Open source packages are the biggest productivity boost of my entire career, at no point did I think "wow, I wish these didn't exist, they're a threat to my livelihood".
What if that happened across the entire industry overnight?
What if every single time you sat down to write a piece of software, someone immediately produced the Open Source version of it?
That's what people are hoping AI is going to do to us
Why would I support that
WordPress did that to the commercial CMS industry. Linux did that to the commercial Unix industry (RIP, Sun Microsystems).
> That's what people are hoping AI is going to do to us
I think those people are full of crap, and I mostly ignore them.
Could it be there'd be less jobs because it would have prevented some businesses to bootstrap and stay afloat? That's also possible.
And this is really the thing with AI, some think it'll grow the pie, therefore increasing the demand for developers. Some think it'll just shrink the size of the piece of pie that's for developers.
If we could predict the former, and be sure of it, I doubt anyone would be against AI.
Aside that though, as a developer, you are also concerned with, is this actually making my job better/faster/more-fun. Or am I just forced into an annoying process of using a tool that doesn't help and will just cause more problems I'll have to deal with.
Prior to open source software development was awful. We spent all of our time re-inventing wheels - or, if we were lucky, licensing expensive badly shaped wheels from vendors and crossing our fingers that they would work (because we couldn't fix them if they didn't).
As a result, very few companies developed software - it's not worth hiring a software engineer if it takes them six months to deliver that initial login screen.
Open source started taking off about 25 years ago, and software productivity skyrocketed. The result was a multi-decade boom in jobs and salaries for us software engineers.
Still do.
At least back then it probably felt more like we were doing something new because 8000 versions of the same thing wasn't right at your fingertips.
I have no leg to stand on, I owe my career to proprietary software building on top of open source code, but lately I have been wondering what that alternate world would look like. As it stands, if you want to write software and sell it, you've got at most a couple of months before someone open sources a clone of your project. Sure, there's no guarantee it'll be anywhere near as good. Photoshop is still king. But one can't help but wonder what the proprietary IBM world would have been like.
Back then the answer was supposed to be OOP. With hindsight, the answer was open source - in particular robust library ecosystems like PyPI and NPM.
It looked more fun on paper, FWIW.
Open-source does replace entire companies, but typically with better products that other companies can build upon, and in the end, this expands the demand for software.
AI is expected to replace developers, and I believe that it will empower non-techies to develop highly-functional mockups, which will in turn increase the amount of (crappy) software on the market, which I believe will in turn increase the demand for people who can fix this software – if we multiply the number of apps by 1,000, even if only 1% of the apps need quality, this still means that we've increased the demand for software developers 10x.
So I actually think that, within a few years, AI will increase our job security as software developers. It's going to be a rocky few years, of course, but I think we'll be better off, at least until the rest of our dystopian timeline catches up.
Now, what I hate is the dishonesty of AI companies. I mean, as software developers, we strive on rigor: good documentation, compilers and JITs that speed up our code without changing its behavior, APIs and tools that work as claimed, etc. AI companies and their PR, on the other hand, peddle magic thinking and gaslighting. That's the exact opposite of rigor. And this keeps assaulting my sanity.
Should be looking for ways to work slower? I can go back to just one monitor.
If productivity gains mean that either me or a coworker is laid off, and my boss makes more money, why should I care about the that?
Having a job is not a favor that people with money are doing for employees, it is an exchange of services for money
I provide a service. So do most people. Anything that gives the people with money a way to avoid paying for my service is bad for most of us
"The tragedy is that although these groups of workers did suffer from the deployment of new technology, over time, the general population benefitted from cheaper clothes, lower prices and new jobs in other sectors of the economy."
Obviously, as a developer, I don't want to lose my career. But am I a hypocrite? Are you a hypocrite for buying anything that is now manufactured by automation, putting people out of jobs? I'd say yes.
Why should we be eager to find out that some new tech is going to undercut us and replace us, devaluing us even more than we already are?