Re:Greg Knauss's 10-year-old son's $23,800 bug bite
by tptacek on Sunday September 02, 2012 @11:43AM
(#4467235)
By what measure do European countries have better health outcomes than the US? We're seeing in this thread why the most obvious metrics don't work well:
* Cancer survival rates, because of the 5 year survival heuristic, capture people who's illness is detected early but isn't actually cured.
* Life expectancy captures the fact that people drive more and faster in the US, that the US has more violent crime, and that more people in the US kill themselves
Intuitively, "high cost" plus "shortest wait time to specialist" plus "problematic overprescription" (a problem common to all first-world health systems) plus "earliest cancer detection" just doesn't add up to "worse outcomes than Europe".
But, it does make sense that despite the money we pay, our outcomes are not different enough to justify the expense.
I strongly agree: the way we finance health care in the US, primarily through a system of employer-provided health insurance policies that give way to a single-payer socialized system that kicks in right when patients are most engaged with the health care system, all without giving patients control or a stake in the cost of their care --- this system makes no sense.
* Cancer survival rates, because of the 5 year survival heuristic, capture people who's illness is detected early but isn't actually cured.
* Life expectancy captures the fact that people drive more and faster in the US, that the US has more violent crime, and that more people in the US kill themselves
Intuitively, "high cost" plus "shortest wait time to specialist" plus "problematic overprescription" (a problem common to all first-world health systems) plus "earliest cancer detection" just doesn't add up to "worse outcomes than Europe".
But, it does make sense that despite the money we pay, our outcomes are not different enough to justify the expense.
I strongly agree: the way we finance health care in the US, primarily through a system of employer-provided health insurance policies that give way to a single-payer socialized system that kicks in right when patients are most engaged with the health care system, all without giving patients control or a stake in the cost of their care --- this system makes no sense.