News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Building Ultra Cheap Energy Storage for Solar PV by throwaway81523 on Sunday August 24, 2025 @05:04AM (#45002635)
This is confusing, why PV to heat the dirt? Black paint will do it from sunlight directly. Or circulating hot liquid. Way cheaper and more efficient than PV at collecting heat from the sun.
Re:Building Ultra Cheap Energy Storage for Solar PV by hackernudes on Sunday August 24, 2025 @10:52AM (#45004683)
My understanding is this is for excess PV capacity. But I think they should address this! Their plan is to heat deep inside a big pile of dirt using resistive heating elements and then pump the heat out in pipes. Maybe it's hard or expensive to add solar heating into the system? But why couldn't they pump it in? Maybe they don't have extra space because the dirt mound is covered in PV panels.
Re:Building Ultra Cheap Energy Storage for Solar PV by theptip on Sunday August 24, 2025 @11:35AM (#45005025)
Water will be limited to 100C, and tanks are going to be way more expensive to maintain.

You don’t get much long-term storage with your black paint as it’s just going to heat the surface. The point here is to heat up a big enough pile of dirt that you can draw out power months later.

Re:Building Ultra Cheap Energy Storage for Solar PV by fabbbbb on Sunday August 24, 2025 @03:24PM (#45006917)
Liquid doesn’t need to mean water? Traditional solar thermal systems use special liquids that can get way more hot than 100C.
Re:Building Ultra Cheap Energy Storage for Solar PV by cyberax on Sunday August 24, 2025 @03:44PM (#45007106)
You can get to around 200C with oil-based media. But oil goes bad pretty quickly, and it leaches tons of crap out of everything.

Above that temperature, you need molten salts or liquid metals that are extremely corrosive. Your other option is to use gaseous media instead.

Re:Building Ultra Cheap Energy Storage for Solar PV by jacquesm on Sunday August 24, 2025 @03:57PM (#45007228)
And those have the problem of not having enough density so they'll be pretty inefficient.
Re:Building Ultra Cheap Energy Storage for Solar PV by theptip on Monday August 25, 2025 @01:02PM (#45016042)
Yeah good point. I think the point about cost is the real crux here, regardless of working temp. (CSP has used molten salt but it is quite expensive to store and maintain.)
Re:Building Ultra Cheap Energy Storage for Solar PV by buckle8017 on Sunday August 24, 2025 @03:44PM (#45007101)
There's very few materials cheaper than dirt.

Solid state solar panels should be more reliable than any hydronic system.

Though I suppose their heat recovery system is probably hydronic.

Re:Building Ultra Cheap Energy Storage for Solar PV by owenversteeg on Sunday August 24, 2025 @04:12PM (#45007358)
The sibling comment by theptip explains this well for this specific case, but the other sibling comment still seems confused, so I will explain more broadly: productive uses of heat are all about the temperature. The boundaries vary, but "high-grade" heat is roughly 300-500C, medium-grade is 100-300C, and low-grade <100C. Up to a certain point [0], heat is easier to use the hotter it is.

High-grade heat can be easily turned into electricity with a turbine, or reused in an industrial process (the entire point of a nuclear reactor is to create heat in this temperature range!) Medium-grade heat can still be used for some processes or used to generate electricity, but the electricity generation will be less efficient. Low-grade heat is under 100C and is a lot harder to use. You cannot economically generate electricity from it, or use it for most industrial processes, so use cases often focus on district heating.

The problem with these low-grade-heat district heating schemes, or more broadly any use of low-grade heat, is the economics. Let's take your idea. The efficiency from sunlight to heat is indeed high (much higher than PV panel -> resistive element) but the heat generated is all low-grade heat.

So what's the root cause here, why is low grade heat usually not economic to use? It comes back to two main causes: 1) efficiency, and 2) storage. Most power is generated from turbines that use heat - a type of heat engine. Carnot efficiency is the maximum theoretical efficiency of a heat engine. Carnot efficiency is η = 1 – Tcold/Thot where temperatures are absolute temperatures (Kelvin/Rankine.) In other words, 7.7% for 50C->25C (298K->323K), 37% for 200C->25C, and 61% for 500C->25C. Note that this is _theoretical_ maximum efficiency; real world efficiency varies quite a bit - from ~1/2 to ~1/10th of Carnot efficiency at peak depending on your heat engine. The second, storage costs, are even more important. You need to insulate your warm object to keep it warm, and if your heat is low-grade, then it is spread out across a huge volume.

Back to your idea, your "paint the dirt black" idea will generate far more heat, but very low-grade and entirely non-economic to use. You will have a somewhat warm pile of dirt, but nobody really wants a somewhat warm pile of dirt. This is the same reason why you see people, logically, tearing down their high-efficiency solar water heaters to install low-efficiency solar panels.

"Use solar panels to resistively heat the dirt", on the other hand, is less efficient and generates far less heat - but it generates high-grade heat. This startup proposes to eventually sell that heat to power plants, to generate electricity directly; and if you're doing that, the temperature of the heat is critical. As you can see from the Carnot efficiency, a power plant couldn't economically do anything with a warm pile of dirt, a solar water heater, or other similar technologies. But they _can_ do something with a source of high-grade heat - namely, they can run the turbines that currently run on fossil fuels. In other words, you can solve the seasonal solar curve problem and have constant electricity production year-round, even in northerly climes.

[0] Above - very roughly - 500C, it is harder to use the waste heat efficiently, because the engineering gets a lot harder, but the theoretical maximum efficiency is higher. That's one reason why there are a lot of efforts to try to build nuclear reactors working at these higher temperatures (see: molten salt reactors.)

