News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by Someone on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @01:10AM (#45099351)
To protect their users they chose to include a feature that allows them to remotely kill nefarious apps on all devices, regardless of how they got installed. A consequence of that is that they cannot answer government requests to kill apps with “I'm sorry, Dave. I'm afraid I can't do that”.

Was that the right trade-off? I’m not sure, but AFAIK, they aren’t allowed to add alarming warnings when users add alternative stores, so they can’t put up signs “you’re leaving the safe area”, so I can see why they made this choice.

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by rickdeckard on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @03:02AM (#45099945)
In this case they didn't remove the app from the users' devices, they “removed Alternative Distribution functionality from iTorrent’s Developer Portal without any warning.”

So they revoked the right of the developer to publish on other stores, and don't allow publishing that app on their own store.

Beside of those apparent "government sanctions-related rules in various jurisdictions" cited as reason by Apple (whatever that means), they now demonstrated that they still have indirect control over the offering of ALL digital markets.

So regardless in which market you want to publish, you still need to remain in good standing with Apple.

Combining that with Apple's ability to observe the install-base of iOS-devices it's quite a conflict of interest. (The least nefarious being Apple courting successful apps from other stores to come over to Apple)

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by nazgu1 on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @05:06AM (#45100663)
I would say they have direct control, as they have to bless app before even it can be published on other stores and can revoke this blessing anytime.
Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by reactordev on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @08:32AM (#45102263)
So you never really own an Apple device.
Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by rickdeckard on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @09:22AM (#45102803)
You may own the device, but everything running on top of it is part of a service in control of Apple.

It would be great if vendors would be mandated to clearly separate communication about the product and the services on top, so they would have to compete again on actual product functionality, but so far it's not the case...

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by reactordev on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @07:17PM (#45110356)
Unlocking/jailbreaking/installing your own software should be legal. I own the device, I should be able to do with it as I please without breaking cybersecurity laws. The issue is this covers IP/Platform Code and covers jailbreaking as that’s a form of reverse engineering in violation of the agreement you signed when you bought the device. It fucking sucks.
Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by kube-system on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @09:17AM (#45102748)
This seems more like a case of: you don't own other people's web servers.
Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by reactordev on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @09:25AM (#45102819)
No, more like you don’t own your OS. I definitely have physical ownership of their “server”.
Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by kube-system on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @09:31AM (#45102886)
No, you definitely don't own Apple's developer portal or any related infrastructure. If you did, then you wouldn't have anything to complain about, you could just fix it.

And of course you don't own iOS -- were you under any impression otherwise?

I don't really understand this culture of buyers remorse. If you don't buy FOSS, you don't get FOSS.

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by reactordev on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @10:06AM (#45103307)
So you’re saying if I buy a computer, I don’t own that computer?

This is what it is. I own this device in my pocket. I should be able to install, tinker, take apart, said device - granted voiding its warranty - without a company bricking the device intentionally or removing software from the device simply because I chose a p2p network over a centralized one.

Stop defending this. Once you sell something, it’s sold. It’s no longer yours. You may have made it, you may support it, but it’s no longer yours.

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by kube-system on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @10:18AM (#45103457)
You do own the physical device and you can do whatever you want with it. You can take it apart and tinker with it however you please.

If you don't like the software that they do or don't deliver to you over the internet, that is something entirely different.

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by reactordev on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @10:29AM (#45103591)
They didn’t deliver software. A 3rd party did. Stop making straw-man arguments to defend their actions. If the app was pulled from the normal App Store, fine, that’s Apple’s prerogative. But a 3rd party store? The app signing shouldn’t be used a weapon against software “you don’t like”.
Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by kube-system on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @10:36AM (#45103691)
Apple revoked notarization -- which is delivered as a service from their computers.

If you don't like that the phone connects to Apple's servers and uses the data delivered, then you shouldn't have bought a product that works that way. Or alternatively, you can take it apart and change it. Nobody is stopping you.

But Apple doesn't owe you an ongoing service that works exactly the way you like just because you bought one of their devices.

