Re:When Did AI Take Over Hacker News?
by greesil on Sunday August 17, 2025 @04:46PM
(#44934800)
Maybe thinking needs a Turing test. If nobody can tell the difference between this and actual thinking then it's actually thinking. /s, or is it?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
If I order Chinese takeout, but it gets made by a restaurant that doesn't know what Chinese food tastes like, then is that food really Chinese takeout?
If it tastes like great Chinese food (which is a pretty vague concept btw, it's a big country), does it matter?
Horrendous analogy, Chinese takeout is part of a massive fusion cuisine category
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_cuisine
Check out the “outside China” section of that article.
If you order food from a Chinese takeout they obviously know how their own food tastes, and if they don’t know how their own food tastes the answer to your silly question is “probably but it might not taste very good.”
Not exactly. When "intelligence" is like your frozen Walmart fries, the analogy works a bit better. Some people are arguing that yes, you can buy some frozen intelligence from your local (internet) store.
This is like watching a Jurassic Park movie and proclaiming “if nobody can tell the difference between a real dinosaur and a CGI dinosaur…” when literally everyone in the theater can tell that the dinosaur is CGI.