News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by shmerl on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @02:49AM (#4504133)
I think all of this is close to be pointless, when there is an abundant and sickening Windows bundling problem which persists until present day. End users don't care about any ISVs, ABIs and other such matters, and some even don't have a clue about OS names. They buy a computer with an OS preinstalled. And guess what that OS is? That's the problem which needs to be solved first. The rest as the author admits, will be solved under the market pressure.
Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by eckyptang on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @03:09AM (#4504186)
Have you considered that windows is good enough for the end users and represents good value?

People don't want to make a choice or have to care about what they buy. The ISVs are quite happy to ship windows as they have reusable experience and it's just plugging things together.

The reason no market share destroying competition has appeared is that people are quite happy apart from a minority of users who are quite vocal.

consider that are more windows power users than there are mac users and Linux users combined.

I'm a Linux user (heavy with 15 years' experience) but i don't have a problem with the current situation.

Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by shmerl on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @03:15AM (#4504204)
Have you considered that windows is good enough for the end users and represents good value?

Same as Linux in this day and age (if user has such option).

The reason no market share destroying competition has appeared is that people are quite happy apart from a minority of users who are quite vocal.

With this logic any kind of monopoly can be justified, but it doesn't make monopoly good per se. Artificial lack of competition is bad.

consider that are more windows power users than there are mac users and Linux users combined.

Network effect is part of the problem, but the bundling issue is just a method to feed it. So one way to break it - is to remove the bundling blocker to allow fair competition.

Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by eckyptang on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @05:13AM (#4504464)
Firstly, reinforcing my position before I say something good about Microsoft: I am a Linux user and have been for 15 years. Before that, it was Solaris and HP/UX. I do a fair bit of work with Windows, particularly .Net at the moment. I'm pretty much neutral. It's a box that does a job.

I don't get these arguments: the user has the option. In the UK, there are magazines on every shelf in every newsagent pushing Linux and in every PC related stored they are pretty much giving Ubuntu away (yes they even had a box at the checkout in PC World with free CDs - completely untouched). You can buy PC's with it preinstalled and buy PCs with no operating system so you can install it.

I know MANY "normal" non enthusiast and non power users from social housing unemployed to professionals who have used Linux distributions and just end up back with Windows. Everyone knows what Linux is or has heard of it.

I don't think Microsoft is a monopoly - they just work pretty well on the desktop for most users (well they did until Windows 8 but I'm not going there in this discussion ;-). The competition is there but it's not really competition in mindshare as people are comfortable.

If you forcibly removed the bundling, you are going to get nowhere i.e. people saying "Can I just have it with Windows on it". Also, at the sales desk, the salesperson is going to make a few extra readies for selling Windows with a PC so you're going to lose anyway.

Take a look at where IBM is now compared to the late 1980's. They monopolised and beat their competition to death and they didn't survive in that market. Microsoft's time will come if they fuck up or piss off a lot of people, but at the moment they do what people want for a price that people want to pay.

The idealisms of "Microsoft sucks" and is a "monopoly" remind me of Slashdot circa 2001 onwards where OSX and Linux were going to take over the world and destroy Microsoft.

Sorry it ain't going to happen and I'm not really that bothered myself.

Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by takluyver on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @07:21AM (#4504799)
> In the UK, there are magazines on every shelf in every newsagent pushing Linux and in every PC related stored they are pretty much giving Ubuntu away (yes they even had a box at the checkout in PC World with free CDs - completely untouched). You can buy PC's with it preinstalled and buy PCs with no operating system so you can install it.

Is this the same UK I live in? The newsagents I see might have one Linux magazine lurking behind the iPad magazines. And you really have to go looking for computers that come with Linux preinstalled or no OS. Dell stopped offering them online, and I haven't seen a Linux PC in a retail store since the brief wave of Linux netbooks. I found a small business that sold me a computer with my choice of distro on, but they didn't really promote the option at all.

> If you forcibly removed the bundling, you are going to get nowhere i.e. people saying "Can I just have it with Windows on it"

"Sure, that will be £20 extra" (a complete guess at the OEM Windows price)

Obviously preinstalled Linux systems aren't going to topple Windows overnight - there's a lot of network effects and familiarity there. But at the same time, it would definitely benefit Linux adoption if consumers regularly saw an option to use Ubuntu, say, with known-good hardware and without having to install it themselves. Not many would take it at first, but a few people would go home and look it up.

> Everyone knows what Linux is or has heard of it.

Many people have heard of it, certainly, but they often have some vague idea that it's a command-line interface for ultra nerdy experts. That's why Android and Ubuntu both avoid using the word 'Linux' in their public branding.

Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by shmerl on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @01:27PM (#4506669)
>Many people have heard of it, certainly, but they often have some vague idea that it's a command-line interface for ultra nerdy experts. That's why Android and Ubuntu both avoid using the word 'Linux' in their public branding.

