News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by TrackerFF on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @07:39AM (#44722029)
When you offer "unlimited", you're immediately exposing yourself to the 0.1% of userbase that will absolutely treat it is unlimited. Whale users/hoarders. This has been a known problem since the dawn of hosting...hell, it goes back to times before computers.

One thing I miss for the other users, i.e. the casual users that never use anywhere near of their quota, is rollover. If you haven't used your quota this month, the unused will roll over to the next month.

Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by thimabi on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @08:00AM (#44722209)
Things would be much easier if, instead of “unlimited”, companies simply offered great usage limits. Yes, hoarders would still exist, but their impact would be negligible.

Even better: provide a counter displaying both remaining usage available and the quota reset time.

But companies probably earn so much money from the vast majority of users that having good and clear limits would only empower them to actually benefit as much from the product as they can.

Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by vertoc on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @08:22AM (#44722429)
I think the hard part with these ai models is it’s kind of hard to figure out how many tokens you’re going to use, especially as a new user. 4,000 tokens sounds like a lot for instance, but is tiny
Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by fuzzzerd on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @10:46AM (#44724089)
While I don't disagree that determining usage is incredibly difficult, it doesn't take a genius to see that something sold "by the million" is something you can expect to to use a lot of.
Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by thimabi on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @12:55PM (#44725694)
If companies offered any sort of counter, users would quickly understand their usage patterns and adapt accordingly. But users are kept in the dark on purpose, often not knowing how many tokens they use, and sometimes not even knowing what are the token limits.
Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by jollyllama on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @08:46AM (#44722673)
It simply shouldn't be called unlimited, then.
Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by const_cast on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @02:30PM (#44726789)
This is the crux of the issue.

Every company wants the marketing of unlimited, but none of them want the accountability.

Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by ollybee on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @09:27AM (#44723086)
Two problem with offering usage limits is the real limit you could offer if all users hit it, is low. The users with usage far below the limits feel they are getting a bad deal, compared to if they can't see the limits and they don't hit them, they feel they have "unlimited!".
Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by Spooky23 on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @10:27AM (#44723826)
I disagree. People will always hoard a constrained resource. Things like phone service and AI tools find their value when people use them freely.

The AI models have a bunch of different consumption models aimed at different types of use. I work at a huge company, and we’re experimenting with different ways of using LLMs for users based on different compliance and business needs. The people using all you can eat products like NotebookLM, Gemini, ChatGPT use them much more on average and do more varied tasks. There is a significant gap between low/normal/high users.

People using an interface to a metered API, which offers a defined LLM experience consume fewer resources and perform more narrowly scoped tasks.

The cost is similar and satisfaction is about the same.

Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by OldfieldFund on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @12:00PM (#44724994)
An even more insidious method is selling "lifetime access," offering incredible over-the-top value, then exiting after 2 or 3 years when the momentum starts dropping. These are essentially rug pulls/exit scams.

There is no such thing as "unlimited" or "lifetime" unless it's self-hosted.

Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by SirFatty on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @08:06AM (#44722260)
Like the unlimited meal pass at Six Flags.. https://www.vice.com/en/article/meet-the-guy-whos-finessing-...

Or the American Airlines lifetime pass.. https://www.aerotime.aero/articles/american-airlines-unlimit...

Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @07:57AM (#44722174)
> 0.1% of userbase that will absolutely treat it is unlimited. Whale users/hoarders

This is somewhat a different issue that’s largely accepted by courts and society bar that one neighbour who is incensed they can’t run a rack off their home internet that was marketed unlimited.

Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by epistasis on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @07:57AM (#44722182)
I hit the limit with a single set of queries yesterday, the very very first time I ever clicked on that "Research" button. And it stopped me from using any of their services at all, without warning. I am a very light user of queries, less than one a day on the cheaper models.
Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by dcminter on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @07:48AM (#44722108)
One does find it occasionally. My mobile phone plan (in Sweden) currently says that I have 774G left of my 25G/month quota for example :)
Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by kqr on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @08:05AM (#44722256)
One might wonder why you pay for a plan with 25 GB/mo when you use so little that you have over 2.5 years of it saved!

I thought I had a low usage with my 1.5 years' worth saved. Only reason I paysfor that plan is anything lower and my provider does not offer rollover.

Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by ajsnigrutin on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @08:21AM (#44722415)
Sometimes these are the smallest usable packages.

