Re:A case study in bad hiring practice and how to fix it
by herodoturtle on Wednesday August 13, 2025 @01:54PM
(#44891610)
> In the UK, where Canonical and Mark hail from
Minor nitpick, but Mark hails from (and was schooled in) South Africa.
Agree with your overall point.
Re:A case study in bad hiring practice and how to fix it
by whimsicalism on Wednesday August 13, 2025 @01:51PM
(#44891575)
i think itβs pretty clear GP is not saying it is worthwhile and is actually implicitly criticizing the practice.
> high school performance is a statistical proxy for class (wealth). In the US, it is a statistical proxy for ethnicity as well.
the degree to which this claim about wealth is true is impacted by confounders. it is generally less true than commonly stated. outside of the public sector, that a measure is correlated with race/ethnicity/class does not make it a priori illegal to hire based on.
There's two big reasons this is such a red flag: 1) Come on. Unless you are hiring highschool graduates directly, you have other means of finding out how good candidates are. If a highschool report card tells you more about a candidate than your own interview process, you need to fire everyone involved with that process.
2) Highschool performance is highly correlated with a bunch of causes that are very undesirable things to proxy-measure in your hiring process.
In the UK, where Canonical and Mark hail from, high school performance is a statistical proxy for class (wealth). In the US, it is a statistical proxy for ethnicity as well. You need to be careful with such measures, as selecting job candidates based on class or race is both unethical and commonly illegal.
Again consider that these are high school results. A person who is born to unlucky schooling opportunities can still compensate for the learning they were deprived of by working harder in college/university or their formal career after that.