Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack
by arrowsmith on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @09:24AM
(#44875913)
> $75m per day is clearly sustainable.
Is this a typo or am I misunderstanding something?
Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack
by max_ on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @09:53AM
(#44876213)
Thanks.
"unsustainable"
Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack
by m_herrlich on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @10:21AM
(#44876549)
now it says unstainable
Also true!
Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack
by transcriptase on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @09:31AM
(#44875986)
I’m guessing it’s implied that the return would be higher than $75m a day.
Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack
by sschueller on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @10:43AM
(#44876883)
Depends what the goal is. A state that wants to break the anonymity of the system doesn't care about $75m per day, specifically a state that can just print that...
Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack
by woah on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @11:49AM
(#44877923)
I'm not familiar with Monero's privacy system, so I can't say for sure, but it is very, very unlikely that a reorg could in any way break anonymity.
Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack
by fruitworks on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @03:14PM
(#44880627)
Reorgs dont break anonyminity
Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack
by idiotsecant on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @11:47AM
(#44877877)
The problem is not that the system is constantly under attack. It's that it can no longer be trusted to be secure. Nobody with money on chain will say 'oh well, probably nobody will steal my money today'.
Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack
by do_not_redeem on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @12:10PM
(#44878273)
A 51% attack doesn't let you steal random people's money.
Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack
by idiotsecant on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @11:42PM
(#44884464)
It absolutely does, just not directly. Say that you have 100k fiat equivilent in monero and I demonstrate a successful monero double-spend attack. How much do you think your monero is worth?
Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack
by do_not_redeem on Wednesday August 13, 2025 @12:16AM
(#44884598)
My man. What do you think the word "steal" means? You can't just redefine words because you don't like new technology.
Do we need to drop down to 1st grade story problems?
---
Alice has 1 apple. Eve has 0 apples.
Eve steals Alice's apple.
Now Alice has 0 apples. Eve has 1 apple.
---
Alice has 1 XMR. Eve has 0 XMR.
Eve 51% attacks Alice's network.
How many XMR does Alice have? How many XMR does Eve have? Show your work.
Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack
by idiotsecant on Wednesday August 13, 2025 @06:08PM
(#44894447)
The only reason this seems like an unusual definition to you is that you haven't thought about it very hard, yet. The critical thing is not how many XMR you have. It's what value those XMR carry. If I create from thin air 1000 XMR and it's known to the market I didn't just 'make' a certain amount of value, I made myself richer by making a lot of people less so. I stole value from them and gave it to myself, just like someone stealing a ham at the market. The only difference is that instead of burning one ham of value for one ham of benefit, I burn many ham of value for one ham of benefit.
This is how proof of work systems operate.
They are very expensive to attack but very cheap to recover from.
$75m per day is clearly unstainable.
Soon they will give up and the network will recover cheaply.
The attack is more of a nuisance than the end of Monero.