Source: http://money.cnn.com/2011/07/28/news/economy/healthcare_spen...
We do gain some outcome advantage from earlier screening, in that it means we will catch some cancers early enough to treat that Europeans would miss, but the outcome differences aren't nearly as big as the 5 year survival stats lead some people to believe.
As far as seeing specialists goes, the US does do well, although I believe Germany and maybe Japan have us beat--showing that universal affordable coverage can be achieved without having to give up reasonable wait times to see specialists.
The thing that makes me sad about the US system is this. Take the top, say, 10 non-US systems. They have quite a diverse range of approaches, ranging from straight up socialized medicine to highly capitalistic market-based systems. All they have in common is that in most areas they have equal or better outcomes than the US, with universal or near universal coverage, for a lot less cost per patient or as a percent of GDP. Based on the evidence, it doesn't appear hard to design a good healthcare system for a first world country. Only the US seems to be able to botch this. WTF!?
* Cancer survival rates, because of the 5 year survival heuristic, capture people who's illness is detected early but isn't actually cured.
* Life expectancy captures the fact that people drive more and faster in the US, that the US has more violent crime, and that more people in the US kill themselves
Intuitively, "high cost" plus "shortest wait time to specialist" plus "problematic overprescription" (a problem common to all first-world health systems) plus "earliest cancer detection" just doesn't add up to "worse outcomes than Europe".
But, it does make sense that despite the money we pay, our outcomes are not different enough to justify the expense.
I strongly agree: the way we finance health care in the US, primarily through a system of employer-provided health insurance policies that give way to a single-payer socialized system that kicks in right when patients are most engaged with the health care system, all without giving patients control or a stake in the cost of their care --- this system makes no sense.
And I can tell you that for my own part, even with health insurance, the deductible is so high that it might as well not exist as far as basic checkups and doctor visits go.
1 http://ucatlas.ucsc.edu/spend.php
2. http://blogs.ngm.com/blog_central/2009/12/the-cost-of-care.h...
3. http://www.economist.com/blogs/buttonwood/2011/03/health_cos...
We do spend a lot for health care in the US, and we probably aren't realizing comparable value, but it is also probably not true that the actual quality of care in the US lags that of Europe.
Say what you will about the worldwide quality of mental health care, but there's not a whole lot a good hospital can do once you've set out to harm yourself, and that one particular tragically underserved health problem is not what people are thinking about when they suggest "Americans pay more money to get less than what Europeans do". That last notion is dubious at best.
This is a view that's strongly distorted by the UK. It's seems to hold there, and the wait times sound terrible, but it's definitely not the case in the majority of countries, by a long shot. As far as I can tell from personal experience, wait times are not an issue in The Netherlands, Sweden, Germany, or France; outside of that I've never heard of really long waits in any country of Europe, with the exception of the UK.
The European systems are all different in sometimes surprising ways, throwing them together into one bucket is an incorrect generalization. E.g. the UK system with the NHS is entirely tax funded, where the Germany system has insurance paid 50/50 by employee and employer, and the Swiss system has 100% privately paid but mandatory and state regulated insurance.
These are really massively different systems, and the effects on e.g. waiting times are huge. They are all state regulated and sometimes state funded, but that's by far not the only interesting characteristic of medical systems.
I don't know what Germany's wait times are, but Germany isn't a pure single-payer system like France, the UK, and Canada; it's guaranteed-issue mandatory-coverage.
The only question is how the rate of growth will slow/stop.
In Norway it's like this: Senior citizen: 4,7% Employed: 7,8% Self-employed: 11%
Last time I checked we spent around 9% of GDP on healthcare.
(Edit from reading other comments: probably not charged in Denmark because of European health reciprocity, but they never verified this at the hospital).
If you're a software engineer or systems administrator or similar type of professional earning a fair living it's not at all uncommon to have completely free health insurance for yourself, and affordable options to cover your family. I haven't worked for a place with an individual premium in 5 years.
