That's quite the selective memory you've got there.
- First gen. "1000 songs in your pocket." First music player to use Firewire (no USB 2.0 yet!). First HDD player to use 1.8" drives.
- Second gen. Touch replaces mechanical scroll wheel. Windows compatibility (MusicMatch).
- Third gen. Mechanical buttons entirely replaced with touch. USB syncing. iTunes Music Store. iTunes for Windows. First iPod to feature the dock connector. Full case redesign.
- Fourth gen. Return to mechanical controls with the click wheel. iPod Photo introduced, the first iPod that can output to an external display.
- Fifth gen. Photo merged into regular iPod. Video playback. Music videos and TV shows appear on the increasingly poorly named iTunes Music Store for the first time. Gapless playback. Games.
- Sixth generation. Aluminum case. Dramatically better battery life (36 hours vs. 8-12). Genius. Audio recording.
Maybe you could argue that the fourth and sixth generation iPods were just capacity bumps and screen overhauls, but many of these features are no less significant than the "processor upgrades" and "radio antenna type" that you cite for the iPhone.
Apple didn't dominate the portable music player space for a decade (>70% marketshare the entire time) by standing still. They also didn't have monotonically increasing revision numbers tacked onto the end.
Saying there were no substantial changes to the iPod because "it just plays music" is only slightly less absurd than saying there are no substantial changes to the iPhone because "it just makes calls."
And of course, I'm not including the best example of revisionless names, the iPod Touch! We all know it's a stripped-down iPhone, but it's always been called simply "the iPod Touch."
Anyway, I have a MINI. The Porsche is too expensive for me.
I was implying that there are many many products where the manufacturer changes the model and keeps the same name. I used the 911 because it's very recognizable name, but your Mini is using the same name as the one that was produced in 1961 and you definitely can't use the same accessories, not even the same gas.
but wait, I'm also going to argue the opposite right here in the same comment: Leica has been making the M cameras since 1954 and they use numbers, sometimes with suffixes just like the S in 4S (M3, M4, M4P, M5). they even went backwards with the M2 released after the M3, and they all use exactly the same lenses and accessories.
my point? it's an entirely pointless discussion trying to rationalize which is more correct or more wrong: companies have been doing both for decades and both have been successful.
And: pointless discussions are the only kind we have here. So why complain about it?
And color screen is an interface change, not a functional change, so it doesn't really fall into the set of things I was talking about earlier.