My first machines were the IBM 7044 (36-bit word) and the PDP-8 (12-bit word), and I must admit to a certain nostalgia for that style of machine (as well as the fact that a 36-bit word gives you some extra floating-point precision), but as others have pointed out, there are good reasons for power-of-2 byte and word sizes.
Were these instructions atomic regarding interrupts? If not, then these look like shorthands for masking/shifting bit-fields out of words, leaving the word as the smallest atomically addressable unit.
My fantasy CPU lets you write to the (say) 15 bits starting at the 43rd but of a 48 bit word which a real CPU would have to do a lot of work to implement but with the right kind of cache it is probably not so bad, it also has an instruction to read a UTF-8 character at a deep pointer and increment the pointer which a real system could satisfy out of the cache except when it can’t.
In fact, recent-ish x86 CPUs have similar instructions, and as of Zen4 they are fast not just on Intel but also on AMD (previously they were microcoded as a bunch of shifts AFAIK with pretty lousy latency)
AI is not just wrong, its so stupendously stupidly wrong, you need to change its drool bib. The PDP-10 was a "six 6-bit ASCII characters, supporting the upper-case unaccented letters, digits, space, and most ASCII punctuation characters. It was used on the PDP-6 and PDP-10 under the name sixbit."
"So PDP-10 didn't have 9-bit bytes, but could support them. Characters were typically 6 bytes, but 7-bit and 9-bit characters were also sometimes used."
Note: "four 9-bit characters[1][2] (the Multics convention)." Confirmed.
</END!!!>
The article says:
> A number of 70s computing systems had nine-bit bytes, most prominently the PDP-10
This is false. If you ask ChatGPT "Was the PDP-10 a 9 bit computer?" it says "Yes, the PDP-10 used a 36-bit word size, and it treated characters as 9-bit bytes."
But if you ask any other LLM or look it up on Wikipedia, you see that:
> Some aspects of the instruction set are unusual, most notably the byte instructions, which operate on bit fields of any size from 1 to 36 bits inclusive, according to the general definition of a byte as a contiguous sequence of a fixed number of bits.
-- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PDP-10
So PDP-10 didn't have 9-bit bytes, but could support them. Characters were typically 6 bytes, but 7-bit and 9-bit characters were also sometimes used.