That actually is a lack of gratitude and failure to improve Linux image on their part. But I agree with the rest of the above. Removing the bundling won't magically solve all issues, but it's a huge blocker which prevents any kind of solutions from reaching the broader audience.

Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by takluyver on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @07:12AM (#4510100)
> [Avoiding the word Linux] actually is a lack of gratitude and failure to improve Linux image on their part

I don't see it quite like that. Firstly, I'm not sure that the people working on Linux (the kernel) particularly want to be a popular brand - it would mean a deluge of naive questions, apart from anything else.

Secondly, Ubuntu benefits from Linux, GNU tools, X, Gnome, Debian, and many other projects. In techie circles, they readily acknowledge that it wouldn't be possible without the work done in those upstream projects. But trying to fit them into the public branding would confuse users.

Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by shmerl on Wednesday September 12, 2012 @12:24PM (#4511419)
For general population, Linux became the name of the whole stack of related technologies rather than the kernel name, so not using it (by Ubuntu at least) is a disservice to everyone involved. I'm OK with Android not using it, since they are too far apart from the rest of the Linux world anyway and aren't benefiting global Linux community much. Just my 2 cents.
Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by shmerl on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @01:34PM (#4506721)
> You can buy PC's with it preinstalled and buy PCs with no operating system so you can install it.

This sounds like a fairy tale, given how many problems people have with claiming the Windows refund alone, let alone getting alternative OSes preinstalled. And no OS option? Virtually non existent, except may be for corporate customers and servers.

> I don't think Microsoft is a monopoly

They formally avoid antitrust regulations by delegating the refund to OEMs (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_refund), but it doesn't change the factual situation - Windows is bundled practically by all major OEMs, and you hardly can find an option of Linux preisntalled or no OS for those OEMs. Getting a refund for Windows is a burden which one has to fight through, do you think it's not an artificial restriction on the competition? I think it is, and it needs to be broken.

Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by pyre on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @02:59AM (#4504160)
Unless the "Linux Desktop" provides what costumers want, no OEMs will pre-install it (or those that do will lose money / go out of business). While "what costumers wants" might not be as complex as power users might imagine, it is not something so easily swept under the rug as "no big deal."
Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by shmerl on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @03:08AM (#4504183)
And what does Linux not provide, that the common user needs? The most common use cases are covered by modern Linux desktop more than enough. When you are starting to go to more specialized use cases (gaming, publishing, etc.) then Linux will fall behind. But they are arguably not the majority. So the common reason not to give an option of Linux (or no OS) is not because Linux is really lacking in functionality, but because of either deals with MS (i.e. reduced Windows price), or because of lack of demand (i.e. the same "network effect"). But demand is hard to build if such option doesn't even exist as an option for an unaware customer. So it's a vicious cycle, which is of course well fed by MS to persist.
Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by Steko on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @03:15AM (#4504201)
"what does Linux not provide, that the common user needs"

Office, Outlook, most AAA games, itunes. Don't tell me that because you can run them today on your machine (well maybe) that that somehow translates to what common users have experienced over the last decade.

Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by shmerl on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @03:21AM (#4504218)
Arguably, the majority of PC users don't care about heavy gaming. While gamers are an important factor, they aren't the blocker for any OEM to provide an option of Linux preinstalled. There are lot's of people who use their computers merely for browsing, reading e-mails and some minimal document editing and multimedia like audio/video. Many don't even use desktop office applications, using some web services for that. And Libre Office or Calligra are decent options as well. The age of immature office options on the Linux desktop is gone.

Outlook is a rather heavy monstrosity. There are better e-mail clients out there, including those on Linux.

Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by liedra on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @03:58AM (#4504301)
Having tried to use Open/Libre Office as a MS Office replacement I can say it's definitely not on par with MS Office (sadly). So many little things that you take for granted on MS Office either aren't implemented or are incompatible with others who are using MS Office. For collaborative documents in an academic setting, using track changes, extensive bibliographies, stupidly large wordcounts etc., it's far, far easier to just use MS Office. I'd love to move these people on to google docs or something but old habits die hard in academia - emailed word documents is still where it's at.

As for Outlook - while I've set up my home computer to not use it, for most it's just easier to use it. Convenience has a lot going for it. For non-tech-savvy people it's also a lot easier, since then calls to tech support at work will actually get you help. :)

Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by josteink on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @04:30AM (#4504368)
> And Libre Office or Calligra are decent options as well.

I use Linux machines for what they do well, and pretty much all my machines sans the "main" Laptop are Linux-driven.

That said: This statement cannot be refuted enough.

Libre Office and its forks are merely bad imitations of previous versions of MS Office while offering few to no benefits once you exclude cost. They are not "decent" alternatives. They are free, but noticeably sub-par alternatives. They are in no way drop-in replacements.

