News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by airstrike on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @09:29AM (#45039409)
I don't think there was ever a risk of the plane crashing with the pilot still in the cockpit, despite the fact that the headline sort of leads people to that conclusion.

The pilot could eject at any time. Still dangerous, but more of a debugging session to avoid other similar costly in the future than a Hollywood-like "if we don't solve this now the pilot dies"

Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by petertodd on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @09:46AM (#45039607)
Ejections are pretty rough, and occasionally career or even life ending. So there would be a lot of pressure on the engineers to try to avoid it. Plus, this plane is very expensive. The cost is multiple times the average lifetime earnings of a typical person. It's not entirely wrong to say that they were attempting to save the life's work of multiple people.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by SoftTalker on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @10:55AM (#45040562)
Also the now-pilotless aircraft could potentally kill people on the ground when it crashes. If this had happened in a more populated area it very likely would have.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by gregoriol on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @12:05PM (#45041508)
The pilot could eject at mostly any time, not if the plane starts spinning uncontrollably though. Also, the plane can become very dangerous to what may be on the ground: if the pilot looses control and must eject it may not always be in a safe place to crash. Or even worse, the plane may continue to fly some distance and crash at a very different place than expected. So yeah, very stressful for everyone involved.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by codyb on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @09:44AM (#45039579)
Doesn't ejecting from a plane potentially break bones? I think it's pretty intense. Good on the pilot for doing the debug session
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by zhengyi13 on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @11:02AM (#45040677)
I've been told that ejections are violent enough that pilots can end up permanently shorter. A short bit of searching turned up this case study of two pilots' injuries/outcomes:

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9453365/

Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by keepamovin on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @10:31AM (#45040255)
It risks career. 2 ejections and you won’t fly for the military any more.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by incone123 on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @11:05AM (#45040735)
I went to an ejected pilot call when I worked in EMS. Guy was ok but protocol was handle as potential spinal injury. The force of ejecting puts a lot of compression on intervertebral discs and the effect is cumulative so more ejections means more chance of trashing your back.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by delfinom on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @11:27AM (#45041033)
I'm surprised they don't design the seats such that they pop out two bars under your armpit so that you transfer some of the forces into your shoulder and collar bone instead of just the spine.

Same way car seat belts horribly injure people if they let it rest on their stomachs instead of on their hips.

Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by johndunne on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @11:47AM (#45041275)
The forces involved would only pop your shoulders and not provide any support for your back via your underarm. And the speed the bars would need to come out at, might end up inside your chest cavity. The ejection seats are a last ditch save from certain death. I’d take the loss of an inch or two to my height than the alternative.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by datameta on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @11:45AM (#45041246)
Not a bad idea at face value but as opposed to seatbelts it introduces additional complexity that has to handle every eventuality including G forces from any direction, and still function perfectly. Probably has failure modes that increase injury risk. But this isn't a bad line of thought to go down, ultimately.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by kridsdale1 on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @11:42AM (#45041218)
These things are rocket powered and deploy in milliseconds. That sounds like a great way to exit the plane without your arms.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by LorenPechtel on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @03:37PM (#45044080)
1) It's too fast.

2) Think your shoulders could take it?? It's IIRC ~15g.

I do think they probably could make a gentler ejection mode as the seats are built for the worst case. The lower your airspeed the longer you have to get high enough to clear the tail and thus less acceleration is needed.

Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by keepamovin on Thursday August 28, 2025 @03:09AM (#45049328)
Visceral grok: there’s a reason supporting yourself on crutches versus standing sucks; your spine is meant to bear load.

I guess a taser like electro stimulation targeted to get the right muscles to tense up to ease a bit of pressure on the joints might help

But i have no idea

Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by drdo on Thursday August 28, 2025 @07:16PM (#45058107)
Doesn't the pilot press the button to do it himself? It's not like it's a surprise, he can tense the muscles beforehand.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by keepamovin on Friday August 29, 2025 @01:39AM (#45060612)
True, but how much control do you have? Seems taser can occasionally provide more muscle control than volition, as that is why it incapacitates.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by burnte on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @11:11AM (#45040824)
It depends on why and your medicals. There's not hard limit of 2.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by keepamovin on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @11:33AM (#45041122)
I guess trashing a couple hundred million dollars is a occasionally considered an issue

tho looking at how contracts have traditionally been funded you’d be forgiven for thinking it wasn’t

Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by hluska on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @12:56PM (#45042125)
It’s a massive issue - crashes are investigated and it’s not uncommon for a pilot to lose their jobs if they deviate from procedures. A few years back, a Marine Colonel was relieved of a prestigious command after being found to have ejected too early:

https://www.military.com/daily-news/2024/10/31/pilot-of-f-35...

Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by LorenPechtel on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @03:43PM (#45044154)
Note that that was the third review. The first two exonerated him--the real problem was his helmet wigged out. His plane was actually flyable but it was lying to him. And the rule was if the plane is not responding properly to pilot commands below 6,000' AGL eject.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by hluska on Friday August 29, 2025 @11:59AM (#45065783)
These details have nothing to do with the comment I was replying to. They’re irrelevant.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by burnte on Friday August 29, 2025 @04:24PM (#45068969)
Depends on who trashed it and why. Because you screwed up? You ride the bus. Because you were piloting an experimental craft in a test? Take a week off. Because you were in a billion dollar jet and the landing gear broke making the plane think it was on the ground? Definitely not the pilot's fault.

