Re:DHH: The Framework Desktop is a beast
by trenchpilgrim on Saturday August 09, 2025 @05:28PM
(#44850422)
The 128GB version wouldn't be throwaway, since that's the maximum the platform as a whole supports anyway- more memory than that would require a new mainboard and CPU at the same time.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:DHH: The Framework Desktop is a beast
by nemomarx on Saturday August 09, 2025 @05:32PM
(#44850458)
Not for upgrade reasons but what if you have a fault in one of the dimms or etc? Now you can't just drop in a replacement without changing everything.
Re:DHH: The Framework Desktop is a beast
by cyanydeez on Saturday August 09, 2025 @06:12PM
(#44850802)
it's basically the same as asking what happens when your M4 Apple has a fault. It's soldered based on the desire to use the ram as part of the GPU.
Without that, it's really not a interesting solution.
demanding replaceable ram means also not wanting the benefits of the integrated memory
I wonder why so few people ask Apple products of such questions -- "what if my SSD goes bad, does it mean my computer is now completely useless?"
I would also ask this! But part of the framework brand was selling a laptop where the answer to that question was being able to replace it on your own. So it's just kind of a contrast for their desktop to be less repairable than their laptop.
Personally I think it's bad that apple products are so poorly repairable and so expensive to upgrade.
Re:DHH: The Framework Desktop is a beast
by alpaca128 on Sunday August 10, 2025 @09:13AM
(#44854978)
Worse, Apple also still claims to care about the environment. While not allowing the iMac to be used as external screen, cutting its useful lifetime by at least a decade.
Re:DHH: The Framework Desktop is a beast
by sidewndr46 on Sunday August 10, 2025 @09:09AM
(#44854953)
How often have you had a memory chip fail? I ask because I only have had it happen once in my lifetime that I can recall and it was for a very dumb reason.