If I want to take the cost of working with a low-end Office-suite which covers the bare basics and sticks to a late 90s design-paradigm, I'll go with Google's online-offering because it actually provides some benefits to weigh up for the cost.

And sometimes I do just that. But you'll never find me meddling with the desktop Linux office-suites. They're simply not worth it.

Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by shmerl on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @04:35AM (#4504383)
How many users use 100% of functionality of MS Office? And what part of functionality most users use? We were not talking about drop in replacements, were were talking about satisfying enough needs of a common user. There always can be cases of some functionality lacking. But for common needs - Libre Office is way more than enough already. Google's options are way too limited comparing to desktop applications, but they work well for some use cases. I find Libre Office more than satisfactory for above average complexity document editing. And while it can lack some obscure functions of MS office, I just probably never needed them in the first place.
Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by josteink on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @04:42AM (#4504400)
You'll have to read my comment as me talking, as a reasonably capable user, which normally merely access around 5% of what I know MS Office can do.

Just basic things like creating sections, chapters, tables, footers, headers and making it all look good and consistent, quickly and easily.

MS Office, since the move to the ribbon-system have really excelled at exposing the functionality required to do this. It's always there in your face, just one click away, when you need it and then it gets out of your way. It's fantastic.

Libre Office and its forks are still stuck in the last generation of UIs where you have a million toolbars, all just mediocrely capable and insufficient to your full needs, none adapted to your current context and always there taking up space and cluttering the UI wheter you need them or not.

There's just no comparison between the user experiences here. MS Office is in a league of its own.

Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by shmerl on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @04:52AM (#4504417)
UI unfamiliarity is not equal to the lack of functionality in the program itself. Comfortable feeling about UI is also a subjective matter to a degree, so what works well for some is irritating for others.
Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by josteink on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @04:59AM (#4504425)
Sure. That is a factor.

But the reason Microsoft moved from the safe (familiar) UI to the new one was because they realized the old UI-model didn't scale well with expanded functionality.

They decided to try to improve the user experience by leaving behind what clearly did not work.

For a company which owes most of its legacy to users preferring familiarity, that's very much not a small thing. But they decided it had to be done.

More than five years later, Libre Office still haven't done anything at all to fundamentally improve UX. To me that sounds like somebody simply not caring.

Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by fmoralesc on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @06:15AM (#4504623)
I agree. Making a turn like Office did with the ribbon interface was a bold, commendable move. Sadly (Libre/Open)Office can't follow suit unless they design and develop a good alternative to it, which is not an easy task. And because of patents, they couldn't simply build upon the ribbon UX.
Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by shmerl on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @01:18PM (#4506605)
I think they care, but they have their constraints. They'd rather polish and add important functionality first, rather than radically redo the whole design. After the LibreOffice / OpenOffice split it's still probably not at the point of such step. But I'm sure at some point they'll address it.
Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by Steko on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @04:38AM (#4504393)
Options are great but frankly haven't always been there and are not options for everyone. OpenOffice/LO are great options and I have long used them myself but if my 1000 employee business is currently built around MS Office then I need to buy new computers with Office, end of story. If those employees want full compatibility with their work files and email at home they needed to buy windows.

For a very long time for most things casual users did Windows was a better fit then linux. Want to play games? Windows by a mile. Burn DVDs? Windows. Download music legally? Windows. Download music illegally? Windows. Word Processing? Windows. Spreadsheets? Windows. Use that new camera/scanner/printer/ipod? Windows by a mile. Read your office email? Windows. DTP? Windows. Visit flash websites? Windows.

Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by shmerl on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @04:47AM (#4504407)
Honestly, besides gaming (which becomes better with maturing Wine) I don't see how Linux lacks in any functions you mentioned i.e. DVD burning, legal music downloads (one can use Banshee with Amazon for example) and etc. and etc. The only issue can be that of unfamiliarity, but it's not a functional issue. Any decent digital player can work with Linux (and I don't consider iPod to be decent one ;).
Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by lumberjack on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @04:05AM (#4504314)
Personally I think a greater factor in the prevalence of Windows is the way children in school grow up using it and other MS branded software. Add to that the reputation that Windows has in the corporate enviroment and the inertia of over fifteen years as the status quo and that probably accounts for the majority of why Microsoft dominates these markets.

I won't go much into the issue other than say that I find it somewhat sad that we are essentially hooking up these children and ultimately our future on the products of a private entity. Even if they are the better option out there, there is still an issue of unnecessarily power being granted to a private entity.

You might also want to checkout what kind of deals your local government/municipality made with MS.

Re:Linux on the (consumer) Desktop by shmerl on Tuesday September 11, 2012 @01:54PM (#4506810)
Yes, MS tries to hook schools early on. But no one stops teachers and school stuff from rejecting MS offers and going with Linux. And it does happen in different places.