News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Self-Taught Engineers Often Outperform by FrustratedMonky on Friday July 18, 2025 @07:56AM (#44603708)
Maybe the perception is because of the larger percentage in each group.

Self Taught -> Already is curious, be default, so 99%-100% are curious. Just by the nature of going out of the way to learn something.

Educated -> Also has a curious % in the group, but also has the large group of complacent "i heard software makes money so i'm hear to learn it, but i don't know what i'm doing". So when you do find complacent, they mostly came from the educated path.

Re:Self-Taught Engineers Often Outperform by bayindirh on Friday July 18, 2025 @08:44AM (#44604089)
That's my experience as well. People came to CS because they love computers and want to learn how they work were so different than "I just want a job which makes money" people in every way even in the university years.

Curious people got high on the caffeine and code, and the other group just got high.

Re:Self-Taught Engineers Often Outperform by aatd86 on Friday July 18, 2025 @11:37AM (#44605923)
All I know is that if my coding ability had been measured through mandatory assignments that I would be force-fed without any immediate need, I would have been disgusted.

"Locking-in" on some esoteric topics just because one wants to is probably the best way to improve in my opinion.

On the other hand I have been through a pretty generalist undergrad education in engineering and it helped in acquiring general math, physics, chemistry knowledge.

Re:Self-Taught Engineers Often Outperform by bayindirh on Friday July 18, 2025 @04:20PM (#44609354)
I also went through a very generalist CS course, that we call Computer Engineering, which covered from hardware to software plus math, physics, chemistry.

I was already a nerd when I was attending the university. My chance was my instructors and professors let me roam free and convert every assignment to a rabbit hole. Poisoned by demoscene earlier, I was already an elegance/performance freak before even I got graduated, and this made me dive into unknown territory head-on instead of being afraid of it.

I have written a compression algorithm from scratch for graduation, then written a multi-agent trading system for M.Sc. project. For Ph.D. I have written a BEM based material simulation which was able to saturate the system very effectively, reaching practical IPC limits of the processors it ran on.

Re:Self-Taught Engineers Often Outperform by Nicook on Friday July 18, 2025 @09:51AM (#44604645)
not all self taught are curious, at least recent batches.
Re:Self-Taught Engineers Often Outperform by SecretDreams on Friday July 18, 2025 @05:27PM (#44610027)
Ya, agreed. I even tried to allude to as much.
Re:Self-Taught Engineers Often Outperform by michaelcampbell on Saturday July 19, 2025 @12:46PM (#44617051)
This goes both ways. I think the vast majority of my colleagues who got into CS later post-college did it because they needed a job, and that's where jobs were.

> Self Taught -> Already is curious, be default, so 99%-100% are curious.

There is some of this but IME that % is half your estimate, if not lower.

It could be different in today's market because CS IS NOT where a lot of jobs are, and my observations are based on when it was very very hot, so there's that.

But, no matter what you or I say anecdata is not data, but in my 30+ years of doing this, I find these broad generalizations mostly wrong.