News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack by lagniappe on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @08:53AM (#44875624)
>until now, no-one has chosen to flex like this.

The two networks have wildly different proof-of-work algorithms, they're incompatible. A BTC ASIC will never mine Monero, ever.

Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack by rokkamokka on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @09:02AM (#44875727)
That's not true for all altcoins however
Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack by scyclow on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @10:32AM (#44876712)
Pretty much everything other than bitcoin, monero, and dogecoin are running proof of stake these days anyhow, so it kind of doesn't matter.
Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack by OutOfHere on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @10:56AM (#44877072)
Litecoin goes in that PoW group too.

In fact, Litecoin has an optional privacy feature called MWEB, which is probably why Litecoin too got kicked off of being named on some conventional news sites.

Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack by subsistence234 on Wednesday August 13, 2025 @12:08PM (#44890299)
KAS is PoW, at ~240 times the hash-rate of LTC, ~120 000 000 times the hash-rate of XMR, and 0.0007 times the hash-rate of BTC. Obviously not really comparable...

https://poolbay.io/coins

Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack by yieldcrv on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @10:27AM (#44876643)
Its always hilarious when someone launches an L1 with an algorithm everyone can already dominate and it gets attacked immediately

Last time I saw that was on photonics processor blockchains

Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack by idiotsecant on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @11:43AM (#44877792)
That's not at all relevant to parent post's point. BTC mining is famously centralized, and continues to get more so. It is inevitable that a manufacturer of BTC asics with access to cheap power will become large enough to control 51% of the hash. It's inevitable. It's bad system design - it makes being able to manufacture your own custom silicon table stakes to run a financial system for some reason.

BTC will have to move to a proof of stake design to survive. It's unavoidable.

Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack by ifwinterco on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @11:55AM (#44878039)
That is debatable, but also besides anything else, changing to PoS means changing the tokenomics (some tail emission for staking rewards, no 21m hard cap), which means it's incredibly unlikely to happen
Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack by ChadNauseam on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @06:01PM (#44882285)
why would staking rewards be any more necessary than mining rewards?
Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack by ifwinterco on Wednesday August 13, 2025 @03:23AM (#44885543)
In the end state (after ~2140), mining rewards just come from TX fees. But true, it is possible you could just redistribute TX fees to stakers.

Post-merge ethereum is designed so that the gas fees and the staking rewards roughly cancel out on balance (so overall inflation is around zero), but they are decoupled so even if nobody is using the network you still get a staking yield

Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack by eurleif on Wednesday August 13, 2025 @03:25AM (#44885556)
>so overall inflation is around zero

Pedantic point: monetary inflation is around zero, not necessarily price inflation (which is what people typically mean when they just say "inflation").

Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack by ifwinterco on Wednesday August 13, 2025 @10:49AM (#44889193)
Yes sorry, important clarification.

In theory if the entire world was on an ethereum standard with a steady state population, price inflation would also average out to zero

Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack by robocat on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @11:56AM (#44878056)
> It is inevitable that a manufacturer of BTC asics with access to cheap power will become large enough to control 51% of the hash

The ASIC manufacturer would also need a backdoor. ASIC manufacturers don't control mining.

Large miners are unlikely to allow backdoors into their mining network.

Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack by fruitworks on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @03:00PM (#44880455)
ASIC miners often do control mining. They often mine with chips before they drop them in the public market
Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack by passivegains on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @08:01PM (#44883203)
I think they mean the manufacturer would just keep most of the stock for themselves. Reminds me of that famous Scarface quote: "You should get high on your own supply, it's a great idea that won't end horribly."
Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack by idiotsecant on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @11:44PM (#44884471)
>ASIC manufacturers don't control mining.

I dont think you understand the BTC mining ecosystem

Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack by LikesPwsh on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @12:52PM (#44878890)
BTC can't move to proof of stake because religious zealots would keep their money in the old fork.

It's doomed in general, see the cash fork.

Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack by latchkey on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @03:52PM (#44881103)
Tokenized bitcoin.
Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack by soganess on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @05:40PM (#44882104)
I ask this not as a gotcha (I don't know the first thing about this), but rather because I'm interested: How do you know not "ever"?

Like, trivially, it's an ASIC, so I can use it to simulate a von Neumann[*] machine, hence I can use it to run whatever algorithm I want. Would that be more efficient than using a modern OoO superscalar? Almost surely not, but that doesn't mean it can't be done, just that it shouldn't be done that way.

*: I realize that the ASICs used in Bitcoin miners don't have dram access, but that isn't a general limitation of ASICs, just those ASIC 'chips' (and maybe not even those chips, just their implementations in bitcoin miners)

EDIT: Thanks to everyone who answered! For some reason, I had it in my head that the way we implement fixed function stuff in an ASIC was basically the same as a "burn once" FPGA. Brains gonna brain.

Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack by tux3 on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @06:22PM (#44882466)
>Like, trivially, it's an ASIC, so I can use it to simulate a von Neumann[*] machine

No, that doesn't follow at all. An ASIC doesn't mean a general purpose CPU or FPGA. A chip that only knows how to do, say, video decoding is an example of ASIC. The video chip can't do bitcoin, the bitcoin chip can't do monero. They're not general purpose.

Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack by BoppreH on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @06:18PM (#44882435)
You might be confusing ASICs with FPGAs. You can't reprogram an ASIC, the algorithm is fixed at design time, and the chip built for this single purpose.
Re:Monero appears to be in the midst of a successful 51% attack by blibble on Tuesday August 12, 2025 @06:23PM (#44882479)
> Like, trivially, it's an ASIC, so I can use it to simulate a von Neumann[*] machine

asic does not mean turing complete

good luck simulating a von neumann machine on a sha256 accelerator