Eg here in slovenia, if you want unlimited calls and texting, you get 150GB in your "package" for 9.99eur, but you somehow can't save that data for the next month.

https://www.hot.si/ponudba/paketi.html (not affiliated)

Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by dcminter on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @11:03AM (#44724288)
Because it's inexpensive and I'd rather pay marginally over the odds than ever have to think about it (I'm not even sure there was a cheaper plan).
Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by johnisgood on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @08:03AM (#44722240)
So it accumulates for you? That is nice. I wish my unused quota would go into the next month, but it resets. :(
Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by raverbashing on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @08:00AM (#44722206)
Still limited. But "unlimited" to most people

In the same way your next-door supermarket has effectively "infinite soup cans" for the needs of most people.

Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by wat10000 on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @08:40AM (#44722614)
Unlimited means for a flat rate. Pay per use/item, like at the supermarket, isn’t it.
Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by raverbashing on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @12:58PM (#44725741)
Still, you can't get "unlimited" soup cans from your next door supermarket even paying
Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by wat10000 on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @05:12PM (#44728313)
Which is why they don’t sell it as “unlimited.” The gripe isn’t that there are limits, it’s that it’s sold as “unlimited” but there are limits.
Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by raverbashing on Wednesday July 30, 2025 @04:50AM (#44732095)
Which to any reasonable person (and it's on the fine print) should mean reasonable limits

But I guess some people do really need "Eggs: contain eggs" in their egg carton otherwise they will throw a legal fit

Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by wat10000 on Wednesday July 30, 2025 @07:05PM (#44740574)
Right, it’s our fault for not understanding their lies.
Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by blitzar on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @08:57AM (#44722787)
Data limits are easier to keep "unlimited" by slowing the speed, which was already finite, to barely servicable levels. If it is clearly laid out this seems a reasonable solution.
Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by dcminter on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @11:05AM (#44724314)
If they've ever done that then I've never noticed it - and mine doesn't claim to be unlimited.
Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by Philpax on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @09:14AM (#44722933)
Thank you, Hallon - I've been on the same plan for the last four years and I don't think I've ever checked my data quota :)
Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by alt227 on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @08:24AM (#44722449)
I havent seen the word unlimited used in advertising without an asterisk for a long long time.
Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by CraigRood on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @08:34AM (#44722535)
Thing is, even with users that don't use the quota, these AI companies are still losing money. This isn't a case of the small users paying for large. The true costs of AI are yet to unravel.
Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by sjsdaiuasgdia on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @08:40AM (#44722609)
Exactly. "Unlimited" is practically guaranteed to become a lie for any service that provides some amount of utility and lasts long enough to accumulate a significant number of users.

Nothing in our world is truly unlimited. Digital services and assets have different costs than their physical counterparts, but that just means different limits, not a lack of them. Electrical supply, compute capacity, and storage are all physical things with real world limits to how much they can do.

These realities eventually manifest when someone tries to build an "unlimited" service on top of limited components, similar to how you can't build a service with 99.999% reliability when it has a critical piece that can only get to 99.9%.

Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by windward on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @08:45AM (#44722667)
>This has been a known problem since the dawn of hosting...hell, it goes back to times before computers.

yep

>Adverse selection has been discussed for life insurance since the 1860s,[3] and the phrase has been used since the 1870s.[4]

Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by Aurornis on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @09:23AM (#44723044)
You’re fully right and I’ve seen it play out at a startup. It’s unreal to see how that 0.1% userbase can find insane ways to use your service. For some people, it becomes a game to discover your rate limits and develop a service that goes just under the rate limit 24/7

In some cases, people discover creative ways to resell the service. Anthropic mentioned they suspect this was happening.

The weirdest part about this whole internet uproar, though, is that Anthropic never offered unlimited usage. It was always advertised as higher limits.

Yet all the comment threads about it are convinced it was unlimited and now it’s not. It’s weird how the internet will wrap a narrative around a story like this.

Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by tsoukase on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @09:34AM (#44723179)
All-you-can-eat allowance at restaurans comes to mind
Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by bayindirh on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @09:40AM (#44723258)
I went to a particular sports bar back in the day. They have "all you can eat ribs" plate. The first comes fully treated with sauce and is very, very delicious.

When you order the second plate, it comes without the sauce and it tastes flatter. You're filled at this point and you can't order the third.

Very creative and fun if you ask me. I was prepared for this though, because the people we went together said how it's going to go, exactly.

Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by tsoukase on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @03:07PM (#44727119)
I was thinking about self serviced "buffet", where the lowest quality starts from then first plate.
Re:Stop selling “unlimited”, when you mean “until we change ... by anthonypasq on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @10:29AM (#44723858)
in cursor you can just set a monthly spend limit at api pricing. seems like what you are looking for