Re:Why the U.S. Wants To End the Link Between Time and Sun
by MichaelGG on Wednesday August 29, 2012 @01:50PM
(#4450014)
Then keep solar time as a timezone and switch into that mode when you really need solar accuracy. This is a rather extreme edge case.
And actually, it can easily, very easily, be done by hand, even if we stopped adding leap seconds to UTC. Just keep a log of leap seconds and then apply them to your UTC clock.
Sticking to celestial bodies for time seems pointlessly complicated to satisfy a few edge cases that can be handled in better ways.
Not if you're on the open ocean and need to know where you are, as I was every day for four years during my around-the-world sail. In that case, "noon" had a very specific, and very important, meaning -- each second of clock error equals 1/4 nautical mile of position error (or 1,519 feet).
I emphasize that both sides of this issue have very reasonable arguments.