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by RedComet on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @12:25PM (#45105252)
You cannot (generally) install and run apps that aren't (recently) notarized, though. They do owe the service inasmuch as they require it for installing and running apps.
Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by kube-system on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @06:18PM (#45109849)
Yeah, the OS preinstalled on the phone functions that way. But this is not in opposition to your ownership of the physical device. You can do still do whatever you want with the phone. Grab a hot plate and pull off the NAND, chuck the whole thing in a blender, anything -- knock yourself out.
Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by RedComet on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @06:36PM (#45110015)
By analogy, if food was sold with poison in it, "hey man, you bought it, just remove it if you don't like it. not a chemist? crack a book buddy". And now imagine you had no means of producing your own food and all food sold contained poison.

If unlocking an iPhone and running e.g. AOSP on it were feasible, people would be doing it. And you know that. Your argument is disingenuous.

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by kube-system on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @06:52PM (#45110155)
Food with poison in it is both criminally and civilly illegal, and it puts peoples lives in danger.

Equating something like this to closed source software is why some people don’t take FOSS seriously.

You might think I was being facetious, but I’m being completely serious: the only way for FOSS to compete is by producing good products and bringing them to market. If FOSS advocates keep trying to fight some software licensing culture war instead of producing good technology, they’re not going to change anyone’s mind. 99.999% of people do not give two shits about a software license, they just want to use a damn phone.

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by RedComet on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @07:13PM (#45110324)
It was an analogy. You're moving the goalposts and ignored the latter point.

And I'm not a foss advocate, I just want to be able to run software of my choosing and without spyware, as has been the case since the advent of personal computing.

As a side note, legality seems irrelevant to your position. What if a world government mandated optional sideloading + unlocking? Wouldn't you then argue against that law?

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by kube-system on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @07:33PM (#45110484)
I know it’s an analogy. I just think it was a bad one. The desire for nerds to run unusual software on their phone is not really a life or death situation. I think it’s important to remember that in context, the number of us who care about this issue rounds to about zero. Most people using a phone don’t care.

I also want to run the software of my choosing. But there’s not a single phone you can completely do that with. Some of this is due to design decisions, some of it is due to corporate lock-in, and some of it is due to regulatory requirements.

I wouldn’t be against a law requiring side loading and unlocking, I would be in favor of it. This only addresses part of the software on a phone, though. There’s a lot of software on a phone beyond user space applications.

But I do think it would be reasonable to put some hurdles to make it difficult to do. There are completely valid reasons to protect the average user from being scammed by malicious software.

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by reactordev on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @08:38PM (#45110948)
Yet it happens all the time. More than half of Android phones are infected. So again, a poor argument for security. If anything, by opening it up, we (the collective nerds) could help harden it. Protect it. Improve it.
Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by RedComet on Wednesday September 03, 2025 @11:45PM (#45123321)
It sounds like we largely agree, then, so I'm not sure what you were arguing in the first place. That because the companies are legally able to do this and that [hardware-based] jailbreaking is possible in theory, it can't be opposed?

To your other point, firmware is another battle entirely and currently has less practical value.

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by keysdev on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @08:50AM (#45102450)
Devil is in the detail
Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by ruszki on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @02:27AM (#45099734)
> To protect their users they chose to include a feature that allows them to remotely kill nefarious apps

This feature is part of antivirus solutions for ages.

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by can16358p on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @02:48AM (#45099863)
If an OS needs antivirus for this, that OS has been designed wrong (excluding Linux, FreeBSD etc as the target audience isn't regular end users) in the first place.

An OS should NOT need antivirus, it needs proper sandbox and containerization.

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by Someone on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @03:10AM (#45099990)
- defense in depth means adding such an extra layer is a good idea

- an app can 100% stay within its sandbox and still be nefarious. For example, a password manager could secretly send all your passwords to Mr(s) Evil.

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by gkbrk on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @05:09AM (#45100684)
With a proper sandbox, a password manager won't have internet access.
Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by kube-system on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @10:22AM (#45103517)
It also wouldn't have a competitive feature set if that were the case -- syncing across devices is a bog standard feature for password managers.

Also, the possibilities for nefarious apps that aren't thwarted by sandboxes are endless: social engineering and phishing are very common and effective.

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by ruszki on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @05:30AM (#45100805)
There is no OS sandboxing and containerization which would prevent an internet facing software, like browsers, to be part of bot networks.