Re:Building Ultra Cheap Energy Storage for Solar PV by simne on Sunday August 24, 2025 @04:42PM (#45007586)
Excellent explanation. I could add, typical Thermal Electric Station (Gas or Coal) could have significantly larger working temperature than Nuclear, because more strict safety measures for Nuclear on nearly same level technologies.

For example, Nuc typically don't cross 400C, when Gas/Coal could work on 450C or even more.

Plus, non-Nuc could use some more exotic technologies, like MHD (magnetohydrodynamic) generator, to provide much more efficiency of power generation, or CO2 turbine to make installation much smaller. (Theoretically, somebody could build Nuclear MHD device, but it will not pass safety restrictions).

Re:Building Ultra Cheap Energy Storage for Solar PV by owenversteeg on Monday August 25, 2025 @01:58AM (#45010675)
Something I forgot to mention - because of the low temperatures involved, district heating people love to talk about the potential use of low-grade heat, but the overwhelming majority of district heating is sourced from high-grade heat. By far the largest installation of district heating is across the former USSR, where the source is mostly nuclear. The USSR used nuclear not for want of industrial processes or black paint, but because the engineering involved is far more practical when you start with high grade heat. From an old report on Soviet district heating: at -23C, buildings were supplied with water around 80C and returned it around 57C. That may sound like it is within the ballpark of low-grade heat, but it required a plant sendout temperature in excess of 150C to get that 80C building supply. And, of course, your heat source has to be higher than your plant sendout temp... and now you're at fairly high temperatures. At that point, you might as well build a nuclear combined heat and power plant for maximum efficiency, which is in fact what the Soviets did.

If you want to do practical district heating, you should look to the Soviets. Unfortunately, most of this information is available in Russian, on physical paper.

[0] http://waterworkshistory.us/DH/1967USSRreport.pdf page 18, figure 2

Re:Building Ultra Cheap Energy Storage for Solar PV by te0006 on Monday August 25, 2025 @05:04AM (#45011818)
Another country with highly developed district heating system is Denmark. They heavily invested in this technology since the 1970s, and currently around 2/3 of all households have district heating, in the capital, Copenhagen, 98%. Moreover, more than 60% of the energy used for these systems comes from renewables. No nuclear power involved (which hast been banned in the country since 1985). A few sources: - https://dbdh.org/all-about-district-energy/district-heating-... - https://stateofgreen.com/en/news/new-plans-to-expand-the-dan... - https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S136403212...
Re:Building Ultra Cheap Energy Storage for Solar PV by owenversteeg on Monday August 25, 2025 @06:47PM (#45020083)
It is true that Denmark has a large district heating system - their national system is nearly as big as that of, say, St. Petersburg. But I think the Danes should be honest with themselves about the reality. The heat comes from burning stuff (wood/biomass, trash, and fossil fuels), the overwhelming majority of biomass is imported - and about 40% of those imports are from non-EU countries. If Denmark burns a tree, that is considered to be zero emissions, because - they argue - those emissions have already been accounted for in a change in _Danish_ land use and forestry. If you are deforesting a foreign country to warm your house, that’s a) not accounted for in your national emissions statistics and b) often not accounted for in the foreign country’s emissions either. So you get heat for free. Of course, if you forget to replant the trees, or they fail to grow back, then the emissions are worse than coal, because coal is underground, trees are not, and thus the surface albedo changes are significant.

The steel-man case for Denmark is that trees usually do grow back, and indeed, global _tree_ cover is substantially higher than it was 35 years ago. But global _forest_ cover is still shrinking, and much of the wood entering Denmark comes from forests. Forest cover is more important than tree cover - for the aforementioned reason of albedo changes, but also biodiversity.

Where things really get absurd is when you begin to calculate the area of land you have to turn into a tree farm to keep your homes warm. Or when you calculate the market effects of buying a huge amount of trees - even if all _your_ trees were good ethical trees from a farm, you have just consumed a large amount of the supply and thus financially incentivized cutting down old-growth forests elsewhere - for example look at the history of Ikea’s wood use. If there were more Denmarks, and it was not just a small country with the population of the Chicago area, there would be massive worldwide devastation.

Don’t get me wrong, I am not an absolute opponent of biomass. It is true that burning things is a great source of high-grade heat. It can play a small role in a sustainable energy mix. But it is not the free lunch Danes think it is, and certainly not at the scale they consume it.

Re:Building Ultra Cheap Energy Storage for Solar PV by Animats on Sunday August 24, 2025 @05:43PM (#45008083)
Because they're trying to go way up on temperature. The idea is to get dirt up to 600°C. It's easy to get warm water from solar, and solar water heaters have been around for decades, if not centuries. But that's well below 100°C. If you start from electricity, you can reach any temperature up to plasma. If you're just storing warm water, you can't get much of the energy back. E = (T2-T1)/T2, remember.

They've made no progress on getting the energy out of their heated dirt. They want to make a hot dirt powered boiler - run pipes through the dirt, put in water, and get steam. Not hot water, superheated steam. That's the hard part, and it will have to be custom.

Small steam turbines are available. Siemens has a whole range.[1] They start around 750KW, at the high end of automotive scale. Siemens can sell you a matching generator. When these guys can power one of those, it's real.

Right now, it's three guys. They need VC funding and a really good boiler engineer. The goal should be a working prototype at about 500KW scale. That would be a big enough prototype to get some meaningful efficiency measurements.

(Maintenance will be tough. You can't turn the heat source off.)

[1] file:///home/john/Downloads/SE-Brochure-Dresser-Rand-Steam-Turbines-2021-pdf_Original_20file.pdf

Re:Building Ultra Cheap Energy Storage for Solar PV by Animats on Monday August 25, 2025 @02:15AM (#45010772)