It does provide a nice discussion point.
Much longer. But the practical difficulties would appear right away, when the time "error" is still measured in seconds. As I said earlier, both sides of this issue have perfectly valid points to make.
Even to get 5 minutes out of sync, that's 300 years. A leap-hour would need thousands of years. I think it's a rather weak argument that we should worry about noon being "out of sync" for thousands of years in the future.
Not if you're on the open ocean and need to know where you are, as I was every day for four years during my around-the-world sail. In that case, "noon" had a very specific, and very important, meaning -- each second of clock error equals 1/4 nautical mile of position error (or 1,519 feet).
I emphasize that both sides of this issue have very reasonable arguments.
And actually, it can easily, very easily, be done by hand, even if we stopped adding leap seconds to UTC. Just keep a log of leap seconds and then apply them to your UTC clock.
Sticking to celestial bodies for time seems pointlessly complicated to satisfy a few edge cases that can be handled in better ways.
Yes, but by allowing our clocks to go out of sync with the natural time of noon, a relationship controlled by orbits rather than clocks, this proposal would prevent that. Over time noon (highest solar position in the local sky) would drift away from noon as given by a clock.
I especially like the part where this proposal's advocates dismiss those who use a sextant to locate themselves on the ocean. I personally required this clock consistency to navigate my boat during my around-the-world sail, after my hi-tech satellite receiver expired.
This is not to argue that there's only one good argument here -- both arguments are reasonable. Unfortunately, they differ in the most basic way.
If we stick to 86,400 seconds in a day and don't allow leap-seconds, eventually daylight will happen at midnight -- either that or we will require leap-hours or even leap-days (as happened in Europe during the transition from the Julian to the Gregorian calendars).
If we continue to allow leap-seconds, all sorts of chronological record-keeping will continue to be more complex than it needs to be.
As with all truly interesting problems, there's no easy answer.