News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by kristofferR on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @01:23PM (#4475532)
Thank God, seems like it'll be called iPhone 5 instead of "the new iPhone".
Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by schiffern on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @01:37PM (#4475591)
This confuses me.

Why does anyone care? The iPod had undifferentiated names for a decade, despite dramatic changes in capabilities. Whenever there's a need for specificity (e.g. buying/selling a device online), people had no problem specifying "iPod third generation," "iPod nano second generation" etc.

Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by jamesaguilar on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @02:34PM (#4475851)
I would say the only substantial change from one iPod to the next was the amount of storage and the quality of the screen. You'd never need to talk about which generation you had, because they only do one thing: play music. Meanwhile, successive iPhones have a few features that differentiate how they actually behave:

    - processor (screen smoothness, webpage performance, what games you can play)
    - camera (quality of images)
    - radio antenna type
    - OS versions supported (iPhone features often vary by OS version, unlike the features of the traditional iPod)
In conclusion, iPods only have one real feature, and it doesn't change, so you don't need to talk about version numbers. iPhones have more features that do change, so version numbers are important.
Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by schiffern on Wednesday September 05, 2012 @03:09PM (#4480905)
>I would say the only substantial change from one iPod to the next was the amount of storage and the quality of the screen.

That's quite the selective memory you've got there.

- First gen. "1000 songs in your pocket." First music player to use Firewire (no USB 2.0 yet!). First HDD player to use 1.8" drives.

- Second gen. Touch replaces mechanical scroll wheel. Windows compatibility (MusicMatch).

- Third gen. Mechanical buttons entirely replaced with touch. USB syncing. iTunes Music Store. iTunes for Windows. First iPod to feature the dock connector. Full case redesign.

- Fourth gen. Return to mechanical controls with the click wheel. iPod Photo introduced, the first iPod that can output to an external display.

- Fifth gen. Photo merged into regular iPod. Video playback. Music videos and TV shows appear on the increasingly poorly named iTunes Music Store for the first time. Gapless playback. Games.

- Sixth generation. Aluminum case. Dramatically better battery life (36 hours vs. 8-12). Genius. Audio recording.

Maybe you could argue that the fourth and sixth generation iPods were just capacity bumps and screen overhauls, but many of these features are no less significant than the "processor upgrades" and "radio antenna type" that you cite for the iPhone.

Apple didn't dominate the portable music player space for a decade (>70% marketshare the entire time) by standing still. They also didn't have monotonically increasing revision numbers tacked onto the end.

Saying there were no substantial changes to the iPod because "it just plays music" is only slightly less absurd than saying there are no substantial changes to the iPhone because "it just makes calls."

And of course, I'm not including the best example of revisionless names, the iPod Touch! We all know it's a stripped-down iPhone, but it's always been called simply "the iPod Touch."

Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by micampe on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @03:10PM (#4476045)
What year is your Porsche 911?
Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by jamesaguilar on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @04:23PM (#4476351)
I don't understand where you're going with this. Are you implying that there are meaningful comparisons to be made between a luxury vehicle whose base model costs $79,000 and a device for playing music whose base model costs $99? Or the opposite?

Anyway, I have a MINI. The Porsche is too expensive for me.

Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by micampe on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @04:40PM (#4476417)
what does price have to do with naming?

I was implying that there are many many products where the manufacturer changes the model and keeps the same name. I used the 911 because it's very recognizable name, but your Mini is using the same name as the one that was produced in 1961 and you definitely can't use the same accessories, not even the same gas.

but wait, I'm also going to argue the opposite right here in the same comment: Leica has been making the M cameras since 1954 and they use numbers, sometimes with suffixes just like the S in 4S (M3, M4, M4P, M5). they even went backwards with the M2 released after the M3, and they all use exactly the same lenses and accessories.

my point? it's an entirely pointless discussion trying to rationalize which is more correct or more wrong: companies have been doing both for decades and both have been successful.

Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by jamesaguilar on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @04:59PM (#4476500)
I see, you're arguing that the approach doesn't matter. I think anyone who has tried to suss out which Intel chip to buy in the last few years would like to have a word with you. Some approaches are better than others.

And: pointless discussions are the only kind we have here. So why complain about it?

Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by micampe on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @05:29PM (#4476646)
not complaining, adding my opinion, since I saw a lot of people arguing against each other and nobody had the same opinion I had, that the naming doesn't matter that much.
Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by jonny_eh on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @04:13PM (#4476315)
Does that affect what software I can install on it?
Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by qq66 on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @02:40PM (#4475885)
iPods grew in feature set as much as iPhones have... they added cameras, video, color screens, and FM radio over the product lifecycle.
Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by jamesaguilar on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @02:49PM (#4475939)
Hmm, compared to the changing features of iPhones, how important do you think the new features of iPods were to buyers (especially in the first few generations)? Me, I never used the FM radio or video capabilities of my iPod. I could be atypical. Camera, maybe, but by the time that was introduced the iPod already had a long history of not having version numbers.

