News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by elric on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:02AM (#44592359)
I was briefly hopeful that we'd see meaningful copyright reform in the EU back when the Pirate Party had its moment in the spotlight. But nothing happened.

Now LLMs are stealing everyone's data, claiming be "fair use", getting away scot free, while irrelevant YouTubers are facing threats to be jailed over nothing whatsoever.

Make it make sense.

Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by meowface on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:03AM (#44592369)
I am consistent on this one, personally. Let LLMs train on anything and let YouTubers do things like this one. It's all fine to me.
Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by drweevil on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:54AM (#44592833)
Consistency would be welcome indeed. We have courts saying it's fair use to do this at scale to train LLMs, but minor violations like this trigger man-years of investigations and threats of imprisonment. The contradiction is grating. This circle can be squared only by admitting that there is one law for the wealthy and powerful, and another for the rest of us.
Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by yorwba on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:30AM (#44593196)
The jurisdiction is different. The alleged offense is different. The stage of legal proceedings is different.

There's no contradiction between an American court finding that using legally acquired copies of copyrighted material for AI training constitutes fair use, and Italian police launching an investigation because they suspect someone might be selling illegal copies of copyrighted material.

Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by navane on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:58AM (#44594134)
No one is claiming that the law is wrongly interpreted. We're saying that the law is wrong.

How is it legal to generate the content of that YouTube with genAI but not to actually tape it with real people. Why does an AI have more rights than this YouTuber.

Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by brookst on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:58AM (#44593506)
Consistency is the hobgoblin.

If the law were truly consistent, surgeons would go to jail for cutting people with knives.

As soon as you recognize that context should matter in law, consistency is no longer possible.

I’m not defending big companies pirating books or saying YouTubers should go to jail, I’m just saying there are material differences in context that make it juvenile to demand perfect consistency.

Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by HPsquared on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:13AM (#44592440)
Sovereign is he who makes the exception.
Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by clarionbell on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:52AM (#44592806)
I haven't heard Carl Schmitt doctrine in long time. I hope it doesn't become as prominent as it once was.
Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by Sander_Marechal on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:18AM (#44592477)
The pirate party is a single issue party about abolishing copyright and having no plan for what to do next. I'm not surprised it didn't go anywhere.
Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by fulafel on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:48AM (#44593396)
The way single issue parties normally affect policy is that getting a seat signals the other parties to take the issue more seriously (eg in this case balance between interests of copyright holders vs interests of the public), so the lack of plan wouldn't normally yet mean a failure.
Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by pjc50 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:32AM (#44592584)
> Make it make sense.

This is easy: law is about power and money. LLM training companies represent an even bigger concentration of money than the IP enforcers, so they can pirate all the books in the world without consequence, while the most onerous consequences are reserved for the most trivial guys.

Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by rvnx on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:54AM (#44592825)
Law is not fair. The law is the reflection of power relations.
Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by atq2119 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @11:57AM (#44594763)
Let's not give up just like that.

The rule of law is one of the greatest achievements of western society and a major reason for the west's global dominance.

True, it was always imperfect due to the realpolitik of power. But that doesn't change the fact that the very idea of rule of law is in opposition to rule of power.

Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by Tadpole9181 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @01:12PM (#44595596)
Outside of mass violence against the political class or praying they suddenly start listening to us, what exactly is there to do?
Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by anon191928 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:15AM (#44593047)
Property Laws usually applies to weak in power. Courts teach to masses to show how they lack true power and wealth. It's for show
Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by A_D_E_P_T on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:37AM (#44593262)
Natural Law is fair by definition. It is merely a reflection of ancient ethical norms.

Positive Law -- the laws set down by kings and legislatures -- is much less fair, but sometimes, however rarely, it tries to embody a codification of the Natural Law.

The way the Positive Law is enforced and prosecuted is an utter disaster. In civil courts, justice is bought and sold as a rule; fairness (and even adjudication itself!) is an exception. It's so bad, so transparently twisted, that I think it's fair to say that humans in general have shown that they cannot be trusted with the administration of things such as civil laws. Too corruptible.

Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by ykonstant on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:56AM (#44593484)
>Natural Law is fair by definition. It is merely a reflection of ancient ethical norms.

There is no such thing.

Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by A_D_E_P_T on Thursday July 17, 2025 @07:10PM (#44599327)
Serious questions, then:

Why is slavery wrong? Does human life have no innate (non-relative, not bestowed) dignity, in your view?

When judges refer (as they frequently do) to uncodified notions of "fair play" or "good faith and fair dealing," what are they basing those notions on? Is it not a continuation of the ancient Natural Law inclination towards promise-keeping, reflected in many human societies as the oath-breaking taboo?

Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by immibis on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:47AM (#44593387)
Natural Law isn't real, and won't hurt you - it's just one particular sect's form of copium.
Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by ohman876 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @11:55AM (#44594734)
You obviously are against that 'one sect', but natural law IS the thing. This is what most people consider to be the norm that governs how we behave. It's not written down, it's what you know is right or wrong. Let me give you some examples:

- Raping woman on the street - wrong

- Giving starving person some food - good

- Stealing from your employer - wrong (unless you are not paid or cheated)

- Killing random person - wrong

- Caring for your spause and children - good

and the list goes on

And the general rule, written down by 'that sect' in their book is 'love your neighbor as you love yourself', you should prefer to live among people who really apply this in their life, whenever you share their beliefs or not, because it's so much easier to live among such people than to live among selfish people who will not hesitate to harm you if only their actions go unpunished.

Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by const_cast on Thursday July 17, 2025 @03:00PM (#44596862)
> love your neighbor as you love yourself

This is just communism. If everyone did this, you would have a community-based economy and society. Communism.

The sheer idea of competition is antithetical to this world view. Because you would never compete against yourself - but you MUST compete against your neighbors. You would never advocate against yourself, either.

Look, it's a nice idea, everyone hold hands and sing Kumbaya. But it's not a Christian thing, Marx figured this out much more concretely. Like, he thought about the actual economic and political consequences of it.

And, I don't know, maybe it could work. But I think it's important we're all on the same page about what we're asking for.

Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by ohman876 on Thursday July 17, 2025 @03:47PM (#44597390)
Treat others the way you want to be treated. Even when competing you should not cheat, lie, steal or otherwise commit wrong-doing.
Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by const_cast on Thursday July 17, 2025 @04:04PM (#44597573)
Competing against someone means advocating for yourself instead of them.

Nobody would ever advocate against themselves - that's self-destructive. So, following the golden rule, competition is immoral. You shouldn't advocate against others, because you wouldn't do it to yourself.

More concretely, when you compete you are trying to take money away from other people and give it to yourself. Right? Because a customer could go to them - but you want the customer to go to you. So you get 5 bucks your competitor wouldn't have.

What we're noticing here is one of two things: either the golden rule is not at all a rule, and we have to make exceptions, or capitalism at a conceptual level is immoral.

One of these two has to be true, no way around it. Personally, I suspect Jesus would never allow capitalism. He would say everyone should share, so everyone can be prosperous.

Again... sounds like communism to me.

Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by anon_e-moose on Friday July 18, 2025 @03:48AM (#44602278)
If your competitor is lazy and grows to accept more money for less quality that is immoral. The moral thing to do is to compete against that company so that you provide better products and services for lower cost. That is the moral thing. Communism is neither here nor there, it's a completely different thing. Happy now?
Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by const_cast on Friday July 18, 2025 @11:37PM (#44612373)
Of course I'm not happy, because you're wrong.

The Bible explicitly states that judgment is immoral, and is the sole duty of God. If someone is committing a sin, it is not your job to fix them of that sin - and actually by doing so, you yourself are sinning.

If your competitor is lazy, the moral choice is to do nothing, and let God handle it. You do not know what is or is not a sin, because you are not the arbiter of morality - God is. Casting judgement on your competitor is sinful.

Really, no matter how you cut it, I think it's obvious Jesus Christ was a communist. He would absolutely not be happy with capitalism. Are we helping other's out of the goodness of our heart? No. Are we giving to the community? No.

In an ideal world where everyone follows the golden rule, the only outcome could possibly be communism. And, there would never be any problems, ever. Because nobody would be greedy - there would be no grounds for capitalism to even form. A revolution could not occur.

Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by rvnx on Thursday July 17, 2025 @03:51PM (#44597440)
Doesn't sound like YCombinator's recipe for success
Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by anon_e-moose on Friday July 18, 2025 @03:46AM (#44602267)
That has nothing to do with communism, go educate yourself, and actually try
Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by immibis on Friday July 18, 2025 @05:49AM (#44602871)
In empirical reality, we observe that most people, especially successful people, talk about following these principles but do not follow them.
Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by VWWHFSfQ on Thursday July 17, 2025 @08:46AM (#44592749)
The Pirate Party lost their public support after the founder advocated for the legalization of child sexual abuse because (supposedly) without it there could never be any meaningful digital freedom.

Obviously that was a bridge too far for people, and they stopped supporting even the sensible reforms the party was advocating for.

Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by speeder on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:13AM (#44593686)
Risking a lot by commenting on this... but what he defended was that possession of images should not be illegal, only the act itself should be illegal.

