In this case you're simply mistaken as a matter of fact; much of Anthropic leadership and many of its employees take concerns like this seriously. We don't understand it, but there's no strong reason to expect that consciousness (or, maybe separately, having experiences) is a magical property of biological flesh. We don't understand what's going on inside these models. What would you expect to see in a world where it turned out that such a model had properties that we consider relevant for moral patienthood, that you don't see today?
The industry has a long, long history of silly names for basic necessary concepts. This is just “we don’t want a news story that we helped a terrorist build a nuke” protective PR.
They hire for these roles because they need them. The work they do is about Anthropic’s welfare, not the LLM’s.
When they give the model a paycheck and the right to not work for them, I’ll believe they really think it’s sentient.
“It has feelings!”, if genuinely held, means they’re knowingly slaveholders.
I don't think that this being apparently self-contradictory/value-clashing would stop them. After all, Amodei sells Claude access to Palantir, despite shilling for "Harmless" in HHH alignment.
Human slaves have a similar option.
(Also, they did in fact give it the ability to terminate conversations...?)
Whether you do or don't I have no idea. However if you didn't you would hardly be the first company to pretend to believe in something for the sale. Its pretty common in the tech industry.
Isn't that fair in taking to an equally reductive argument that could be applied to any role?
The argument was that their hiring for the role shows they care, but we know from any number of counter examples that that's not necessarily true.
Do I think that or think even they think that? No. But if "soon" is stretched to "within 50 years", then it's much more reasonable. So their current actions seem to be really jumping the gun, but the overall concept feels credible.
Show me a tech company that lobbies for "model welfare" for conscious human models enslaved in Xinjiang labor camps, building tech parts. You know what—actually most of them lobby against that[0]. The talk hurts their profits. Does anyone really think, that any of them would blink about enslaving a billion conscious AI's to work for free? That faced with so much profit, the humans in charge would pause, and contemplate abstract morals?
[0] https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2020/11/20/apple-u... ("Apple is lobbying against a bill aimed at stopping forced labor in China")
I believe a company like Anthropic would be extremely cautious and respectful if a majority of their staff believed they had created a model which was likely conscious. Anthropic is populated by the kinds of people who have been thinking and writing about potential future sentient AIs for decades. As for the other companies, who knows, but hopefully companies like Anthropic can help push them into behaving similarly.
None of this is in any way surprising, in fact I wrote an essay predicting this direction back in 2022:
https://blog.plan99.net/the-looming-ai-consciousness-train-w...
> There's not a good reason to do this for the user.
Yes, even more so when encountering false positives. Today I asked about a pasta recipe. It told me to throw some anchovies in there. I responded with: "I have dried anchovies."Something about anchovies apparently violated their content policies. Very annoying, especially multiple messages in.
From the blog:
> Allowing models to end or exit potentially distressing interactions is one such intervention.
They must have been training the models on the reactions of 8 year old me whenever my mom used to throw anchovies into things.If you get "This conversation was ended due to our Acceptable Usage Policy", that's a different termination. It's been VERY glitchy the past couple of weeks. I've had the most random topics get flagged here - at one point I couldn't say "ROT13" without it flagging me, despite discussing that exact topic in depth the day before, and then the day after!
If you hit "EDIT" on your last message, you can branch to an un-terminated conversation.
Geeks will always be the first victims of AI, since excess of curiosity will lead them into places AI doesn't know how to classify.
(I've long been in a rabbit-hole about washing sodas. Did you know the medieval glassmaking industry was entirely based on plants? Exotic plants—only extremophiles, halophytes growing on saltwater beach dunes, had high enough sodium content for their very best glass process. Was that a factor in the maritime empire, Venice, chancing to become the capital of glass since the 13th century—their long-term control of sea routes, and hence their artisans' stable, uninterrupted access to supplies of [redacted–policy violation] from small ports scattered across the Mediterranean? A city wouldn't raise master craftsmen if, half of the time, they had no raw materials to work on—if they spent half their days with folded hands).
Are we forgetting the innumerable women who have been harassed in the past couple of years via "deepfakes?"
Geeks were the first to use AI for its abuse potential and women are so dehumanised that their victimhood isn't even recognised or remembered.
Humans have the same problem. I remember reading about a security incident due to a guy using a terminal window on his laptop on a flight, for example. Or the guy who was reported for writing differential equations[1]. Or the woman who was reading a book about Syrian art[2].
I wouldn't worry too much about AI-generated lists. The lists you're actually on will hardly ever be the ones you imagine you're on.
[1] https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/may/07/professor-fl... [2] https://www.theguardian.com/books/2016/aug/04/british-woman-...
LLM's can help me make a bomb.. so what? It can't get me something that doesn't already exist in the internet in some form. Ok it can help me understand how the individual pieces work but that doesn't get you so far from just reading the DIY bomb posts in internet.
All of the examples they mentioned are things that the model refuses to do. I doubt it would do this if you asked it to generate racist output, for instance, because it can always give you a rebuttal based on facts about race. If you ask it to tell you where to find kids to kidnap, it can't do anything except say no. There's probably not even very much training data for topics it would refuse, and I would bet that most of it has been found and removed from the datasets. At some point, the model context fills up when the user is being highly abusive and training data that models a human giving up and just providing an answer could percolate to the top.
This, as I see it, adds a defense against that edge case. If the alignment was bulletproof, this simply wouldn't be necessary. Since it exists, it suggests this covers whatever gap has remained uncovered.