Re:We'd be Better Off with 9-bit Bytes
by p_l on Thursday August 07, 2025 @08:49AM
(#44823821)
They are atomic, indeed. The underlying implementation might have used masking and shifting, especially in bit-slice implementations like KS-10, but as far as operation of the computer was concerned they were atomic.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:We'd be Better Off with 9-bit Bytes
by PaulHoule on Thursday August 07, 2025 @01:30PM
(#44827529)
It becomes problematic for multiprocessor systems but you could probably build a communications fabric and memory model that works.
My fantasy CPU lets you write to the (say) 15 bits starting at the 43rd but of a 48 bit word which a real CPU would have to do a lot of work to implement but with the right kind of cache it is probably not so bad, it also has an instruction to read a UTF-8 character at a deep pointer and increment the pointer which a real system could satisfy out of the cache except when it can’t.
For PDP-10, because it operated only on word values, you can easily assume that every bus and memory operation passes a full 36 bit word every time.
In fact, recent-ish x86 CPUs have similar instructions, and as of Zen4 they are fast not just on Intel but also on AMD (previously they were microcoded as a bunch of shifts AFAIK with pretty lousy latency)