He used as an example of how the law was bad, that if you witnessed someone doing the act, and filmed it to hand over as evidence to the police, you would end in jail too, something that is obviously unfair.

Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by xienze on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:14AM (#44593042)
> Now LLMs are stealing everyone's data, claiming be "fair use", getting away scot free, while irrelevant YouTubers are facing threats to be jailed over nothing whatsoever.

I’d like to point out that for decades the argument pro-piracy folks made was that you can’t “steal” software since it still remains. It’s only fair to apply that same standard to AI companies who are simply scraping data...

Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by slightwinder on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:40AM (#44593950)
Piracy is making a 1:1 copy, there is no own work involved. But AI-Companies usually do not steal data, they buy them and compile them, and the problem is about whether the compiled data are still the original or something new. Which is similar to how humans do not automatically steal content just because they read a book and take this as inspiration for their own book.

So the problem regarding AI is more nuanced and complicated than the plain copyright-question of piracy. It's more akin to cases of plagiarism, which go case by case.

Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by throwawayffffas on Thursday July 17, 2025 @11:28AM (#44594408)
> But AI-Companies usually do not steal data.

There at least two documented cases of the major AI companies downloading millions of books of torrents. Anthropic is in litigation about it right now, meta was in the news about it. I would be surprised if it's not all of them.

Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by slightwinder on Thursday July 17, 2025 @11:55AM (#44594742)
Hence, the "usually". Poisoning your sources with potentially illegally acquired content is a separate problem from the legal status of the compiled system's output. I mean, if you steal the book you use as an inspiration for your own book, would the author or bookseller of the stolen book then have any rights to your work? This is a fundamental problem, not one where the specific fails of companies matter.
Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by elric on Thursday July 17, 2025 @09:47AM (#44593376)
The difference is obviously one of intent. LLMs are not being trained for personal use, they're being trained to be sold to the masses.

Very few people download(ed?) movies or music with the intent to distribute it. They downloaded it because they wanted to consume the media.

Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by xienze on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:36AM (#44593913)
> LLMs are not being trained for personal use, they're being trained to be sold to the masses.

Come again? Deepseek and numerous other smaller models can be run locally, for free.

I think what’s really behind this attitude is that “information wants to be free” when I’m pirating IP from a big, faceless corporation. But when it’s _my_ IP being pirated, it’s theft.

Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by const_cast on Thursday July 17, 2025 @03:03PM (#44596899)
Yes, it's called power dynamics. You're weak and irrelevant, they're rich and powerful. When they do the same things you do, the consequences are different. I can make selfish decisions all day long and the blast radius is pretty small. When rich people make selfish decisions, or worse, when political leaders do, the entire economy suffers and in the worst cases millions of people can die.

In some developed nations, we're almost comically unaware of power dynamics, sometimes to the point of inverting power dynamics.

Consider a McDonald's employee versus a Police Officer. The McDonald's employee can make almost any mistake and it's not a big deal. Pickles on your burger when you didn't want pickles? Eh, you'll get over it.

When Police Officers make mistakes, innocent people die. Taxpayers pay out sometimes millions of dollars.

Based on that, you would expect the standard of behavior for Police Officers to be much higher than a McDonald's cashier. But no, we've inverted it.

If the Police Officer accidentally kills someone they shouldn't, they'll likely keep their job. If a McDonald's cashier's drawer comes up 1 dollar short, they're terminated immediately.

Oops. Messed that up, didn't we?

Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by 5ersi on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:51AM (#44594058)
LLMs are learning in a very similar way humans are learning. So if humans can read a text (or view a video), learn from it and then use the knowledge to produce something, so can LLMs?

Copyright laws have quite strict rules on what constitutes a copy, and this was tested in courts many times. This rules also apply to works produced by LLMs.

Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by raron on Thursday July 17, 2025 @12:27PM (#44595069)
Okay, but in that case humans should legally be able to pirate all the books, music and movies they can or are learning from.
Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by elric on Thursday July 17, 2025 @04:54PM (#44598096)
That's a load of hogwash. Humans are only allowed to learn from books they buy or loan from libraries. We can't download books en masse from the interwebz just because we want to learn something. We're also not allowed to read stuff on websites and then regurgitate it verbatim pretending we made it. We can't even make songs that are vaguely similar to songs thag other people have made, even if they've been dead for a good while.
Re:YouTuber faces jail time for showing off Android-based ga... by cookiengineer on Thursday July 17, 2025 @10:58AM (#44594131)
Dead internet theory confirmed.

Well, the Ministry of Truth is working on it, at least.