These are good to have, just like how it's good to have an antivirus. In some cases.

Most of the people download things which were checked before with an antivirus (like Play Store, App Store, GMail), or they don't really download anything outside of browsers (e.g. on desktop), so most of the people (almost everybody in case of percentage) don't need that much protection than 20 years ago. I also don't need neither OS level sandboxing, containerization, nor antivirus by default, because I know how to prevent compromise even without those. I, of course, use those when they are needed, when for example I install or browse something risky. But then I use a full blown VM, or an ultra sandboxed browser, and I know the risk, that there is nothing I can really do, if they use a vulnerability of my hardware for example.

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by rjh29 on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @03:54AM (#45100252)
> To protect their users they chose to include a feature that allows them to remotely kill nefarious apps on all device

And yet if you refund an app it's not automatically removed from your device. Always thought that was weird.

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by franga2000 on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @04:30AM (#45100452)
Why can't they add a "this app is not verified by apple, we can't guarantee it's safe" popup? Making people jump through ridiculous hoops (like jailbreaking) would violate the DMA, but surely not a simple matter-of-fact warning? Windows does the same with unsigned apps, as do many version of Android.
Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by StopDisinfo910 on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @05:18AM (#45100739)
Because they want to cripple alt stores and ignore the DMA for as long as they can to protect the 30% extortionate rate their position as the sole provider allows them to force on developers.
Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by fwn on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @11:10AM (#45104118)
The deliberate crippling of third-party stores is a clear example of malicious compliance, something Apple is well known for when facing regulatory pressure.

It's neither new nor surprising. Think about it: the Netherlands' dating app payment pricing trick, South Korea's alternative billing law, the US anti-steering injunction in Epic v. Apple, the Core Technology Fee for the EU's DMA, their ridiculous 'right to repair' process, etc.

What’s striking is how often parts of the discussion around Apple completely ignore this known pattern, instead leaning on apologetic corporate narratives about safety, integrity, privacy, or the environment.

I am against most of the (current!) regulatory pressure on Apple, but regardless of whether one supports these regulations, we can talk honestly about this practices of malicious compliance or even corporate disobedience. They exists in the world regardless of our personal stance on regulation (or Apple).

Generally speaking: If a tech giant does something and there are several possible motives, one of which is profit or power consolidation, and the others are different things, it is always profit/power. They did not start out a giant after all.

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by klausa on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @04:32AM (#45100465)
Because people don't read and scammers would just teach people how to click through that.
Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by netsharc on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @04:59AM (#45100607)
It's tragic, the amount of babysitting supposed adults need...

(I'm not totally against it, the mythical grandma would otherwise lose all her savings because of an animated dancing monkey exe)

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by lupusreal on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @06:27AM (#45101176)
Protecting grandma from scams by blocking a torrent app on her phone is rich. Getting a phone call is how grandma is going to get scammed.
Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by const_cast on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @10:31AM (#45103623)
Telling these people about threat modeling completely destroys their arguments. The arguments are lazy, a thin veneer for corporate profiteering, rent seeking, and restrictive behavior.

Youre right - granny isn't installing unsigned binaries and anyone proclaiming otherwise is just bullshitting you.

The reality is that there is no security here. We have massive, glaring holes in the systems we use. Adding a door lock when there's a giant hole in the wall next to it does nothing.

Granny is being scammed via phone, but nobody wants to fix that. I wonder why? Hm, maybe money has something to do with it.

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by mschuster91 on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @05:09AM (#45100688)
Unfortunately, said grandma isn't all that mythical. Scams of all kinds cost US citizens alone 158 billion dollars a year [1].

[1] https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/ftc-states-scams-cost-us-cons...

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by const_cast on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @10:33AM (#45103655)
This granny is mythical - granny isn't installing unsigned binaries off an alternative app store. Let's not argue dishonestly - we both know how scams actually happen. That statistic is less than worthless in this context.
Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by edm0nd on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @10:17AM (#45103441)
If you had told me many years ago end users would be opening powershell prompts and willingly copy pasting commands into them to infect themselves with infostealer malware, i wouldn't have believed you yet here we are with ClickFix
Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by franga2000 on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @04:35AM (#45100478)
That's not "Apple is not allowed to", that's "they don't because they think it's ineffective".
Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by klausa on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @04:41AM (#45100505)
Did anybody in this comment chain ever suggested otherwise?
Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by franga2000 on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @04:43AM (#45100519)
Yes, the person I was replying to...