Context is always important.

Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by keepamovin on Saturday August 30, 2025 @12:54AM (#45071996)
What's the most number of ejections of a military pilot?
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by drdo on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @11:00AM (#45040642)
Even if the ejections happened with no fault on your part?
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by pixelfarmer on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @11:14AM (#45040860)
Your spine doesn't care why an ejection happened.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by empiko on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @11:14AM (#45040850)
I think it's about health concerns
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by shawabawa3 on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @11:00AM (#45040647)
Also isn't there like 5-10% fatality rate?
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by Tuna-Fish on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @11:46AM (#45041253)
Not with modern Martin-Baker seats. IIRC since 2000, something like 800 ejections have happened, of which one lead to a fatality, which was caused by improper maintenance to the seat. (Martin-Baker was chastised for not warning maintainers of the specific risks of overtightening certain bolts above printed spec.)

When Russians were still flying planes deep over Ukraine, they have something like a 50% fatality rate on ejection, but that might be exacerbated by Ukrainian locals often finding the ejected pilots before any military force does, and people getting bombed have historically not liked the people flying the bombers much. When a pilot on the ground has a lot of bruises and a snapped neck, it's often hard to identify whether that happened during the ejection, during the landing, or after. And even when the cause was clearly violence, the emergency services might not be overly interested in blaming anyone or anything but the seat.

Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by LorenPechtel on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @03:48PM (#45044240)
And note the situation over Ukraine. There are systems like the Patriot--you do not want to be above the horizon to one of them. But so long as you're some distance from the launcher and stay very low the Patriot can't see you. But that puts you very much in danger from stuff like a Stinger and when one finds your engine you're going to go in very, very fast.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by 542354234235 on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @11:30AM (#45041064)
That might also be influenced by the situation which necessitated the ejection. Ejecting in optimal conditions could have a 0.1% fatality rate (not a real statistic), but cases of ejecting from a disintegrating plane at 100 feet probably aren't as safe.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by HPsquared on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @09:53AM (#45039701)
I wonder if the ejection seat has different levels of acceleration depending on the situation.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by Sharlin on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @10:56AM (#45040583)
I don't think so. It's a solid rocket motor, there's no modulating such things.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by Tuna-Fish on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @11:53AM (#45041356)
Many seat types have multiple distinct motors for redundancy reasons. Even if there are not, you can adjust the effective output of a solid rocket motor by modifying the nozzle configuration, and Martin-Baker has an expired patent on this.

... but even if the seat in question was able to adjust the ejection thrust (which I don't think it was), this particular situation involved ejection really close to the ground, which calls for maximum thrust.

Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by HPsquared on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @06:36PM (#45046190)
Car airbags are basically that, and they have different levels of deployment (on a much lower budget).
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by borlox on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @10:25AM (#45040175)
When you're chosing to egress because the plane stops to know where it is or where it isn't, would you want it to decide how fast to eject? Chances are that the ejection system won't get reliable data to decide on in these situations.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by LorenPechtel on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @03:50PM (#45044268)
I believe the only relevant factor is airspeed.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by HPsquared on Thursday August 28, 2025 @03:59PM (#45056390)
Airspeed, altitude, vertical speed.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by LorenPechtel on Friday August 29, 2025 @05:14PM (#45069460)
Make it two motors, they either burn together or they burn one after the other. Neither altitude nor vertical speed is going to matter as you get the same impulse. Airspeed matters as you have to clear the tail.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by the__alchemist on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @10:56AM (#45040578)
I've never heard of this, but I imagine it would only make sense as a manual override used explicitly for controlled-ejection scenarios. This incident was almost one of those, but turned into an uncontrolled one.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by chasil on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @09:54AM (#45039722)
I imagine that ejecting at certain phases of these two attempts would not be survivable.

"The pilot then tried two “touch and go” landings, where the plane briefly lands, to try to straighten out the jammed nose gear, the report said."

Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by nacnud on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @10:29AM (#45040231)
According to the ejection seat manufacturer [1] there is no minimum height or speed at which the ejection seat can be used, so as long as the aircraft is roughly level then the ejection should be survivable.

[1] https://martin-baker.com/ejection-seats/us16e/

Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by jefftk on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @11:07AM (#45040759)
I would expect if the aircraft were level at 50 ft above the ground, flying inverted, an ejection would not be survivable.
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by palata on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @11:23AM (#45040967)
I assume it's what they meant with "as long as the aircraft is roughly level"...
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by dfox on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @10:56AM (#45040587)
The actual report mentions that this was a concern for actually landing the plane (as opposed to touch and go), because there was real possibility that the plane would end up in attitude that can hardly be described as "roughly level".
Re:F-35 pilot held 50-minute airborne conference call with e... by the__alchemist on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @10:57AM (#45040602)
The main times a "0/0" ejection would be expected to be unsurvivable are going really fast (e.g. breaking the mach), and with some combo of high sink rate and high bank.