calculated the minimum calories required so that Palestinians would not be "overfed". I'm in constant disbelief about the nonsense that Zionists tell themselves.
There's no significant Hamas presence in the West Bank and yet there Palestinians are routinely kicked out of their homes, beaten and shot by fanatical settlers as the Israeli army supervises. That is the reality of Israel. A fascist ethnostate, lawless and hyper aggressive. A Rhodesia on the Mediterranean if you will.