> I’m not sure, but AFAIK, they aren’t allowed to add alarming warnings when users add alternative stores, so they can’t put up signs “you’re leaving the safe area”, so I can see why they made this choice.

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by klausa on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @04:54AM (#45100579)
Sorry, I misunderstood your question.

I thought you meant "why couldn't they have done so in the first place, without ever giving themselves the ability to killswitch any apps at all, and just show a scary looking message?".

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by happyopossum on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @09:49AM (#45103096)
No, they are literally prohibited from doing that - they tried and were shut down by the eu
Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by rickdeckard on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @09:07AM (#45102623)
Because Apple is not allowed to discourage the use of other distribution methods, and such a popup implies that an app provided via other channels is "less safe" than an app provided by Apple.

> Windows does the same with unsigned apps, as do many version of Android.

This is not the same. Windows states that they cannot verify the origin of the app because its not signed. In the current state Apple thoroughly verified the origin of the app, and the app is also signed.

Imagine a guy standing in front of your grocery store telling you that "the food in this store did not pass quality control of Walmart, so we can't guarantee that it's safe"

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by franga2000 on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @10:00AM (#45103221)
I still don't see the problem. Apple can say this app wasn't verified for safety by Apple because...it wasn't. I see an argument for them having to have a setting to disable the nag screen, but it's just stating a fact, just like Windows says "this app is not signed, you can't verify it comes from the correct publisher".

The walmart comparison makes no sense. A better comparison is the operator of a mall putting up a sign saying the products the stores in there sell are not verified by them. Often a store chain also owns malls, so Walmart saying "the things in the Walmart in the WalmartMall are ours and we vouch for their quality, but the other stores in the mall are independent and not vetted by Walmart.

It's only weird because it's so obvious nobody would think otherwise for a mall. But apparently people expect different for phones, which does make sense given Apple hasn't allowed third parties until now.

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by rickdeckard on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @11:08AM (#45104089)
> I still don't see the problem. Apple can say this app wasn't verified for safety by Apple because...it wasn't.

In the context of this popup, Apple is not just the manufacturer of the device, it is the operator of a competing marketplace. The fact that they suddenly present themselves and state that they did NOT verify this app implies that the quality of the products offered in that market are somewhat inferior to what Apple themselves are offering. <-- This is anti-competitive behavior

> It's only weird because it's so obvious nobody would think otherwise for a mall.

No, it's weird because Walmart has no business telling customers of OTHER markets that THEY don't vouch for its quality.

In this Metaphor Walmart was already caught and ordered to stop hindering other players from competing on equal grounds, so naturally Walmart cannot put someone in front of every competing store to cast doubt on their offering.

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by Someone on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @10:52AM (#45103892)
I think that’s because of the last phrase in this provision in the DMA (article 13.4 in https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=uriserv%...):

“The gatekeeper shall not engage in any behaviour that undermines effective compliance with the obligations of Articles 5, 6 and 7 regardless of whether that behaviour is of a contractual, commercial or technical nature, or of any other nature, or consists in the use of behavioural techniques or interface design.”

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by reactordev on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @08:31AM (#45102244)
It wasn’t their choice to make. The user purposefully installed the app from a 3rd party store. That sounds like user intent. If Apple cared about their users, they would allow a user to use without caveat. Including installing whatever software they wish so long as it worked on the platform.

This is right to repair. This is ownership. When you buy some hardware, you should be allowed to install any software you wish, provided it works and you have the technical know how to do so.

Re:Apple pulls iPhone torrent app from AltStore PAL in Europe by SirMaster on Tuesday September 02, 2025 @09:28AM (#45102856)
>they chose to include a feature that allows them to remotely kill nefarious apps on all devices, regardless of how they got installed.

Huh, I sideload some pretty nefarious apps all the time on my iPhone and have been doing so for about a decade, and they have never got remotely killed or removed.