Re:Show HN: Use Their ID – Use Your Local UK MP's ID for the...
by toast0 on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @12:38AM
(#44719125)
> why not use a basic regex on the FE and an OTP which gets sent to the provided address?
I can't prove I control an email in order to use your wifi, if I can't use your wifi.
Re:Show HN: Use Their ID – Use Your Local UK MP's ID for the...
by ethagnawl on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @07:20AM
(#44721854)
That's a great point. I guess I'm so conditioned to various 2FA methods that I take some amount of access (i.e. mobile) for granted.
Re:Show HN: Use Their ID – Use Your Local UK MP's ID for the...
by swores on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @08:30AM
(#44722501)
Some wifi networks give you a limited number of minutes online during which you need to click a verification link they've emailed you in order to not get cut off.
Re:Show HN: Use Their ID – Use Your Local UK MP's ID for the...
by codedokode on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @02:56AM
(#44719973)
They can connect to a mail server and pretend that they are going to send a message and the server would reject the invalid recipient email.
Re:Show HN: Use Their ID – Use Your Local UK MP's ID for the...
by ethagnawl on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @07:24AM
(#44721892)
I had no idea this was possible. This sounds almost like an HTTP OPTION request. I'd love to find an example of client code which does this.
Re:Show HN: Use Their ID – Use Your Local UK MP's ID for the...
by brk on Tuesday July 29, 2025 @09:25AM
(#44723059)
You're looking for the SMTP VRFY and EXPN commands. However implementation is very hit-or-miss. In the good ole' days of the internet, VRFY was widely implemented. Then spammers realized they could connect to a mailserver and do a form of a VRFY dictionary attack to find valid addresses, so it stopped being supported.
It's obvious that they care (to some extent) that they're getting valid emails, so why not use a basic regex on the FE and an OTP which gets sent to the provided address?