Again, not saying the system isn't broken, but rather that there's a reason all Americans aren't vocally supporting the ACA and the president: this is mostly a lower-middle-class-and-below problem
I agree with your point: the reason the country isn't completely behind health care reform is that they get it from their employer and don't understand how it works. Of course, they're also getting screwed financially in the process.
I'm self employed, and even if I go back to working for a larger company, I would prefer to continue to keep my private insurance. I have private homeowner's insurance. I have private car insurance. I have private life insurance. Why oh why do we demand/insist that employers provide health care, to the detriment of market forces favoring individual purchasing?
Conservatives in this country should be in an uproar that the 'free market' isn't allowed to run its course because of the combined interference of big business, big labor and big govt over the past several decades, but they're not.
Because unlike cars and homes you only have one life. If you let a profit seeking entity control and dictate what happens to your health, you might not have a chance to go back fix the problem by choosing a better one. You could be dead.
There was just recently a story on Reddit about someone who's relative a was killed by a driver and his dead relative' insurance company effectively provided council for the defendant. That's the kind of stuff you'd be dealing with. You health insurance company would be interested in killing you promptly as soon as you develop a chronic or expensive condition. And they'd all want to do it. All 1 of them after they merge into a giant conglomerate (since you know can't be messing with the free market and stuff, there will be nobody protecting against monopolies).
It's more broken if you're middle-class-or-below (as you mention) or an entrepreneur who isn't either early-20s-and-healthy or raking in huge piles of cash. The part that seems most out of keeping with the American ethos is how anti-entrepreneur it is: you get good collectivized coverage if you work for IBM or Microsoft or Google (because it's socialized across their employee base), but if you start your own company or are trying to buy insurance for a 10-person company's employees, well then you're screwed.
Not entirely a theoretical question, b/c one of my friends has a congenital heart defect, and is himself not 100% sure how his condition would impact a small company. They aren't allowed to inquire into such things when hiring, but could it possibly tank their group health-insurance plan, if 1 of [small-N] members had a major preexisting condition?
In the US, group health coverage is distinguished in part by not "qualifying" patients, so that latter example doesn't really come up. There are horror stories about companies being forced out of their insurance plans by prohibitive cost spikes after major medical events, but I don't have any of them ready to deploy on this thread.
LOL. Go to the emergency room now in the US, with a real emergency, wait for hours. After this is sorted? Wait for days, maybe?
Our health system is completely broken in every way, and building up more bureaucracy is just going to make it worse.
I am counting on hospital visits not even being an option in the future, in the US.
Americans are exceptionally good at everything the free market touches (consider the tech world). Medicine could, and should, be a lot like going to the vet. Extreme competence, speed, and low price. The difference? There honestly isn't that much of a difference, except veterinary practice is pretty much a free market.
By the way, I've personally been forced to undergo unreasonably waits at the ER (I was kicked out of the building by a security guard because I wouldn't take a seat or stand - I couldn't physically do either, and I went and laid down in a parking lot outside). I've also seen a loved one hurt--potentially very severely over what could have been the case, but who knows--by not getting competent attention during a stroke. And there is at least one other bad story I won't get into here.
By the way, I do think my stories are representative of a larger trend. The above-mentioned incidents occured in different hospitals mixed between the east and west coast. That still isn't enough to prove anything. But I'm hearing complaints from a lot of people. Also, if you talk to someone applying to med school, you'll see that the number of doctors is being artificially restricted.
The public discussion about healthcare is missing a huge component, which is: why is our healthcare so completely shoddy and incompetent today? What can we do to change that? And, why aren't there enough doctors? I'm talking totally independent of the _cost_, which admittedly is also a problem.
Yeah, and patients whose cures are more expensive than they can afford should be put down painlessly, eh?
There are some aspects of health care where free market mechanisms can improve efficiency, but efficiency is not by itself the ultimate goal a health care system should have.
Seriously, it's the most humane way to go.
In the meantime, I'll be thinking about going to India if I or loved ones need serious medical care.
Quite a few hospitals with ERs also have a 'urgent care' or 'express care' clinic attached which are quite effective as they can a lot of things a ER can do, and expedite transfer to the ER if can't be treated there.
