News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by guywithahat on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @12:08PM (#45028477)
It doesn't, money has surprisingly little effect on competitive elections
Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by notRobot on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @12:12PM (#45028545)
So then shouldn't be a problem to stop it entirely, right?
Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by ch4s3 on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @12:15PM (#45028584)
How do you stop people from running 3rd party ads in the US while not violating the 1sr amendment? You get into dicey territory quickly. The old overturned election laws were used in many cases to prevent books from being published in election years.
Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by icandoit on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @12:26PM (#45028759)
>The old overturned election laws were used in many cases to prevent books from being published in election years.

Which laws and which books? I can't find anything.

Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by pcfwik on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @12:43PM (#45029020)
I assume the poster is referencing Citizens United v. FEC, specifically about the government's use of the 2002 Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act to restrict showing of political documentaries (apparently, called "Hillary: The Movie" and "Celsius 41.11").

While (as far as I know) the law was never actually used to ban books (only documentaries), the case became infamous because the government argued that it had the right to ban books if it wanted to. See, e.g., the NYTimes article below: "The [government's] lawyer, Malcolm L. Stewart, said Congress has the power to ban political books, signs and Internet videos, if they are paid for by corporations and distributed not long before an election.".

https://www.nytimes.com/2009/03/25/washington/25scotus.html https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens_United_v._FEC https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/cert/08-205

Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by ch4s3 on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @04:13PM (#45031757)
Yeah I made a mistake. There were a couple of films the FEC went after and they claimed the power extended to books as you pointed out. I was under-caffienated.
Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by guywithahat on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @01:41PM (#45029815)
No, because then the race wouldn't be competitive. It's a game theory problem, and it only holds true when both sides try their best. It's just that when both sides are trying their best, money doesn't seem to have a significant impact. It's why presidential races are often won by the candidate with less money (sometimes significantly less, like half the funding)
Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by iancmceachern on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @12:11PM (#45028522)
Do you have a source?
Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by MangoCoffee on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @12:16PM (#45028611)
just google kamala harris campaign fundraising vs trump. 2024 election just happened not too long ago. she got more money than trump and yet lose.

money is not the only factor.

Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by Chinjut on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @12:22PM (#45028691)
The election where the billionaire prominently campaigned for by the richest megabillionaire in the world won proves that money plays little role in politics.
Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by thejazzman on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @12:23PM (#45028703)
elon poured a ton of money into strategic locations right at the end, such as running a fake lottery in PA. many attribute the outcome on the role he played.

may not be the most money, but it's the most effective use of money.

PA roads were littered with trump signs because of people being paid to litter our streets with them. for months.

people are, sadly, very easily influenced. companies wouldn't pour so much into advertising, in general, if it didn't have such an effective influence

Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by prasadjoglekar on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @12:42PM (#45029003)
Reid Hoffman poured an equal amount of money thru Future Forward PAC on the Harris side.
Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by digital_sawzall on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @12:25PM (#45028729)
Kamala raised $1.65 billion compared to Trump's $1.1 billion [0]. Not like it was a massive difference. Especially because that does not take into account super pacs, like Musks $200million in Pennsylvania.

[0] https://www.usnews.com/opinion/articles/2024-11-15/trump-har...

Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by tzs on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @01:56PM (#45030003)
Probably what the money was spent on should be taken into account too.

Most campaigns stretch the truth a bit here and there, but from what I personally saw and from what I read from other states where the campaigning was more intense generally the Harris campaign did not stretch nearly as far as the Trump campaign.

I'd expect that this let the Tump campaign get more out of a given amount of spending than the Harris campaign could.

Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by iancmceachern on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @12:26PM (#45028755)
Yeah but if you ask chatgpt:

"Absolutely, money does have a measurable impact on political outcomes"

https://www.investopedia.com/surprising-thing-billionaires-s...

https://www.opensecrets.org/elections-overview/winning-vs-sp...

Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by myrmidon on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @12:32PM (#45028856)
Maybe, but Trump spent over half a billion on his 2024 campaign. Are you suggesting the outcome would have been unchanged had he spent a "sane" amount like $50M total? Because I don't think so.

Furthermore, in a country with somewhat free media you would always expect populist candidates to outperform with a given budget, because their platform is much better aligned with media interest; mass media does not want boring budget plans or quaint reforms-- rage-bait sells way better and nets populists tons of "free" online presence.

Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by guywithahat on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @12:46PM (#45029068)
For fun I did a non-scientific analysis of presidential candidates a while back, and found funding raised wasn't statistically significant https://thomashansen.xyz/blog/election-spending-isnt-statist...
Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by myrmidon on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @12:24PM (#45028719)
What does "surprisingly little" mean to you? US election spending in 2024 was almost $2bn (mostly presidential election).

If media presence had surprisingly little effect on outcomes, then I would expect candidates to spend surprisingly little or be constantly outperformed by "underfunded" candidates-- neither of which is the case.

Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by guywithahat on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @12:45PM (#45029052)
It's a game theory problem. There are lots of studies around executive performance, and what people find is that the specific executive/CEO has basically no impact, while things like general industry growth and direction is what matters (suggesting executive/CEO decisions are just a game of chance). But obviously I could also choose a bad executive who would tank the company. What's really happening is when everyone is trying their hardest, all of the executives are as good as they can be, and the things they do tend to look more like luck than performance.

It's the same thing in elections. Because everyone is competitive, who donates what money or it's amount tends to not really matter. If a candidate were to sabotage their campaign they would lose, but in a competitive election it doesn't end up being statistically significant.

Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by notahacker on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @12:44PM (#45029037)
The old "half of my advertising budget is wasted, but I have no idea which half" quote springs to mind...

Not sure how you're defining "underfunded" candidates, but the incumbents in competitive races where enormous amounts are spent by both sides to try to gain an advantage don't win anywhere near as often as the incumbent in nom-competitive races which parties and PACs barely bother spending in. Ultimately the spending is positional and cancels out, and the biggest spender often loses because there's not nearly enough difference between the candidates' spending levels to affect whether voters hear their messages.

Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by keiferski on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @12:51PM (#45029146)
This seems like a big number, but frankly in context it's actually quite trivial. We're talking about the lead office in the world's most dominant country, and the amount spent on the election is roughly equivalent to...the amount spent on ice cream or manga/comic books, per year.

There is a lot of money in America, and comparatively not that much is actually spent on the election. Maybe it's still too much in an ostensibly democratic system, but it's worth noting.

Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by myrmidon on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @01:52PM (#45029955)
> This seems like a big number, but frankly in context it's actually quite trivial.

It's not really helpful that the number is tolerable in terms of national GDP: election spending being so large in terms of median wealth simply excludes lots of capable potential candidates that are not well positioned to raise money (for whatever reason).

It also leads to completely outsized pandering to "rich donor" interests, because those finance the largest share of the campaigns, which is an obvious problem if you want to call yourself "democracy" (instead of oligarchy or plutocracy).

Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by keiferski on Wednesday August 27, 2025 @11:08AM (#45040774)
Yes, I didn’t say it was a good thing, I said it’s actually surprising that comparatively little money is spent on influencing the election. More money is spent on buying ice cream in a single year than on a once-every-four-years election.
Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by intermerda on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @12:35PM (#45028913)
If money has surprisingly little effect on competitive elections, why do candidates ask for it?
Re:Silicon Valley is pouring millions into pro-AI PACs to sw... by Perz1val on Tuesday August 26, 2025 @12:41PM (#45028989)
Yeah, cuz no matter who wins can be bought anyway... That's not good either