And color screen is an interface change, not a functional change, so it doesn't really fall into the set of things I was talking about earlier.

Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by truebecomefalse on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @03:12PM (#4476059)
Very important...sometimes. I had someone order 100 of the wrong generation once... We needed front facing camera in out setup. I'm not sure how typical our use case was but there was another 10,000 item order of the correct generation after the contract completed.
Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by jamesaguilar on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @04:26PM (#4476369)
Pretty sure that if you're ordering a lot of a hundred of them, you're already outside the range of the typical buyer I was referring to earlier. That said, can you share what you were using them for? You've piqued my curiosity.
Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by rahoulb on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @04:23PM (#4476357)
It matters a lot when buying cases (as someone who knows Apple products and still bought the wrong one for my wife's Nano)
Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by nchlswu on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @01:52PM (#4475646)
I never understood why so many people made such a huge deal out of this.

IIRC, it was only referred to the "new iPad" in marketing materials. If Apple was focused on reducing the importance of numbers, what else would you call it in a conversation? The new or the newest ipad.

Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by ceejayoz on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @01:31PM (#4475576)
I'm just waiting for the people who were absolutely certain Apple would call it the iPhone 6 to show up.
Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by MatthewPhillips on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @01:57PM (#4475667)
iPhone 5 would be more confusing considering this will be the 6th generation.
Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by arrrg on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @02:28PM (#4475823)
6th iPhone, arguably the 4th generation (iPhone 1, iPhone 3G and 3GS as one generation, iPhone 4 and 4S as one generation).

Naming it iPhone 6 would be extremely confusing for consumers (Where did the 5 go?!), as would 4G. The only workable alternative is iPhone 5. Anything else would be a horrible idea from a marketing point of view.

Yeah, it’s slightly inconsistent, but that’s just how it is. (Apple used the 4 both as an iPhone number – with the iPhone 4 – and like a generation number – with the iPhone 4S. That’s how they already introduced the inconsistency they now have to work around.)

Your homework: Why did Apple count iPhones and not generations when they introduced the iPhone 4? There is a pretty simple answer to that.

Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by MatthewPhillips on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @02:33PM (#4475849)
> 6th iPhone, arguably the 4th generation (iPhone 1, iPhone 3G and 3GS as one generation, iPhone 4 and 4S as one generation).

Are you still going to think that when the new iPhone still looks like the 4/4s model?

> Naming it iPhone 6 would be extremely confusing for consumers (Where did the 5 go?!), as would 4G. The only workable alternative is iPhone 5. Anything else would be a horrible idea from a marketing point of view.

Or drop the number altogether and leave the math to the nerds who care.

Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by arrrg on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @02:48PM (#4475934)
If the rumours are anything to go by the next iPhone is deservedly a new generation. New metal back, larger screen, different connector, …

Sure, it looks somewhat similar to the 4/4S, but you would have to be extremely superficial if you think only a completely new look deserves to be a new generation name. That’s not how Apple thinks. If they like a look they keep it. They don’t change it for change’s sake.

Here is a reminder: iPhone 3G and 3GS as well as 4 and 4S looked exactly the same. I only dared to call them part of one generation because they really looked exactly the same. If the rumours are true the iPhone 5 will look somewhat similar but certainly not exactly the same as the 4/4S.

And sure, no numbers would also work, but if you want numbers 5 is the only way to do it and it honestly makes a ton of sense and is not the least bit confusing. Everyone will know what you are talking about, no one will be confused. It’s unique, it’s memorable, it even makes sense.

Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by arn on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @02:09PM (#4475714)
It will be less confusing as "iPhone 5". 5 comes after 4. Most people don't know what generation it is.
Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by MatthewPhillips on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @02:30PM (#4475830)
> 5 comes after 4.

Does 5 come after 4s?

Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by pooriaazimi on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @02:42PM (#4475900)
Yes, but only if you're a JavaScript nerd:

    > parseInt("4s") + 1

    5
(it was meant to be a feeble joke. I actually agree with you)
Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by danneu on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @02:47PM (#4475927)
Don't most languages parse strings like that?

Ruby:

    "4s".to_i + 1 
    #=> 5
Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by pooriaazimi on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @03:06PM (#4476021)
I suppose you're right.

I was so eager to bash JavaScript that I forgot about it. Come to think of it, I think even non-dynamic, traditional, old-school languages like C also parse string like this (`atoi("4s")`).

Re:Apple announces September 12 media event by arrrg on Tuesday September 04, 2012 @02:49PM (#4475942)
Sheesh. Sure. The S works like a modifier. 1, 1b, 1c, 2. Like that.