I'm a researcher hired by a Danish university, which made for a fairly easy fast-track visa under the "researchers scheme" [1]. In fact the entire process was by mail and took one round-trip: I mailed my passport, offer letter, photos, and application to the NYC consultate, and they mailed back my passport with a visa pasted into it. Most professionals with an offer will also be able to get a visa; it's not nearly as restricted as getting U.S. visas is. If you have an offer that pays more than 375,000 DKK ($63,500), you qualify under the "pay limit scheme" for similarly preferential treatment [2]. Getting permanent residency depends on if you're an EU citizen. If yes, it's just a matter of remaining in the country as a legal resident for at least 5 uninterrupted years. If you're from outside the EU, there are more requirements [3], including that you must be employed for 3 of the 5, and must pass a language exam establishing basic competence in the language (which is unfortunately quite difficult to speak, though the grammar and vocabulary are not particularly difficult).
I must also give them kudos for giving all of this information in not only English, but straightforward, non-legalese English. Dealing with the Danish state is generally not a horrible experience so far, even for someone who speaks no Danish.
[1] http://www.nyidanmark.dk/en-us/coming_to_dk/work/researchers...
[2] http://www.nyidanmark.dk/en-us/coming_to_dk/work/pay-limit-s...
[3] http://www.nyidanmark.dk/en-us/coming_to_dk/permanent-reside...
Permanent residency removes any qualifying requirements, and gives the person the right to remain indefinitely in the country with full social rights (except voting), as if they were a citizen. That means, for example, that they would be eligible for the national healthcare system and state welfare system even if they found themselves long-term unemployed, which isn't normally the case for citizens of other EU countries.
Some more information here: http://www.eurofound.europa.eu/areas/industrialrelations/dic...
Inside of EU and Schengen you should be able to get a limited work permit. Then you are usually covered by local health care after a couple of months paying tax.
There are far more difficult places to gain citizenship (e.g. Liechtenstein, China).
Afaik, Denmark doesn't require the EHIC for acute emergency care. Anyone is eligible for unbilled emergency care, with some exceptions to combat medical tourism (if you're found to have traveled to Denmark for the specific purpose of entering an ER to treat a health condition). The EHIC qualifies you for some additional care, e.g. childbirth. This is actually a big current sore point in Danish politics, because many other EU countries don't extend a reciprocal courtesy.
Also, unless my memory is totally off, each country has to pay up for EHIC, depending on who used what, and visa versa. So the cost should be evened out.
Edit, because I cannot reply to you later down: I think we have a different view on what emergency medical care is. In most of the world you will get fixed up so that you are no longer in life threatening condition, this is the case in USA, Denmark and Norway. But afterwards you will have to pay, even in Denmark, as long as you're not apart of EU and have the European Health Insurance Card or a citizen of any of the Nordic countries, which has a special agreement.
[1] http://www.sos.dk/en/Corporate/OurNetwork/ForMedicalFaciliti...
In the UK you are not, purely because they don't do the accounting that way in the first place as it would cost a lot of extra money to keep track of billing when no-one is being individually billed, so there is no bill to bill.
Even Canada? Canada by its location would be at acute risk for medical tourism from the US, if it didn't bill for ER treatment. That problem isn't as big for Europe, Australia, etc.
I could almost imagine a financially manageable system where Canada gave free ER care to anyone except Americans, but that would produce obvious political problems.
My travel insurance reimbursed everything but you'd better have money on your credit card...
Before getting my work holiday visa, I had to prove that I had medical insurance covering me during my stay in Canada.
[edit: I'm from Belgium]
I do hope someday to move back to the USA (mix of language / "feels like home"), and am mildly hopeful that PPACA will make it feasible, by 2014, for an individual to buy private health insurance without worrying about preexisting conditions and rescissions and whatnot. But we'll see. For now, Danish is growing on me. :P
Incidentally, this kind of emergency care would be free even for a tourist in Denmark. Regular use of the national health system is only available to legal residents, but acute emergency care is considered a basic service not subject to billing, like police and fire response.