But I fear it's worse. Based on how past open standards played out, I find it believable they do care - that there won't be an open ecosystem of password managers.
> But they’ve shown no evidence of hating user freedom on principle.
Yes, they did, just see Microsoft's crusade against Linux and the origin of the "embrace-extend-extinguish" term.
I recommend reading the MDN docs on Webauthn, they’re surprisingly accessible.
> Yes, they did, just see Microsoft's crusade against Linux and the origin of the "embrace-extend-extinguish" term.
The whole point of the trial that term came from was that Microsoft explicitly saw Linux as a material threat to their business. What threat are Google quashing by preventing you from using passkeys they don’t control?
I agree, why would BigTech care about those dozens of users. Screw those guys, they can use our password manager or they can get lost, we don't need them!
Because big tech loves control. Just because you can't see the angle yet, it doesn't mean there isn't one now, or won't be one later. It has been shown time and time again that they will take all the freedom away from you that they can.
Even if there wasn't already an example, it's easy to turn control into a revenue stream at a later time.
> Even if there wasn't already an example, it's easy to turn control into a revenue stream at a later time.
I think you’ll have to justify or qualify this a bit. If Google forces every website on Chrome to have a red background, how do they turn that control into a revenue stream later on?
Chrome has already started kicking off extensions, see ublock.
I can't divine the future about how they will further their income streams.
As for blocking things that block ads; if you can’t see the monetary incentive for Google there then I don’t know what to tell you.
I didn’t ask you to divine the future. I said “I’ve not seen them do X without trying to get Y” (a statement about the past), and you still haven’t given me a remotely credible example.
Where's the direct monetary incentive to interfere with end users installing a modified Android image? What about SafetyNet?
At absolute minimum you can use it to influence the perception of your brand as being the gold standard.
Bots using a custom password manager to share logins.
Now the Yubikey is just an API you can call, websites cannot tell the difference. You can't export keys, but a bot can add new keys after using existing keys to log in.
Every time I’ve seen them actually attack user freedom, there was an embarrassingly obvious business angle. Like Chrome’s browser attestation that was definitely not to prevent Adblock, no sir.